©05097682 EXERCISE ELIGIBLE RECEIVER 97—1 ER97—1 U ess Af Cal iga t a SZ FINAL OBSERVATION REPORT U cosooree2 rnam Reply ZIP Code reiteress MENORANDUM FOR Diisiburion Ls ited SUBJECT Final Observation Report for Ecercse ELIGIBLE RECEIVER 97—1 ER97—1 1 U The Final Observation Report for ERS7— s enclosed a Comments son wis should be addressed to the J7 6 R Sone ino gek sertion conceging ti eagre eme 3 0 Without th encore this lozeis UNCLASsirIED GeoneEr cose in Major General USA Director Operational Plans and Introperabilty Endsire «cnonse ‘ 05097682 ‘ «ent Taste of contents cHinetia Paok Letter of Transmitat 1 ‘Table of Contant and tof Efectve Pages m Executive Summary mer 1 — Genera exercise inrormamion anb assessment 11 u —— awareness ano unoenstanomia d mt — roucvissues tha iv — nereraaency coonpination issues mat V — reannio proceounes ano processes issues vi v — caissurs va vi nerenuiaenice surront issues via vin ueoa issues vina ix — eAroucy anp srmareoyissues Bei X useacomonservamions xi x — omerorsemvations xa xu — giesjmim mane xu cuossary aia rams Kil ‘Training Assorsment fo EAIS—1 ER#E—1 BNP7—1 xaeis antuix A — indiduat Ageney Everdse Objectiee An 8 — NEX Rar Bind fo 1 June 1997 ma «bazie cosnoreez menues rxecurive summary I OHilerExerstin Obfectves 3 0 Sueall Ausssment All ERS7—I objectives ware achieved A senior DOD offal sated hat ENOT1 was the most Interesing Informatie and challenging exercise we have sean n a fong long time 4 0 LITi—Trainlng ERP7—1 provide the opportunty for the Sta t train on 26 ‘Universal Jone Tak Lise UTI eats o eaten en one enie pne ApEH H pocco aon ram apa meni Ail and observations and data colecton PSne nm d lich nile do mar mal ink re tk mn ui in uncovered n ENOT is beyond th scope ofthis obsersiton repor However the Jone Sut Depury Directo for Oporationnformation Operations 139 wil bo denied as th oad ofice in developing this scion plan in coordination wih J and 4 «snamin cosoares2 »nreminn 4 U Resomementsion The DOD rolein th protection of ertealIntastrcture Inclucing the priats seceor should be determinet £ U Resommantations aogeige connate on te lesvor eaprnt hows sve peleas aliens a stone in «stone c05097682 suant n 0 Recommendations cosoaree2 § ¥ U Shaseratlon The Jone Staff understood it needed the DISA Liason Team but di nat know how to us it O Recommendation PISA and the nln Sait should onordinate the role and dues o lalion teams and arrange adeqvate worlapace ecure communications and procedures to exchange nformation — wusemimce Co5087682 «seense— a _ V Shanrvation Even when thay became aware that ttacls on nformation systams were being widely reportnd few organizations took additonal defense messures to procude Impact on thelr systems «scenes ©05097682 § — bh — U Recommendations «ssenge cosoores2 hamm be — U Qhaseration The NMIC experimented wth various nternal Intoience ——— Working Group eonfpurationsfor the 10 ers by U Qhnarvation The nclcotsuficient to dy 10 ncaigonce and nformation reporting hampered jolt taf efor t provide Incaligenc fusion daring a erie br _ U Recommendations bn U Obsanation During RFI the NHIC ound the exchange ofLNOs tobe Invaluable in Interpreting nformation foclitaing th exchange of information and providing technten advice «nenin Co5097682 nomen 9 0 Recommendations p conte cosoaree2 wuenes current f exencise mronmation ano assesswent «scene cosnoree2 scent 3 J Malor Exersse Oblaclis More f the major pariipan in ERI7—1 xsalihed their respective axarcse objective tee Annex A unde th overarching NIEX objective fed % ANERI7—1 objectives were aehiored A senior DOD offa stated that ERIT—1 ‘as the mont Incoresting Informatie and challenging axercin wo have seen ina long long __ Chapter I hrough dotnet assersment of actvties supporting the sbiectiot Debirrartcpant offeror mere not sumed by te joie Sorfsbnarraden tam Backgrnund Scroarie § y # § ©05097682 — «temien f —esense ©05097682 ° f «mente «uamiee ©05097682 b —oughie The Artie Threat c05097682 «snene § 0 NIEANET Wnchaifen 4 1 2 4 S1PRNET Ciwsiied The location ofthese Intruslons were Aniod to C m § x ¥ Fl 178 «Ghemim cosneresr qnvemonauy stang quamen coso97682 «zenen ——— charrent awanentss ano unpersranoine f Discussion s uence cosnaree2 frmmad L 0 — 0 Dicuaion 2 0 During the exercise sever riica intastructures wer aticiod paricarty power miter and BGD computer tems 9 W The DOD Critealintastucture Protection Working Group CWG is vorking the mmary aects of irenractirs protwston ‘The CiP ¥ is designed to comiderInsue across components that could he with the low or ruption ot spelt national and defers infastctirs tlecommunicatlot electrical power systers gas and ll storage and transport water supply matams banking and finance transportation amargency services and continuty of gorernment 8 W Intastractre protection Includes many goverment departments and agencies Itis not exctnvalya DOD rels d 0 USACOM through Forces Command hasa role n the protection of national intustructire ase @ U Seochiian Understanding various agency responses and capable and how to coordinate unt of frt is required i dealing with atials agains the @ ® Recommendations 6 2 The DOD rels n the protein oferieaintastrueture Including the privat sector should be determined U The rele ofindusty in derelopingIntastrueture protection t When T eeve doin ist ant arhses seas atic t bom siting unt sie nooo ano aneetrodain 0 A deciion ruppere ucture to provide unly of for in desing with infrastructure ateacla should be establited The Department of Defense and other Government agenclss should continue o conde exarcie in national infrstrctureproteczion 0 ¢ Since many ofthe stove recommendations are alruady under active consideration bythe Creal Inastructure Protection itmay be ime ove ‘Working Group CIPWG temay D — ision The exercise scenario included computer nebwork attacks CNAs aprinst DOD inormation aterm The receion o the plarsto the CMs demonsraced the need to rain users and administrators on how t protect thir sntems rom atack and inoepsoss thee aneul be rater he in comenta is invion or aste — ® fam vas able to mke or wilnorabiis that should have bean cored by other propor uninad won or apstem ndrminimentor Some examples include the use of simple pasword Improper contguration of azzten networks and operations security OPSEC o artedar system Intornt protocl P names ‘The Red Team found dee a w harn fund large amounts of unciasiied computer home «suanisn cosnoree2 a #33 nremonauey stan coso97682 —enense © cuarrenit —— @ rouerissues «cuaniies cosoores2 »onamiem f p ndation b U Obnsnation There were no polide or procedures that stablihed clear respond for directive muthorlyor control over numerous nodes af the Defonse Information nfrastructure O1 In ERP 1 here was nearly a lation witha commander in thief CING saring block it and the Global Operalon and Security Canter GOSC uring Jeave it open for a router nrpectad of being penetrated f E ® 6 mami cosoores2 hi Becommentacion — G _ 0 Ancommentarion —— anenek ©05097682 sence coarreniy mremacency coonpmation issues _ f j cusion «shani Setor hacen sessnds sin ermarcccacacunmmmmervarecncocnncuvecommmmmmmmmmusce cosneres2 my 3% D — C Dimuaien 0 Jurtdicton fo defending against nformation operations deponds f cnig pe «shemigh Srrrsnnnssordoadisisrrcoru unsere orccaccescasgoosern ens lyaranaccadcrasicaumnsucscanmmucs 05097682 § a Laval Reauraments Ausesnsss From perpectva the Deperement otiurtice CC ine provctnh opine array ir i goo oraionte communiadon Intrcepis nbninomat m miltary was airendy intercepting intoratonalMarline Sutaive NTAREAT conmuntmont rd tad ihe f it a 3 teobain @ _ 4 Sandinioas _ ® % B Tie Separiment of Beton and had captured Intviuats and equipment The 5GD en m a quick proiininay inallgunca ° «scam ©o5097682 «seense assesment of any captured materia DOJ and the DEST configuration were oriented toward evidence and prosecution no onscone 10 intligance 9 U The nodlnal modifcation to the DEST was inuficent to permit onal review ofthe is The ds had t be notlonly transported to Washington DC for anabiland evidence nande of the FBJ but did not say the DOD nead for on ight analyis for Inaligence purposes Local technic resources in Gam wore also inuficont thus £ % Qhsenatlon The Join Saflunderstood it needed the DISA Lisson‘ MARE c Jone ie the ‘Team but dd D — 0 Riisaaton 4 0 The Jone Stuf naw tht lter coordination wih or information «ramien ©co097682 «sorte from D13 war erical forthe exercise sconrlo that was presented to them % 8 U The DISA Linon Tear was requested and was usd asan axtatnlon athe Join Saf to got questions answered 0 0 The nam had no worcarea the Atvt day The folowing days the only nuthmation upport wa a personal computer wth word procening U Elocronic ntorchangs of information borwoen the team and DISA besdauazton wes nonenditan Only a secure telephone unit BT and a ficsiite machine Mutiple people rom th oin Sout and 4 tated the DISA knoe raps ae 0 00 thta trm injure sess 33 rott eta pas 0 There wa no priordeaton of cala relied t thir Importance 8 ganstiian_ Jelot Staff ne ofthe DISA Linton Team vas inoficent Aecommentations _ 5 DHA and the Jons Sat should onortinass the rete and duten of Uhison tames e Mn oneniaieaibeaine hould estat procedures to ensure talon teams wre not taget severe dine tor pours inommaadon nisi @eremonaucy samy «suonige Sram insersrmnreninrot6e a 0 dsusace ivaahson i666one nas anenonine 000 0000000 00 0 cosooree2 »mashioe — charreny — rannin rocebunes anp Processes issuts o menen cosoares2 «uonie «sneng« cosoeree2 «moni «senor cosoaree2 f onnemninn mochaniom ware miitog ——— for which answers were not clear included the folowing © ‘While the number of potential vilerable ystems and accounts rea to be algniAcant largo a iy dedicated adversary would have taken much more time a nian rope Miacicciimmmetant date npmnted would wiling to serie some reconnalisance capaliics teatuin woul The number of detections may aso be skawed a it on the low side because some h en ©0s097682 ‘ $ _ ° 3 © U Ohascvation Even when thy became aware that atiacla on Information stems wore king widely reported aw organizations took diana deferave measures to precude I Discusion a «mane cos097682 «soni f f mme % «schon cosostee2 emma — tt it Eustice G __ ¥ Resommentation —— «enehu® cososree2 t as © Risssaion «nemwens cos097682 — _ Ua H _ D — 0 Dliswaien 8 U Not all CERTs are manned for 2¢hour operations and were not manned 24 hours during the exercie ® U GETs may not have contingency plans to support 2¢hour x ® ‘There was o evidence of eourtination of defemive Information opattiofe ar faraiet Bete Rextinas Condon GereONS or Hiren Condiuoes rcons @ — Senchialan No approved 10 THREATCONe oxi «ener cos097682 «signin p $ — «semen ©os097682 E _ «nonem wl L220 cosoares2 —ssenge cuarteny ‘ carssues —uemie cosoeree2 «mami — J © mmrmntoninenontttor c meee rmrrsnmnititoons 00 000 nomos coso7682 —ssensr —suensr 05097682 «scents «szcnem 05097682 caarrenvi mevuisence supront ssues Dlsusion i Disston «enema cosoores2 —suense ® we may _ _ © 0 Observation The NHIC experimented wit various internal Intligence Working Grom asniqurationsor ge 10 oir ® ¥ monge cosoores2 —scense © Qbssnation During ERT7— the NHIC fund the exchange ofLNOs to be Amalia in ntorpreing Information fultaing the exchange of nformation and providing technical advice R ® § af Hiren stement ot intersgenty operntons requires futon atitoncr staring of eridea nformation ind Intligence A time honored comfortable and efbetiro method to ecordinate in erin has been the us ofLOs cenme ©05097682 —scenis © 0 DBA vas ty requers request essenialy cuttnto the avalable echniea stuf sed for event analyis 1 D % Some crits conter managors would suggest that the use ofLOs isa cick yee effectiv fi fo voids in nterngoney standing operating procedures SOPs Others ‘would muggostthat LNC are assent oven with tachnology and processor t Interpret and ¥ Agencia and sft have experienced dramatle downsizing in recent oravtabie ree Inpostat ‘ncthricat compatent mangonar has decreased t the same time agony spon raquo As the wise mini rectly inhe nner aqecty be endaganer needs t dendly those supporting sganci rom which is eots sndoonce The Ikon earns provide th ead agency a singl point af contac for support as wellas koe the supporting D — U Rlisumion gts 4 % 439 ensabtahd a watch call uled the Information Response Call CO U ren rmnmmtmmmctmpamed a MMi representair was aslgned to the $99 24 hour days however the ING wan not goning sonanie cos097682 ani 1 _ 0 Dlcauion 0 _ U Iesommentatin s «sGmen coso27682 © 10 «omensy nrevmonatey ceer stan — sconm cos097682 «ugmim charren vi reom issues k ___ imm — sense cosoares2 «scent anrermonauo stang ¢ »chomien cosostes2 «soni cuarrenix t rAPoticy aN strateoy issues e U Development of pres comments for the President vas discussed and asked t th ead agency ti Federal Berend o Inventzaton however the FB doce not % «snemion c0s097682 «scenir— @ Condision r and PSYOP proponent The themes for dexing withthe situation and future scions were not ning devaloped rapidly enough to keep up wih evens The exercise als demonstrated the need for balance among PA PSYOP and operations security OPSEC % cosoo7ee2 «scenes @wrevmionauey stang «songs 05097682 — «szoner cuarrenx useacom onservations dring p71 eonems ©05097682 f cussion onences an llllhsullll 2 ‘cosostee2 «sener C_ _ «szonie 05097682 «enener charrense oren osservations 1 0 Intdussion a 0 This exercis was th first serious cpber war for most in the Department of Defense andthe Govemment Interagency Communiy Unlike mort exarcses thatare ddaignd to train and alo t evaluate ntablihed lam poliles and procedures this exercise daary demonstrated that nformation Operatons G plan polices and procedures are sll vary much in the formativn stage or development 7 i U Asa reaily the most notable cbservaion from this exercso was that erals more quesions tha t anwered People know what needs to be dong however who or whit argentation should do It How do we detect ntradanst Who reports to wham and in what format isi reportedt The questions are many butto ensure the essence of the uncertainy s not lose n these pages the mort commonly observed uncertainties ar included n this chapter Some quertions reflect a lac f poly o ack of knowledge ofthe existing polly or the Implementing procedures and some questions rect contradletion within and among dien 2° W ibserattons Thi folowing ts is a summation of quertions and concerns aind by paricbants during Exercise ELIGIBLE RECEIVER 37 ERI7—1 Thi is does not attempt to b allnclusve but Inston a representative ofa week of lose cbservation For convenience the question colide with the chapters n ths report 0 Chapter Avarensse and Understanding 1 U I thore shortage of trained nformation operations 10 specitost C 0 I the peacetime manning level of1O spocalits sufficient to mont the demands for addidonal anais ison personnal and augmentess ina «rils operadlont G isthe patensa problem n manning the tachnicalskiled poston shortft or a ciel ae US And Co or Forces G for anbde sete ontact of in ni ood Bie decaite ar Pau How should be imroved in developing intastructure protector mponntins aniiprotniton m 1s there a decision support structure tht would ofettertin denting with intrevucture atiagat poverty ® Are there any required advanced training and education programs for system administrators within the Department of Dofanset h % Where are th 10 reporting requirements codtfect 10 U Should we not be able to find some rel 10 talent n he Nadlonal Guard Sts inn cosoarse2 —scense 12 U Hou do we advent people about and the need t senare GBD S0 thew to ve dvere eat meverreerinanrnenturs na we note intantand notsecidentat b 0 Chanter Polic lies Saw % coordinated atk the United Staest 43 i Aine Peice nnd eni oites be tamtrmes poss ins enforcement o the Natlnal Security Communion © © ChanterIV Inragency Goorsination foes Should we tal to industry Notte ® G Was me inormgenar on TPTF mile t digit whes may appuor to be an inigniicant problem for one Intrstructure eg electric power but may have substancial consequences when locked at rom the poipecive of another intastruczuret 4 0 Should tad agoncy Jurindleion depend onthe Identity and location ofthe perpstrators ate of nadon orend—ronl te of attacla ® U ii reasonable that lead agency responsllties would sh with a changing scenario and If s how do fusion cll respond proceduraly tothe shit — Deos the apartmant of Defense need to have a loser reatworld reiaionstip wih the Federal Bureau of Inresizaton FBD on sharing low tevelinruion C U What should be the werkingreltonstip in the Jolat Sta between 39 and the 10 Tasic Forest mw T ols attadcassessments to make tham usable product ina cti 10 U Should the designate lad ageney be provided wih standard guidatnes of minimum expectations and authorities to filia s potential directive offer over other mugy mltres cocartingt c —snenge cosoarsez «snense 4 U Chanter V Planning Procedures and Process isues 1 U Which ri command centers or agencies need to have 10 cris ction standing operating procedures SOPs for 101 3 0 Shen each node isa potentaitruson point should ll agencias be required t have an 10 Sot @ % What are the essential ament information required bya command canter daring an 10 eri 0 Shoue Consequence Harsgemmant CH Team be insomorated ito $0P since this funcion s often overlooked for 10 weapons of mass destruction and teroriont — _ amount to retey many moet 2 0 In the alerts or varnings when does the Government request Incuserial exoperation versus direct complancs fo Increased defensive measureat u in er who wouldbe lable for untoresean Hike ® # lge formats to whom and how froquent Ifa alt 12 U in the aler or warnings area of concern is ie procial tohave an on—th—ahef comprehensive plan for pull and Industrial alerts wih decals ofhow by whom to whom the legal asl existing Presiden authorides nuthorides to request revering requirements and report tor tac araipant — — 14 U Can stam and procedures deignod t detact intrusion have thir strstoide lowered to shwareintutons demonstrated In the exercise 5 ___ os umanitn Bonnes mmnsorrerretsnnnorre ron iremmmsesrcrsommnenmcnenerrann s cos097682 »idhithe Co n a a a nA TNH E incmmum Emerganty Response Teams CERTY to DISA 18 4 Do reporting procedures disiguih between normal and cris reporting 12 U Who wil coortnata the reviw of potential Service shortfts n w uper nnd 0B ale mitay varig ove amplate have 10 secion sering GNC $2 fot toon de we aet arti ele teat to GM os tasurs apubation s be © 0 ChantecVL Cdl sues anu oon 40 2 Con yo merarti the morte rent to ames bov vtoectte te re © 0 Chanter VIL Intllgsnce Support oues 0 @ What are the data filon requirements for 10 offensive and defomave gies on 8 00 Hon terastitet eontoa taran tia he h ervarmet wom wnemssn o o Co5097682 » Wegnins intalignce among the agencest ® U Wha isthe ustityof 29 which has approximately 5 percent of ts wok in compartmentd areas ponding 100 percent ots time during a cris soproqated rom the matn Crise Response Teamt 6 0 i shore any correlation between Defense Readiness Condiions DEFCON ant 10 Threat Conditons THREATCONh mess g 2 ay ts chore product ota Federal agoneyt £ ChaoteeVI Loga bnues 1 What diferent authorie are neaded to respond to threats in the continental United Stites CONUS versus ouside the continantl United States OCONUSI 2 U What authorides would be needed to employ 10 tool for defense or eounteratzidch CONUS er oconust G U What s the best national policy or docionmaking forum to Inidace wily planning and volvement in I0t 4 U What should be th Imis ofthe DOD rele n infastructure protection or 10 defense of the private sector and would any of these tations stand up inthe foc of he publ ousery that would company doruption ke those n the exerciet 0 Chapter IX PA Poly and trator hues 10 ene ® U Who i responible for coordinating a national press pilc or guidance in an 2 Who s responible for the pubile ats PA «® bu ecordinating porchologia — @ w Pareare he PA ofice crrcination procedures wihin the Department of Defense down to the ld command level and are they thorough enough o deal wih complex he ® 1 Why iit that in mat earces we camnot pot the PA office to play a reate rele and the topic is always nodlnalized away «lamin L cosoares2 «contr cureua cicspien manme TG serem The Oios Joie inion Esverst Tase v OMMETL was approved by Chairman ofthe font Gies of Sil Instnetion CJCSD 3800 02 join Training Mastr Pan 1 Octaber 1995 For Ecercon ELIGIBLE RECRVER #7—1 BAST— planners used the METI StrateleL ovel Matlnal Miliary Tasks SN to develop the axercio objectives Based ona rie ofthe asercin concept and CJCS—approved seonare supporting SNs were slactad as 2 TET Tealnlay ERY —1 provided the opportantrto he oin Seu t isin the j — on Riovet OGS Jel Filmion Emconl Taa OMT whiot wore roid from te Univeral o s ie — — r a 3 St 2 Desalon Steatagl Intllsence Survellance and Recornaiizance To produce the intligence required by strategie comsement fr formulating rationatlevel pig nernty and matty lave and operators The straits ntablgnnce ask plies nrons the ringe ofrnlitary operations incluting miltary operators other than war inctudes 8 @ wd Eiko sree 4 0 M L 4M 2 1 Clos Information on Sratgle Sinton Worldwide Informaton and daa from al source on the siategl sation Aross o interest include acti and atuadons hat could Impact US naslonl securty nturents and objectives Iinfmatin rnaigw mnwniale mvoge men ifone emg hase or enemys ‘trntogl cantare of rovion and rrd Uslegil ard chanted NBG cpuiiione Ti one include collssing Information on hay foreign nadorsp and decitornmakars and citeral fuctors that may Influence decilons information is lo collected on the nature and charucterindes of theater and regional arzasofinterat This task iso Includes collstng apuiost high payoff arguts of rational ntriegle vile whose attack wil fad direct or intircthy wo cha onomy defeat This cllscion task roguree that deployment trammportation Information ng threat to and statu o rasportaton inrastructures and ports of debartation PGBs on routs and wihin the are of rrponatiy AOR be ealoctd to mppore Erodeploymmont planaing for Intethestr and ntrathoster ait seat and land movements Thi tas includes collcing bastlefald damage asessments munition efects and matical teeeemons inorder o condhct mindan amenmane The tik aise incuder cotenig counteritaligonee meteorological consnographic and gnorpatial 04 ronsutinl iidrograptic produits and erogriptig inontaion OP 23 P 211 34 ¢ $2 3 Cerrlate Matloal Strategic Information To anocate and corthine den on a eat ecdece ae impevrs the ralat or wether of th Informaton OP 20 12 4 Realiats Integra Anales and Inverent Information To sppriee Information for eredibliy retabtiy pertinoncs and accurney Ersin It Includes forming Re ac eash she selection and comitalon of proceed Information Gntegrnan ‘Tae tik fhrther includerrevtewing Infomation to dant ignfeant fits for subsoquont intorpromion — Analraa Finaly the xlci to fudge the sintfcance of lnformation in relation to the curent — body of nowtedgs Interpret P20 m V S241 Idol Glal and Reriona tons and Throats To ament throaty putunoreneanansineitretnney and stuntions that could nadond rocuity ionromand efectos 09 20 SHLZ4 L 2 Detsersine naren labal Capn and Stateile Courser of Arsion «snene» Susnsorrdinmmenite ris sassommrmennnncnccneonce ec amacecm menaces vce cosnares2 «nongr ‘o Monty atthe national stratugle oval what an enomy or patanta enemy can do as wat ‘uct aeitvth whes serait This tak addres bett mtitary and norenitary cpubtiden Under mittary copubtites marines ground ais cara necea chomic Mologiea information warfare uncormentioal warfur and font cxpab ites Normitary capable Include potiéca and oconomi netins This tak also includes dentiying all 1tratoge courses of action COAs open to the enemy and where saMcian ntaligence to writable determining the reatve onder f probaby of ach COA Any factors that may Infuence the enemy to adopt a COA should be denifad Analy determination should be mad as to the nsenptbliy f vt elements ofthe enamys ntionat power to potenda ctions of another nation Enemy stratugle vinarshliter may come from poliiel goorpasial eg anrerautical hirographic geodetic and tepograpiic climate economic sclerite ocio se mitt tis gras to a 0 5142 42 Provide Workdwide Matonal Sratesc Indlations and Waening repo ime aondliveintligence on foreign derdlopments that could throatan the United Sate l citzersabrood or alled tary pobdcal or economie interest This task also Include dentying hovite reaction to US reconnaliincs action and Indcaions of imperthe ertornntinte oe Recidenmities To report irstele ntllgunco of Immediate valuo relating to pariclar rons f concern to the National Command Ashore NGA strategt planners This ttc incuder ‘he preparation ofincaigence ortmater and asersments and perdic ncotigonco bricing and Rncidonsmatars Ne eniinaentabiinns bntonte Netoos Sre xtmngant appropriat to support planning and COA deraopment P24 E D SN 1 Conetinats Forwaed Presence of Force n Theaters To colaborats wth other US deparemont and agunclo and the US Congros and to work with foregn gremmments to alow the staloning of or temporary pretence of US combat and support unis and Individual Service mamibers or DOD svens The objective sto alow the rapid application of the miliay Instrument of natlnal socuriyby placing US forces n a poston _ from which thay can rail respond t a eis or can upport the rapid sponse ofother foree to such n cris P 30 307 P308 207 1 ean moan l virsonglcterd enemy targets criride ang merulg ritnatee ar temiot enon worttvide and in nonlethal moans P 34 212 1 3—13 1 3 53 P 3 08% 3 11 3—66—1 0 S124 Protact Bratoglc Forse and Means To sefepuard Mondly strategie contort of radi irategl force potential and bases n the continental Unltd States Onder the ol populace and nduaiil capacy of the nation by reducing or avocing the affects ofenamy strategie teva action and unintentional endly medlns This task Includes T oR deployment of frees P34 301 1 2015 3—11 P3—10 282 m f¥ey moe mine lector uhacle sinconaiy band 10 To uke actonsto minimize fiend Indicators ansoatd wih rational lity strategy This task Inclade signal socurty and proteczion acte eg» pattorn viatenl forces and fuction from enemy observation and nrvetlance ag mtalion P 24 3454 C108 2212 01 P34 sim a 250 qgesmaizzesp £4 0 SH Projet National Swateels norinatton Information Bsend Procoesen aod Information Systems To defend nformation Informatincased processte and sovemime 822 1p ©05097682 nene — Information anitems by planing and implementing comprohonsive defense information Wartirs GWW2 measures based on rdernnagerment approach This sk includes ensuring neces o may necurat and relevant information when an where needed and to deny an drersary the opportunty to expll Hendy informaton and systems for thar own purpose ans 0 1 4543 50 P hes sar gestartantp @ U 3N 43 3 Cosedinato Refonsnida Lee Support To advise commanders and state o ll ti milly International and operational fw haven to review all rules of srgement ROR operation plan and recive fr conltency with US and Internatonal laws and to provide gal stcance to mary personnal and thet umites This uk Includes ‘ovrsoning ndmiriration of mlttary atie and udvic on detetion and handling of onomy pritnors of wa EPWW OP 3 083 207 $0 1 P34 31 3101 318 349 ¥ U S215 Provide Stratece Drnsion and Intoeraioo To develop and revise natonal andlor mutisadonal miliary strategy This sul s based on national securty msstegy for the atislnmant o siraogl soc tty Intoress objection and ond state The Join Chic of Seul octdcs the Chairman and Vie Chairman ofthe Jont Chick of Bet dere irtoste tinction natdenal securty tratngy and pote irecims The Secretary of Dofese through the Chairman of the font Chiat of Sta provide srieglc puldnce and direction to the A cornbntant commanders The combatant commanders ssbsequenty provid srategle direcion for the employment of aint Service sepporting specid and mutational forces brough thir unified action n theater rrateglr and campaign lana This aac Includer providing dear command relationships and tubing authority through an appropriate CJS warning lrt or execute onder Theater operations are on In conjunction with inomgovernmanta and priata voluntary agoncen and UN forces These three eratele id reamed stratele plan integrate the rzlonal ends ways and moans P 02 14 s0gn has sara 2 11 cals cas weep nomes aeanesane Mia bg one of command component Miltary Department ls or other organization to another by any move P 02 54 64 1 Z 51 5 1 4 Mavline Worddta Strategic Station To continuoualy observe and anar event reslonaly and gttball nclucing mace inthe conter of nslonal and mofinaional scurty rillarystrategiw and other elmont o rational power Le pottical economic and nformational P24 54 64 P34 £ 2 84 5 24 Dacits oo Nond tor illi» Actin or Changs To decide whether stratele actions are required whai are diferent fom those that combatant command and Servier rew hav aieaty heen anated to moore OP 1 02 29 30 50 SNE3 1 Jie Sratngl PncnineSluidunts To provide guidance on goteand obecivs resources and planning tata to Serie staf Service major comment and combatant command plannars This task includes providing puldance fr developing rmsornmendation for the national miley strategy t also includen providing guidance for Coren fercet sn ensure they pepport mubinatona and theater strategic and campaign in eanformance uith BOD GJCS and contingency planning qudance Guidance may Include ‘erguting plicy ROE levels of acceptable rids and other rentrleion and consontns P 1 oral ot f 1 C5 22 £22 Setoc o Maiit Mobioutonal and Matonal Milia Stators Plan and Shthr Satna Aetions To decide onthe stratege option tha afer tie best prospect for messes ors reel coh prpdloty selected 0b L 02 40 Or zap v W SM £24 Review Siratecc Option and Hacormmendations with NCA and Otter — «nevis Biren aitrerseinseiiin ot iene 06ge n 000000 00 omommms comme wass ©05097682 c «mene Offal and Adas To reviw stategtc option and recommendad strateges with the NCA and Chairman of th Joint Chic of Sal fad Congress and forogn government oficals as required to anale them to make a reasoned decidan To adhut the recommended statngy or acton based on NCA or CICS guidance P 1 02 34 54 P 24D w 0D S154 Proparm and hun CICS Gnats To promulgate rational strategie «umition decilons to nchordinats headquarters as wal as directly to execuiing and supporting fore Thi tak Includen warning aler and CJCS exscute orders JP 50 500 1 P03 $4 St 3 8 Coontloni Woridvita Infurmation Waeti ‘To Intograte the elements @ereaes wernedion Wartare W 0 and M © aect a piel destruction mitiry deception prchologleal operation lociontc ated operations securiy and other Information Wartire NW capabiite in order to afec an dversary nformation informaiton based processe and Information sre while defurcting ones oun This tak includes miltary upport to attacking and defending IW aspects of nadonal miltary pote and economic power P3—i3 1 CJCSH 321001 P24 349 7 S54 Provide Public Afales PA Waridvide To advise and ande the NCAand Chairman of th Joint Chics of Stl and combined chics n a couliion n tating the miltary» stor to both nternal and external avitonces Ths tk Includes orignating and amining ‘illa news madi in preparing both print and brondcart news materil and asltiog with comminityrelatdans profect PA srviee anol ters the rango of itary operations and are rpecaly plicable in miliary operations other han war For example Ina countersurganey ritrtion PA 1s the Antion that can Infunce educats and Inform the popudation and stl foclitats modia operations P 3 073 P 1 02 03 34 3—1 s Invik rmsutire wide flee dron eqpintine ms Interageney process uk ensures the atcomplatment or US otjecives through the combined m ‘us poinice miter otjecives ge 0230 30 3—03 P 200 1 2074 2 1 qos anizenp r a 5 A 1 3 Conetioat Milicy Actrites Wit th Interngency Process To work with represontaives of he other Exaciive department and agonies to resatvo muss Invohing operations bath overseas and domarc Thi tak includes woridng whi the Intursgonty proces and ertahluting inform also o ensure the resolution of ifereteos and the shaping of avn fo presentation wihi the National Securtty Councl System MSCS P er Ainartontt r Sn 62 2 Cond Informaton Mansgement in the Jotsengency Proonus To ensure tha the mazionurn Information is made avalable to all in th interngeny Procen This faa Include nt only protean reoree o fnformanion ovaide tie rarnid Garnazent information proces tio nclude onmaing that te few of information does nok 10 HEL mbit rory ammontin Amaee To Yok tanh be as 0 St A23 Eamblik Intengenes Cooperation Struentss To proces ensuring perronnalrepresont the views ofthe Join Chics infometement foctoam fhe un decee hove departments and agencies not normally represented in tha interagency proce to ensure Ail cverdination within thn Execstie Branch This ak alto Includes the eoaibiaiment vere inndet otiefornaifrocmanns ot talon groan r SM 8 4 ectorm Ganmeniencs Management n she Inturnguncy Arson To work withthe representatives ofother Exacitve departments and agonctan to undernand the posi path a developing erie can take and o provide hedging actions as option for «ssoneg» cos097682 «conte» ‘dediloomalors within the NSCS P 02 3 0 3 0 Taling Amotimant Tahio Xe depless a subjective assesment ofthe linc inlidor—essonil tal runing accompli daring ERPT—1 A compartron is provided with the Arnining asserement from th last No Netlc nteroperabllty Exercisn ERIS—1 and ERIE 1 ‘The assessmant is based on the uccentd or unasecessd accomplishment of the sxrdso objectives Bans inthe table Indicate thatthe UJTL utc was not applcabl oo the specifc exerci Ils anticated tha tis chart wil bo updated afte future ELIGIBLE RECEIVER «sercse n order o rack the GICSJMETL training i thi exercse series — Table XI U Training Assessment for BRGS—1 ER 9 1 ER9T—4 urine Assessnmemense—1 Assessnenrensr—1 assessment Sbamie tarsi 2 carsn2 14 sn2zup mizz snaage renaaapsn24 sna minal — swaara snzard szaar nasi r r T — p— r r Tan j siad — sana musa r ® renzcimsn3a2 maas snzaem ® penasarsns san «sscass f Rss ©0s097682 «conte ‘Table XH % Training Assersmont for ERAS— R 96—1 ERS7—1 continued umn 1 h Assessnmerenst 1 Assessmerensr—1 assessnent mis svar mus pens Lrrtsn s rapsn sia susiar rt rmusaa susaa La r feussztrensa © snsaa swsas susar sntac muse sussu i r ® re T r r r r ® r r Pama snes s swesa mass r » psveaur ticnin Amsemmermmnmnccncncoo006960220 0srssosumeccncmmmand cannes nane acca issa cusses cosooree2 swener — crossary Aan Afr Aetion Review ar Abr Fores nou Ameria Ontine Aon Area ofRemponitity age Automated Security Incident nformation Moemurement sms Air Saf Information Management System a command and contrl a command cont ind communication c command control communication and computers ca command control communications computers and ntaligonce c Conder Cac Cris Action Cat car Criss Action Team cam Gommanders Crtica nformation Requirements cowt Command Centar Watch Team — corr Computer Emergency Response Tea ca Central ntaigunce Agency ane commande in chief arwe Cited Inrassmenire Protaion Working Group car Computer Incident Reporse Team amac Computer Inventiguive and Infastructure Thvest Asserumont Center acs Chairman o the Jot Chit of Seat ges Cbairman of the Jot Chi of Stu Instruction des Chairman of the jont Ch of Staff memorandtim are commander oin taakfores cay cianifed by echexson ciuntfcation reason — on ‘Consequence Management cua compatsr network sieck can Caite Mews Network con course otacton © Conrusec computer searty consec communicatont socurty crc Grids Resorse Cat ese Goortiating Sub—Group a countertereriem be DierictofCatimbie — pane deputy commander In cer pereon Defense Readiness Condon vest Demonte Emergency Support Team pia Defemss Intligence Agony Btmsa Directoy National Seainty Aguncy pisa Defenss information Systems Agony «nemam mean nor rre mmacccnncacy near eccrocgusornnsme ccs mmmsccndend canes wn maas cosoores2 monies pia Deferse Loglites Aguncy pis Data Management Sptem bof Department ofJusice Ie Emergoney Action Pan P sen asventa elements of Mendy Information —— te exsonia elements ofinfrmation ss for sample erw boner of war ay Eo iieiiceven e Ew electronic arte max fasimte rat Federal Buress of Imertiguion rest Foreign Emergangy Support Tea nsa Foreign InsBigence Survetlance Act rorscom Forees Command aces lobal Command and Control Spstem cosc Global Operaidons and Security Center ors ground tracking sailon munnrt humareresource ineligmnce w Information atin io Mentifer in datls mrosc Information securty mmansar International Maridime Satallto 10 Information Operations iP Internet protocol irs Intaligonte Preptradon of Bantespice ire Information Protection Call — tere IntrestruciureProtmeion Task Force me Infomation Response Call me Intollgunce Task Foren iw Indications and warning iw Information Wartire iwo Inviligeace Working Group jeawe Join Command and Contrl Wartire Center herac Joint Inteligunce Conte Pacifc met Join Muslon Enondal Task men Joint laton Esnonal Tsu — mac Joint Wartre Anatnis Centar ta Los Anguics Lan Local Area Network wo ibo oftcer we Leglitic Raxdinon Genter mner Wilm Network wa notapplicile f wae nuctear Mologeal ad chamica Ssontr an cosoores2 ««sonsr» o new Natal Comment Authoridr wiex Mo Notic Interopertbtty Erecise wn Matlnal nformation ntusiricture wiener Mon Secure Internt Protocel Router Notwork wnce National Miltary Command Conter wag Mational Miltary Join ntaligence Canter won NIEX Nows Network wo National Reconnaliance Often nsa National Secu Agony use Matlnal Secrty Counc nees National Secrty Count System carson Offcn ofthe Anitan to the Secrotary of Defense Pubic Atlin conus ouside the continent United Seater onan operation lan omer aperatona eport orsec aporitions security ort Operations Panning Team on Offen of Special Inrenigations ose open source ressurch r noedepracice ma pubticatiirs races Pate Al Forces reo Prosidantal exective order rop port at debartation ree planning procedures and processes pevor perchologie operators vrea paris argetsloctronicroconnaieance new» Royal Canattn Mounted Pce noe ofengigement s Secret scaba Supervisory Contro and Data Acquitan sony signals matigunce sro ‘Senor Information Protection Oticer sommet Secret nternst Prooseui Router Network mo Secure Mall Guard © aw Stratego Level MutonalMittary Task sor special operations forces soo Senler Operations Oficer I standing operating procedures s mine sto Spada Technical Operations stoc Spada Tnamiea Operations Center smu secure talephone r tained Teatcon Threst Conditen Trop Time Phased Fares ard Deployment Dam u Unclantfot untrained f «scene c05097682 «Seontr um Univers Joint Task ise usacon US Adtartc Command usar — US Alr Force usce US Count Guard uscivceac Commander in Chic US Pacitc Command use US Govemment useacom US Pacite Command ussoc US Spacial Operations Command ussocon US Special Operetions Command ussencecon US Space Communt yaar Sem Spoon or int Aunts rog watencon Wai Gondton @xremonaucy stamy —sconir 2 cosoores2 «memamne — anvex a inpmviouat acencr exencise onjecrives U Eatisant Obissinas Most of he major participants entalished thir own nternal «xarcse objectives These objectives by organisation ar a follow 4 Desarimentof 3a b — U Fedscal urns of ecesdealon IPB _ U Tistinss Inllomce Amos DA «teman» ©05097682 Law‘ ie __ 0 US Space Commend ussPAGEcom I_ 0 UB Facie Command useAcom mente R 05097682 «suche annexe nex manor aimo ron 11 june ier V The ight page Early Bd for 11 June s on the folowing page — remonauey sang «sun Pennie s asesorcrccccrrcmecunnuanr crus ct wecnaraymmmem mmm vns