1 Ilpe3H neHry PoccHHCKOH l e nepaI J l l EJihllHHY E H rocrro nHH Ilpe3H neHT IloCJie nHHe meCTh JieT OIHTaJI 51 CB0HM 0Jir0M BceMepH0 co neiCTBoBaTh TOM rroJIHTHKe KOTopyro co BCeMH oroBopKaMH M0 KH0 6Lmo neM0KpaTWieCKHM HaJBaTh IlOJIHTHKa IIp0lfH0 rocy napCTBa rrpeo6pa30BaHHeM CBIDhIBaJiaCb 11 nyJ Qero no c BallIHM POCCHH 11 • HMeHeM neMoKpaTwrecK0M ' nyrH noJiroe BpeM sI Bbl a 6bIJIH rJiaBOH rroHaqany OIHT3JIHCb JIH ZlepoM u eM0KpaT0B IloKa Bbl 0CTaBaJIHCh B paMKax noro H onrran ce6 H BarnHM COI03HHK0M a 3Ta B Tex cJiyqaax Kor na BarnH a Ke Kypca rnam paCXO l HJIHCb C 0611 HM HanpaBJieHHeM JJ BH KeHH sI HJIH pe3K0 3aMe rr rnum ero TeMII - JI0 HJihHblM 0IIII0HeHT0M IJ opora PoccHH K CBo6o u e He o6eJ QaJia 6b1Tb JierKoii MHorHe TPYJJ H0CTH 6hlJIH oqeBHJ Hbl npeo ztoJieHIDI 3apaHee BceM MH0rne HaM B03HHKaJIH BJiaCTH 061 Qecray HeO KH U aHH0 Ka KJJ OMY LrnI HX qenoBeKy rJiaBH0e DpHXO lWIOCb npHHHMaTh HenpOCThle H U a Ke -rparWieCKHe perneHH H 11TO crpa Ha 0 KH ztaJia OT Bae rro BOJIH K IDMeHeHIDIM H l JeCTHoCTH Oco6eHHO - qecmocm lli6Hp3JI Bae PoccH H BH u ena nepe ri co6oii He TOJihKO noJIHTHKa rorosoro JI0MaTh crapoe rocy ri apCTBeHHOe ycrpoHCTBO HO H qeJI0BeKa BCKpCHHC crpeM HIIterOOI K3MeHHTh caMoro ee6H CBOH B3rIDI D hl npHcrpaCTH sI IUlaCl1lhIC DpHBbJllKH Bbl y6e l HJIH MHOrHX - 11 MeIDI B TOM qHCJie - l JTO ryMaHIICTH11ecKHC H zteM0KpaTHqeeKHe eHHOCTH Moryr CTaTh JUI Bae oeHOBOH pa6on 1 D0JIHTHKH Mbl He 6hIJIH CJieIIhIMH Mhl BH D eJIH Bee o61 ouoacK o-QeKHCTCKHC CTCpeOTHIIbl coxpaHHBWHee I B BaweM IIOBe neHHH Ho • KOHue KOHllOB BCH 6oponacb caMa c Poccmr KaK lfenoaeK no naep KeHHbIH TIDKKOMY co6ou lla Ke He nJ06 J Bae - Bae noHHMaJIH JIJIIKO 3a nocneJlHHC fOJlbl Bbl np0 D OJI KaJI s Ka KJJ 0M ny6nuqHOM 31NfNITb CJJywaTCJICH s CBOCH HC3bI6JICMOH npueep KCHHOCTH BIINUl Mt cr JIH - CHa'lana MC llJ CHH0 a ncrroM Bee 6onee pyKOIIOAHMOA BaMH rocy 11apcra HHOH nOJIHTHKH B CTJ alUUI nblT eTCJI noaepHyn -crpa- HY • y KaJ'OD e fiwno npo naw B 1991 ro a aBrycre 3-ro npHBO IJJfT MeIDI K He06XOJll IMOCTH rry6JIHtfHO o6ooHa'IHTb CBOIO Il03Hl HIO He 6y y nOMHHaTh Bee Barne MHoro'IHCJieHHh1e onm6x11 u rrpocqeThI - Ha 3TO Ha H ll eTCSI TbMa OXOTHHKOB IJ eno He B KOHKpeTHblX npoBa rrax a B RX npH'IHHax npHHI UIIIHaJlhHO HeBepHOM Bb16ope rrpHOpHTeTOB H Kp11TepHeB B rocy napcrBeHHOH IlOJIHTHKe HatJHHa H no KpaIDieH Mepe c BbI6HpaJIH He Te leMOKpaTH'leCKOM 6eCt1enoBe1JHyio 3aKOHOM peweHIDI o6w ecrBe MOw 1 JIIO IlhMH KOHIJ a KOTOpbie a Te BparH yr peIIIDUIH KOTOpbie rocy napcrneHHOR Bannr 1993 ro n a BhI nocne n oBaTeJihHO yicpenrremra cBoeii JIHtIHOH BJiaCTH Ho CTO H UJ eH 'ITO B1 1 npaBa CHJIY BOOpOJK a TIH Manm Hb1 yrBep K naIOT 61 1 T 'Ilyro 1-1 Ha npaaoM nenan H na Ke eCJIH no He Tax B rro cyn or JlJUI rroro He MCIDleTOI TJ arwJeCKHe OCCHH B COMHeHHH 3a ny po OBOH 1993 ro na H He 6eJ cephe3HbIX BH 'TpeHHHX peWH1ICH Bae rro n nep KaTh H He CHHMaIO c ce6H OTBeTCTBeHHOCTII no n n ep IQ y R IlOJiara rr llTO npHMeHeime CHJibl 6hIJIO B TOT MOMeHT He06XO nHMOCTblO rrepe n JIH QOM rpOOHBIIIeH BOT-BOT BCilbIXH 'Th rpaxutaHCKOH BOHHbl R H TOr na IIOHHMaJI 'ITO OKTII6pbCKHe C06hITIDI Moryr DpHBeCTH K TOMY tffO BepXOBHaJI BJiaCTb HallHeT BOCrrpmrn MaTh HaCRJIHe KaK o6Bl IH H npHBbNHblH HHCTp 'MeHT IVUI pememra IlOJIHTWieCKHX npo6JieM o Ba ne a nca Ha npyroe trro npeo noneB KpIDHC nernTHMHOCTH H coo naB llIDI OCCHH HCXO llB 'IO npaBOBYJO 63 3y Ilpe3H l eHT H npaBHTeJihCTBO c neJiaIO'r Bee oe J11lll MHJ HOfO H -IVU an1 repeaTHB1 1 CB060 lHOfO pa3BHTlUI crpaHbI trem MHOroe B JaBHceno JIWJHO OT Bae Eop0c HKKonaeBHll R BepWI BW6epere sropoi nyn H oum6cll IOUJ 993 fO Zla Ha Zle TllleT Ilpe3H neHTa orpOMHhIMH H smnarae-r Ha Hero orpOMHYJO OTBeTCTB HHOCTb np B H B 60 n I a K_n H 0 H e - u • K K Bbl p nopB nMH b I HH H H B 11 '1'11u Jrll 'l'HJJ 2 nonHOMOtJl UI CHJIOBblM CTp 'KT 'paM PeayJihTaT _ npecryrunnrn no- 3aKOHa npe KHeMy ryJI H OT Ha CB06o ne a 3aKOHOTIOCJI 'llIHbie rpa KJ aHe o6perx 6eJonaCHOCTH BhIHy K neHbr Tepnen eIIJ e H TaK H He JIIO II eH IIpOH3BOJI 3 B M 'H l Hpax BLI 1 ITO 33 SIBHJIH QeJIOCTHOCTH repplITOpHaJibHOH 6e3 napH3 SI Barna rpa K O aHCKaJI BOHHa u en1 coxpaHeHHe H l e nepau HH PeayJibTaT - BOT y Ke 6onee ro na YKpermeHHe Il030pHa a nonbIXaIOJ l a a H Ha CeBepHOM KaBK33e Ilo n BH OM 'KpeilJiemra o6opOHOCTIOC06HOCTH PoCCRH B1 1 rrpeceKJIH Bee IlOill ITKH BOeHiiOH pe popMbI KOTOpruI J aJia PoCCKH 3q q eKTiraHbie 61 1 H coBpeMeHI-11 1e Boopy KeHHLie CHJI1 1 Pe JyJI1 TaT - PacxoJ b1 Ha apMIDO pacryr reHepa rroB KOJilflleCTBO y nJIHIDIIOTC» c eCTBOBaHHe COJI llaThl II O OIIIJIO oquw epbl ymDKeHIDI 6ecnpaBIDI y lHB 1IJIThCH 'tJTO OT H n o cpoKH HHil He HerrpIDIWIIDI CJiy K6hI Koppyn QHH cpe eBeKOBOH - orrpaB l aTb OTMeIDnorca H o6opBaHHhie 'lfT06bI H KpeITKH peKpyrtmHbI RX A orcpol lKR A rpa n mu m fOJIO J Hbie no-npe l HeM ' llero Ke OT xy UlleH Harracm KaK 'KJIOHJllOTc sl neCBTKH ThlCj l MOJIO I blX nro nen B1 i fOBOplITe 06 OTKpbITOH IIOJUITHKe 0 rnaCHOCTH H rry6nwrnOCTH - H OllHOBpeMeHHO II0 l IIHCbIBaeTe ceKpeTHbie YKa3hl KacaIOI IJ HeCH Ba KJ efunmc rocynapcraemn rx nen cm naeTe JaKpbITbie miCTHTYIUIB JaceKpe'tfllBaeTe Bee 6onhme CBe Zlemrii O pa60Te BJiaCTHl IX CTpyKTyp 0 IlOJIO KeHHH B crpaHe exa HH3M eimh npHlillTml npe3H ZleHTCKHX peweIDUi K3 K 3TO 6bIJIO BO BpeMeHa IloJIHWIOpo CTaJI 1101 JTH UK Knee Ke CTOJih He ceKper o B CBOeH lle HTe nbHOCTH Bee 60JibWe OIIHpaeTeCb Ha cne u CJiyiK6bI Ha HX r- - JaJq bITOH HHq opMaQHH Hey KeJIH BaM ZlO cHx nop He O'tleBHJUia ee Be IIO TO BepHOCTb H TeH llCHllHOOHOCTb JqX BaJI nonHTHKa c Ka l JI LIM JJ HeM onpeJJ eJIJleTCB see 6onee BpeMSI pBJJ OM C BaMH BCTpe laJIOCb HeMaJIO n10 l eH 0 lbHM Te H M I n e lHHCTBeHHbIM HB 'laJIH - npH M n q p B BfJUl JfTeCb JIHQa B CBOHX IlO'-leMy D HBJUITbC H CJIC D OBaTCJibHO H BnpolleM cero nIDIWHHX crpaHa co paTHHKOB H Zl OBepxeT B3 I I IHM He BaM Bbl a BCJie n 3a BaM H H Bee craBJiemmKaM BhlCilllle a ' rocy II apcraeHHore B HHMaJIO He 3a60THTC H 06 o6m ecrBeHHOM MHeHHH lfHHOBHHKH 4 nepecraHeTe B1 1 MOMeHTbl KpK3HCOB BMCCTO OTKpbITblX H 11eCTHbIX OOb HCHeHlrii Bbl H Ha3Hal JeHHb1e BaMl i pyicoBo enH rocy napcrBeHHbIX Be ZJ OMCTB TIO'N 'lOT Hae TaKoJi o'leBH HOH H 6ecnOMOlllHOH JIO KblO 'ITO rrpocro MC K lly 06I llCCTBOM -rpamnum RTiaCTblO XpynKHR MOCT I OBepIDI C - rpy noM HaBe leHHbrn BOrrpeKH CTOJieTHeH CHOBa pa3pymeH qepe 3 6hlJia H OTOpOIIb 6epeT ro n C He60JibIIIHM IlOCJie OKTII6pbCKHX co6bITHH B MocKBe BaMH pa3B113a Ha lJClJCHCKa H BOHHa IIpeHe6pe KCHHe rrpaBOM nonpaHHe OHCTHTynHH neMopanmaQIDI H pa3BaJI apMIDi BOrm 10masr HeKOMileTeHTHOCTb cneQcrry K6 6e3 napm rn KapbepIDM BepxymKH CIDIOBbIX Be UOMCTB He 'KJIIO KaK QHHINHcUI JIO Kb ooByqi maeMasr nepBbIMH JI aMH rocy napcrBa - Bee 3TO s DOJIHOH Mepe npoKBHJIOCb 3 Uecb Ho B 3TOM KpIDHCe y KacaIOI I te o6Ha lUIJIOCh H eIQe 0 I HO CBOHCTBO npeHe6pe KeHHe K coo naBaeMoro 'ICJIOBelJeCKOH TW0111 mo n ei - nom6nH OJih O HX 6bIJIQ - pom Bw HY Bameii KIDHH IIOJIIITHKOH pe Kl Ma - IIOJIHOe KaK TaKOBOH llBa--rpH-lleTbipe neC HTKa H tJTo Mb1 na Ke He JHaeM B TOllHOCTII KTO OHH MHpHbIX KJiTeJieH pOCCIDICKHX COJI naT 6oeBHKOB scer n a ueHHJiaCb neweBo B PoccHH BHecJIH HOB 'IO neMOKpaTJllieCK 'IO H OTe11CCTBeHHYJO 11 ryMaHHCTH1 eCKyK 11 -rpa nH HlO QeJILIH BOCCTa HaBJIHBanHCb oco6eHHo npH 6oJibIIIeBm ax ro n KOHCTHTYl lHOHH1 m 11 ape CB06o ZlHblX BbI6opos rrpHBeJI H 16KH ct na u crpyro B 6oM6aMH qetJHe rrop11 noK 1TY 11 rrpa Ba H He MOr He npHBeCTH K ua n e KJ Ha MHp B pernoHe To HO TaK KC H B M Bo6o KJleHmr T y JaJIO KHHKOB Bbl nposeJIH flO II JIHHHOH Ke H npDBaJIHBW 'IOOI pp pHCT H np p JI na rreK OT Toro 'IT06hl B03Jiaran HTapHbIM CTpOH KOTOpOMy 6hIJI H y nap preJlbHbIH npoH3BO l CTBOM 3all Hll aeT Barna BHHy TOJibKO Ha Bae aHeceH cephe3HbIH HO B03MO KHQ He ce6» IIpHCVTnHMH J eMy cnoco6aMR Hacenemm no MeHoi Pa3Bpall J eHHeM KpIDHca IQ CTBeHHhIX n eHHocreH BCIO JIK4 Hax BHHa · TOM 'ITO B1 1 He TOJibKO B IDITCTBOBaJJH 3THM TeH neHo IDIM HO CI'HMynunoBanTx ' BLI nyMaere fO mDilIIIDUI 'ITO HX E LITb MO KeT JIIDITh KpaNaHilllle B 6ecnpaBIDI lJ JUI cpOKH Hm IMH BOCCOJ naTh CJIOBaMH B1 1 crapoe 601n meBHCTCKOe 60JIO'I'O TOJU KO KOMMyIDICTINeCKa SI BOCCTa HaBJIHBaeTe B B cnoco6aa OTKpbITOe cppcoeo normi n He crpo ine Bemn 'IO Pocci no no 6naro ee rpa K n aH HeT Barn IlOJIHTIIKa napcmo y ' IlOKa 3aMeHSieTCH aHTHKOMM 'IDICTWleCKOH Baum PHTOpHKOH O Ie npeeMlllIKH H 3TOT He lOCTaTOK 0 crrpaB SIT Ha lla JIH B1 1 3HepnRHhm 6open CBOIO L eMOKpaT HqeCKyro Kapbepy KaK HanopHCTbllI H oqnu n 1an1 H1 IM BpaHheM H rrapnnIBoii n ecnornei i a c 33 KaJNHBaeTe ee IIOCJl 'llIHl IM HCIIOJIHJITeJieM BOJIH J O llllNHhIX BJiacromo6n eB OKpy KemUI Bbl KIDIJIHCh IIOCTJ OIITb rocy napcrno Hapo na H AIDl B3 Ba111ero HapOJJ 3 no a B ICTpOHJIJ f tnlHOBHlltJblO IIHpaMH ny ua n Hapo noM H IIpOTIIB Hero Bbl OTKaJaBWHCb OT neMOKpa eCKHX ueHHocreii H IIpHH1 HIIOB He epecrasaH DOMHHaJIH aer 'ITO neMOKpaTHIO TaK 'ITO HHOH HaHBHblH lleJIOBeK H s KpeMJie y BJiaCTH Haxo wrrcx neM0KpaT1 1 11 • Barna OMIIpOMeTHpOBaJia ca Mo 3TO CJIOBO H eCJlll neMOKpanrn B PoccHH a B sep10 s 3TO - oHa 6y ner KHTb He 6naro napx a BorrpeKH -----·o ropbKO H 1t' p 1 _ 1 ro lfTO Bbt npoHrpaJin ca Moro 6s He oMa - 'I noseKOM A se n b MornH H I y n M Bbl Hp Tb Bbl 5 jl C'IHT3 JI an CBORM BaweH 0Tb B nonroM OCTaBaTbCH a nMrumcrpaI HH no Tex 1 JeM-TO XOTII 6bI B nycn H 11 Ha 06w ecrneH1I1 IX nop IlOKa MOH CTaTyC Il03BOIDIJI OT nenbHhlX npOTHBOCTOKTh CJl Ia HX 3 BOBblM H a HTKrYMaHHhlM TeH ne B rocy napcrBeHHOH IlOJIHTHKe 0 1 e'f H H ceWiac 3TH B03MO KHOCTH He no KOHU a HOiepnaHbI JlaJlbWe poHHHKOM pa60'raTb J eMOKpanm c HH Ilpe3H UeHTOM rapaHTOM rrpaB KOTOporo II He Ho H OIHTaIO He HR cao6o n rpa K uaH MOeH crpam 1 YBe noMJUI10 n Bae tITO c JToro IlIDI H 6oJibllle He HB IDIIOCb ffiI nce naTeJieM KoMHCCIDI no npaBaM llenoBeKa rrpH Ilpe3 0 neHTe P l HR 11 11eaoM Ilpe3H II eHTcKoro CoaeTa RH 'tlJieHoM rrpo'lllX rrpe3 0 neHTCKHX CfPYI TYP· JlYMaIO llTO Bbl He 6y nere CO KaJieTh o MOeM yxo ne H TOJK e Ceprei Ko saneB nenyraT focynapcraeHHoi Uy-M1 1 6