r71 ugh 10 U S C 1301 sateen moraine aih - The following is a brief overview of our initial operational assessment for Operation GLOWING The overall operational assessment framework consists of the task accomplishment framework for evaluating how well we're executing the operation and the operational effectiveness framework that will assess how well the operation is achieving the intended effects The focus this morning is our assessment of task accomplishment thus far I will not be briefing the operational effectiveness portion of the framework because we are still collecting data and intelligence reflections The framework is broken down by phase from the CONOP with supporting measures of performance and indicators Actual numerical data for each indicator is shown in blue After each indicator description are the Coalition partners represented in the data The stop light circle next to each indicator assesses that particular measure The gray circles represent indicators that are not important for assessing task accomplishment but still contribute to the understanding of Coalition activities The full legend is shown on the bottom left of the slide Sec 1 4iai EH MEL Overall we assess the task execution of 065 as green or successful All evaluated indicators are green except for which was assessed as amber The goal in the CONOP for that task was to be completed however avataii tha was achieved - had no negative impact an the mission- U Sir I ll give you a few moments to look at the U Next slide on Sec 1 4 cl W era the The breakdown of the results is shown in the pie chart on the right - demonstrating a high success rate ISAISWREL We also observed very effective coordination between Coalition partners- In a number of cases W at least U Sir pending any questions this concludes my portion of the briefing Operational Assessment Framework Task Accomplishment OPERATION GLOWING 193 1 394 l-4 a Ed Legend Successful task accomplishment Successfulwith some limitations Unsuccessful Not evaluated Version 1 1 as of 20161114 Operatlonal Assessment Framework Additional Discussion on Task Accomplishment - W Effective coordination with partners IS CLASSIFIED Sec- Version 1 1 as of 20161114 US YBERC OMWSA OPERA TION GL 0 WING OLLAB ORA TION - W-TERMS OF REFERENCE - U Operation Assessment - A continuous process that supports decision making by measuring the progress toward accomplishing a task creating a condition or achieving an objective JDN 1-15 - U Assessment A continuous process that measures the overall effectiveness of employing joint force capabilities during military operations JP 3-0 Determination of the progress toward accomplishing a task creating a condition or achieving an objective JP 3-0 - U Battle Damage Assessment - The estimate of damage composed of physical and functional damage assessment as well as target system assessment resulting from the application of lethal or nonlethal military force JP 3-0 U Measure of Performance MOP A criterion used to assess friendly actions that is tied to measuring task accomplishment JP 3-0 - U Measure of Effectiveness MOE A criterion used to assess changes in system behavior capability or operational environment that is tied to measuring the attainment of an end state achievement of an objective or creation of an effect JP 3-0 1 OPERATION GLOWING COLLABORATION - I -- OGS TASK ACCOMPLISHMENT ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK OPERATION GLOWING 112 111 5-22 111 2 -13 1 in - - Liam Successful task accomplishment Successful with some limitations Unsuccessful Not evaluated Version 1 1' as of 29151114 - USCYBER OPERA TION GLO WING COLLABORATION I - OGS OPERATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS FRAMEWORK OPERATION GLOWING I m LinaIv b-C'Olulru 20161114 This document is from the holdings of The National Security Archive Suite 701 Gelman Library The George Washington University 2130 H Street NW Washington D C 20037 Phone 202 994-7000 Fax 202 994-7005 nsarchiv@gwu edu