a I V 1 NSA ADVISORY I BOARD PANEL ON DIGITAL NETWORK INTELLIGENCE DNI N e 320 ieeort to irec'tor Lt Gen Jim Clapper Panel Merhbers OVERALL BRIEFING CLASSIFICATION 28'1 1999 Rpleasad by NRA on 17-May 2004 - I I pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act SEW Lase 91 1 73 - You asked forth ime of UNCLASSIFIED IL CLASSIFICATION OF THE BRIEFING 5 AGENDA Purpase I and Historical Overview 7 of 7 Riga Technology Trends - Definition i 4 feplwment - - I SMM - Skills Systems mga-nizational z-Res ources icmlausions UNCLASSIFIED 1 Purpose 1 road strategy for 86 36 UNCLASSIFIED 531 i Authorization Act - Background Focuses on NSA management of awnve- ntio nal and programs Requests DIRNSA task NSASAB for two part study UNCLASSIFIED i Part Canvem ma areag UNCLASSIFIED i The Taskng I consider broader applications Automation Research Center and recommend additional for of I 2 2 reporting of direction and planning for i Do the samethirm for ma that ELL did for Connentinnei Linden pert UNCLASSIFIED The Challenge 1 86-36 3 -18 USC 798 13 33-50 USC 403 mm 1 1 a The Mllelnge cont d 86 36 3 -18 USC 798 Pp-50 use 403 The I Challenge ii i at es-whims to these questions and the ve-atmkwi'ei 4P3' 'ai k 5% ti A - out an entirely new paradigm J r x 5 2 Background The mlmperatiVes to re-tooI- organizationally and'technolrogically of the I ref as it Should be conducted action which embraces the- Farm Follows Function Fi UNCLASSIFIED AGENDA 1 Rum-pose t Background 3 Definitions and Historicai of g target Technology Trends - De nition imminent Functional SMM 4 Skills A Systems 4 organizational Resources 7 Conclusions xammendations 1 Overview What is c2c and its partners lib 86 36 USC 798 ED-50 USC 403 A AGENDA 1 Purpose 2 Background 3 e nitions and Historical overview 4 Importance of mo - sarget Techn-O-logy Trends - DNI De nition 1 as A Deployment Functional SMM Skills I A Systems Organizational 4 Resources 7 Conclusions 18 SReCommendatiOns - UNCLASSIFIED m 86 36 3 -18 793 3 50 USC 403 1 iPu lspose 2 iaackground and Historical Overview 4 11mmrtance of 5 Target Technmagy Tmm ig ENE I 15 AGENDA Deployment Functional SMM Skifl IS Systems mg ani zational ReSources sGa-zneclusiO-n-s Recemmendations UNCLASSIFIED 8b 1 86-36 EH-18 use 798 33-53 use 403 5 Target Technology Trends I @0096 Growth volume 1 86-36 3 -18 USC T98 0f I 31-50 use 403 J- 1988 1998 y same - Repeat 19 98 This profound change mandatesa new paradigm 19 Target Technology Trend-s DNI De nition igital Network intelligence i The new SIGIHT naradigm I The intelligence from intercepted digital data communications transmitted between or resident on neMorked computers AGENDA 12 1 atware-and and Historical Overview - lance of I gent Technology Trends - DNI De nition 6 Deployment Functional SMM fans systems - 1 Resources Canning-lions 7 1 86 36 3 18 USC 798 3 50 USC 403 AGENDA Purpose -ie nition-s' and Historical overview I Emportance off i 1 Trends - DNI Definition A Functionai 1 WM i Q Skiils Systems '4 Organizational Resources conclusions 1 Recommendations UNCLASSIFIED ACCESS COLLECTION Definitions Includes Attendant Operational Management Activities A c - Thegactiuity of identifying and acquiring target networks - Theprocess of converting machine language into human language b1 1 bl 3 4313 86-36 lb Bl-18 USC 798 bl 31 50 USC 403 Dissemination 4 The forwarding and presentation of multimedia intelligence WW 1 86 36 3 18 USC 798 3 -50 USC 403 Eunction l Ta x'ononiy - Prqc ssihg DNI PROCESSING CYCLE 1 86 36 03 3 1s use 798 3 -50 USC 403 idho y - Processan - PROCESSING FUNCTIONS Ji 33-11 86-36 31-48 USC 798 31 50 USC 403 l 1 86 36 use 798 Nb 31 50 usc 403 6 Functional Taxonomy - Processing - - - a 1' Example of the signal proceSsing Challenge - Where What do we extract i bl 1 - b1 86 36 USC 798 3 50 USC 403 b li 86 36 USC 198 USC 403 86 36 USC 793 was 403 86 36 In 3 18 USC 798 bl 3 -50 USC 1 103 tb 33 9 L 85 36 3 618 USC 798 use 403 3 8 5-36 b1 31 18 use 793 use 403 5 1 86-36 Usc 793 b 43y 50 use 403 86 36 19 use 793 53 use 463 86 36 3 18 use 7 93 33-50 use 403 1 DEFINITION I 86-36 USC 798 3 -50 USC 403 IMPORTANCE of irrelevant intercepted data Critical to EIGINT Mis t er miss ens UNCLASSIFIED 86 36 I 1 -18 USC 798 50 Use 403 - S MM governs the end-to-end process AGENDA 2 riaa gii mnarta nceof Trends - DNI De nition - ISM A Skills 1 1 SyStemis 112 7f - UNCLASSIFIED 86 use use 86-36 798 403 I 3 Historical Overview of Trends sma - -- I A Systems 4 mgmizational I UNCLASSIFIED Systems Taxonomy Wm H 36 3 USC 79% USC 403 Ni-b 1 86'36 USC 798 USC 403 MW 1 86 36 M 3 -18 USC 798 EU-50 USC 403 Eff-guescription mn 86 36 USC 798 PSC 403 86-36 IS NOT THE 1 86 36 3 18 USC 798 3 -50 USC 403 m 1 86-36 3 18 usc 798 3 50 USC 403 49 6 Ovezrvsi-ew of - Definition organizational iemunces - 6 The System Taxonomies - Organizational Organizational Taxonomy b1 1 86 36 USC 798 USC 403 CO AGENDA Overview Definition- anizeational e50urces UNCLASSIFIED 86 wri nw wu I mwy a r Ex full - - I I a 32 I 3 CT - 5 5r I 1g A 7 Historical OverView of czc A Trends - Definition Functional SMM 4' isms coalsgsa niiz- ation-al A Resoumces Cn-nclusions 2 5 UNCLASSIFIED 1 86 36 USC 798 30 50 use 403 86 36 3 -18 USC 798 EH-50 USC 403 - - - a 1 a Fifi E'rlv roun Historical Overview 1 iffechnology Trends - DNI De nition 2 315' Functional 4 - nisza tional Resources a i 15% Recdmmendations UNCLASSIFIED 3J-P L 86-36 33 18 use 799 33 50 use 403 58 61 Cont d wheel i iindfustry and academia always be the rst choice 1 86-36 USC 798 33-50 USC 403 AM 9 3 Li in - x w Emu 13 14 ss 36