UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No F-2016-07743 Doc No 01792029 Date 5 apartm e'n Of State TELEGR 2 6 RELEASE IN PART as AM LIMITED OFFICIAL USE 5 9 PAGE 0 BANGKO H5767 P723522 BEST COPY 6 2 AVAILABLE ACTION 55-14 INFO OCT-GI IBIS 662685 APR 72 Fm BANGKOK TO NASHDC 2923 OFFICIAL USE BANGKOK 5767 3 a a TRAISE CLASSIFICATION T0 LIMITED OFFICIAL USE PER PETERSON USOH PENGKUK CHANNEL EJHJI STAIEHENT OF T0 THF BDMBIKG 0F HAIPHONG IF THIS CABLE TRANSMITS A DISSENTING VIEW SUBMITTED BYI BB 2 WE THE ABOVE-MENTIONED UNITED STATES FOREIGN SERVICE-RESERVE SERVING RITR THE AGENCY FOR INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT IUSONT IN THAILAND HEREIN FORMALLY REGISTER OUR TO THE ACTION TAKEN BY THE UNITED STATES Al qT THE REFURLIC OF HAVE CHOSEN THIS HENTHOO T0 COMMUNICATE OUR DISAPPROVAL- a IT REPRESENTS THE SOLE OFFICIALLY SANCTIONEO FORUM FOR SERVIFE EMPLOYEES TO EXPRESS THEIR DISSENT ANO BECAUSE HE ANY UNRESTRAINEOJ PUBLIC CWITICISM ON OUR PART EITHER 01 THROUGH THE MEDIA AS SERVING N0 USEFUL PURPOSE ARGUMENT FOR OR AGAINST THE WAR HAVING an FIWCE SEEN MADEREGARD THE AIR ATTACKS AGAINST FUEL AND OTHER use 3' UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No F-2016-07743 Doc No C17980029 Date 07 31l2017 U S Department Of State Case NO F-2016-07743 Doc No 017980029 Date 07 31 2017 Department of State TELEGRAM LIMITED OFFICIAL USE I I --n6l PAGE #2 BANOKO @5767 2723522 FACILITIES AT HAIPHONG AND THE NASSING-OF CONSIDERABLE AIR AND SEA FORCES IN THE AREA To FORESTALL FURTHER THRUSTS IN THE SOUTH As A BREACH SPIRIT-IF NOT THE LETTER OF STATED To DISENGAGE FROH THE AND 55 AN ILL-TIHEDI ENTIRELY IDEFENSIBLE D OOSTILITIES NHETHER INITIATEO As A PRECAUTIONARY MEASURE T0 REMAINING UNITED STATES TROOPS IN SOUTH VIETNAM OR TO BUT AQDITIONAL TIME FOR THE RETALIATOQY RKIOS 0N 15-16 HERE UNWARRANTEO 15 MORE THEY ARE US SUBSTANTIAL SUPPORT HITHIM THE-T INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY AS wr-L AS AT ANO RUN THE VERY REAL RISK 0F PRDVOKING COUNTRIES TILL MOH HAVE LIMITED THEMSELVES T0 MATERIAL SUPPORT OF THE I Hg 00 NOT CONSIDER THE RISK OF ANY OF THESE ALTERNATIVE OUTCOMES THE RELIEF THE UNITED STATES IS LIKELY To ACHIEVE FOR FDUTH VIETNAM BY ITS ACTIONS FURTHERMORE wE DEPLORE THE F ILlpg CJNSIDER OTHER OPTIONS WHICH THIS ACTION OTHER NATIONS OF THE WORLD HILL HERELY FIND RENEWED JUOIIFICATION OF THEIR VIEW THAT THE 0 5 INTEREST IN RORLO AFFAIRS IS PRINARILV IN MILITARY TERMS AND THAT HE ARE IN MILITARY DORINANCE NHILE OISAPPROVING OF UNITED STATES or HE TN NO HAY CONOONE THE RECENT moves OF THE NORTH VIETNAHESE TO ESTABLISH ITS DOMINANCE OVER THE guuTH THROUGH FORGE or ARMS RATHER NE FEEL AND WHOLE HEARTEOLY DNOORSE THE COURSE OF THE ADMINISTRATION EMBARKED ODOR IN THE T963 NITHORAHAL NE APPEAL TO THE PRESIDENT To ADHERE TO AT ALL COSTS- TRIUMPH AT THIS JUNCTURE IS HELL BEYOND THE GRASP STATES BUT IS IS NOT TOO LATE T0 SALVAGE PART OF THE NATIONAL Ppagwla ME HAVE SACRIFICFO TN VIETNAM OVER THE LAST ULTIMATELY AS THE 0 3- HAS OFTEN DECLARED SINCE 1968 SOUTH VIETNAM Aug RESRONSISILITY FOR ITS NATIONAL Hansg OUR GOVERNMENT IS Mow PREPARED TO PUT ITS CONFIDENCE IN TO THE TFST EVEN RISKING ITS FAILUREI U93 3 MILL REMAIN DIRECT AND 0UP COMMITMENT OPEN-ENDED a -Iqq 3 NHICH ARE ATTRACTIVE PROSPECTS Era HOPE THAT THE NIXON OOCTRINE REPRESENTS A SinceRE u AI NEE POLICY OPTIONS FOR THE 1979's AND To LEAVE LIMITED OFFICIAL USE I UNCLASSIFIED U S Department Of State Case NO F-2016-07743 Doc NO 017980029 Date 07l3112017 UNCLASSIFIED US Department of State Case No Doc No 017980029 Date 07 31 2017 Department of State LIHITED OFFICIAL PAGE 93 BANGKO @5767 2783522 THE NARRONI MILITARY DOHINATED OPTIONS NHICH HERE CONSIDERED THE ONLY VALIO ONES DURING THE 1966'80 IF NEH OPTIONS ARE TO CONSIDERED HE CONSIDER IT ESSENTIAL THAT HE NOT ALLOW OURSELVES TO BE TEMPTEO TO USE THE OLD AND EASILY AVAILABLE NE 010 IN THE BOHBINGI UNTIL WE HAVE EXHAUSTFD ALL MEANS uw ew LIMITED USE I UNCLASSIFIED US Department of State Case No Doc No 017980029 Date 07I31l2017 UNCLASSIFIED U S De-artmegtpf State Case Nol Doch C179SO0S4 Date 07 31 2017Hui 1 - 3 5 It - - a '5 W's I I- s iuwc 'IE i'iuhE f 1 a NewAW- 32 2866682 APR 72 063 265 FM SECSTATE HASHDC To AMEMBASSY BANGKOK - IRELEASEHRPARTBE use STATE 973434 0155 HT - I 3 USOH BANGKOK AND I FROM DI HECTOR REF 5757 I WHIs HILL RECEIPT - MESSAGE CONTAINED IN BANGKOK 5767 FTJEESTEIS THis RECEIVE NET DISTRIBUTION or TELEGRAHQHASRBEENR SECRETARY SEGRETK SECRETNRT ST AND THETCHAIRMAN GFETHE Fd 1 6'33 21-32 4 131333454 - - I Rsia'c- 53 j a i il'w 32 - 54 1 UNCLASSIFIED US Department of State Case No F-2016-07743 Doc No 017980034 Date 07 31 2017