UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 INWMING · · ·- TELEGRAM ' - - - - - -- - --W 11-- H m --t rjf--------- ··· - ·- - - INFO OCT•i1 AUS•l0 •1 •'' SECHET PAG 01 PAijIS 21 7a ACTION r OOS•iJkJ r · Bl OF 02 2 161ioZ1 COPY _ _ ____OF 15 COPIES P 291547 JUN 79 I- • ' ' ij l - ' ' · ii F AN NliA ST PAHIS TO SECSTATE ASNOC P IORITY 2122 Sf CR ET SECTIQ 1 OF i2 PARIS 21 7a PASS OOEIISA • P H RCH E 0 12165 H0 •1 6 29 79 CFriI D AN Ao TAGS PARM TECH M 11 C· Pf FR SU8J S IkT LLIGENCE OISCUSSlON ON PROGRAM REFr PARIS 19Y5a 1 • EN IRE X 2 TWO SEPANATE MEETINGS WtR NELO AT tNCH FUREIGN OFFICE ON TECNNlCAL ASPECTS OF PAKI TAN - UCLEAR P D RAM A O ATTERS t$EPTfLJ I THE FlkST - tETINij T FRENCH ERE REPRESE TEu y·LEYGONit ACTlNG $fC EfARY - uC EAR ---- -POLICY COUNtJ CDL ROBERT HLiN ANO- GENtRAL MONTR LAY · tGENERAL SECRlfAklAl FOR NATIUNAL Offt SE FRAhCUii BEBILLEAU tCEAl ANU GDTTLIEij CDtPUTY to · LdUtT e THt us DeLEGATIUN iN LUOEO IEDNAN · csc1cuuNS GALLUCCl SIP ANO LOCK£ PN PP · 1N THE tCOND ·M ETING Tht fRENCH OELf ATio · ·LSO INCLUOtD CuAtE C Al AND T f US WAS REPRtSENTfD bY KRATZ 00 lSi YA STRUN tuA HIOlitE ANO t RiHA A OA NP - ' StCRET REVIEW AUTHORITY Marvin Russell Senior • NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF TUE EX$iq lTIVE SECRETA Y I · - UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 · UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 Pl M01 U- li'6 • INCOMING TELEGRAM i SECRET ___ I 3 IN THt Fl Sf ftTl ThE FHENCh dE AN bY EPEATIHG T f I FDR ATl N PHDYl EU EPT L 0 THEIH f l F THAT PA ISTAN I usiNG NARA ING STEtL- AfhEH TNA ALUNlNU FON CENTRIFu E ROT KS ANU ThtIR bfLIEF TNAT HARAGlNG sTtEL iu SEE I PQRTfU • RO - T E fTHEWLAN s DURING Th · AFTtk OU THE F ENCH-SAlO TNAT T EY o ltV TNE ENTIR CENTRlfUbE fHD CAPSi StLLUW$ ANU ROTOHS WA NAOE OF HAHiGlNG STiEL THtY MtNTlON O-A ThO ROTUR MACHlhE BUT o o NOT - REAFFIR lHt $TAT MtNT DURING DISCUSSlDN TH GOF CUNCLUUED THlS FhO ANALYSIS OF TECHNICAL INFUR ATIUN PRD IuEO to ThE · F CH CONPANT CALORSTAT S PAHA 4 ANO RoN · T E FHENCh KNDWLEOG OF U fNCO TtChNULOGY IN ESPONSE Tu FR NCH RfQ f$f FuR INrU NAT10N A80UT eNRlCHHfNT ITES iN Pi ISTAN GALLUCCI eRiEFLY DESCHiaED STAT S Di PAKISTAN NUCLEAR PROGRAN IN lH£ SA £ · t R S USED iN INFUft AL hEETlNij 1N VIENNA T f ijtViUUS AY SE TEL e RfN n IhTELLI ENCt REPRESENTATiYi TAT D THAT THt 60F hAS 1Nr HNATlDN TH4T THE AHUTA ENTKifUij FACILITY iUuLU ijsrA T UP WlT IN A HO TN WHEN WUtSTIONfD ABOUT EiACT iANiNG I t · WhETHER CONSTHUfTIDN OH OPERATION OF asCADtS wouLo START UP TNE r CH SIDE WAS UNSURE - tnEY RECOG I Eu TH SIGNIFl AhCt CF THIS IN OR ATlON ANU P CNISEO yo · FO LD uP -IN AUUITlUN THE FNfNCN RUViOfD TnE · FOLLOWING lNFU AliuN ON TH tX D r·o SAFEGUARDED ANU UNSAFEGUARDcU UNANiu TU PA lSTiN °FHOri NIYt SAFEGUAMO D UHA lu -WAS SENT TO PAKiSTA lN 1977 TONNES JUNE 1978 58 TDNN Sl ARCH-1Y7i lABDuT·l TONNES IN O ITION THE FH CH SAiD T AT IGER E T U SAFEGU RQ O U ANIUN t PA ISTAN-BY AIR ThHO Gn LI YA UNDER P 11 1S f ANI GuA os ACCOR01Nli TD FRc NCl 'I • • lNTELLIG NCi SUuHtt SNlPNtNTS of UNSAffGUARuE URANIUM eR MAUt IN 1978 15 TUNhE jAhUARl 197i SECRET - - NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF 'VE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY I I UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 Ptt41Ul3U-1J'66 - Department of State - INCOMING • TELEGRAM I - SEC ET · AHlS 21W73 150 TONNESJ AND B LifVfU THAT TNt THE FRfNCN STATED URA IUN NAS S IN 81 F si 291b1 Z ARCh 197i 15 TUNhE l fHEY UNANIUM WAS IN oNCtNTNATtD FOR ThAT TriEY HAO N KNDWLfOiE wHERt TH CONVEHTfO TO f I •• IN THE AFTEWNOON THE FRENCh ROVIOtO THE OLLOWING INF R ATION OH COOPERiTlON SEl•EE PAKISTAN A O ThE FRENCh CO PANY CALD STAT PRIOR TO JULY 1977i THE PAKISTANI ENHASSY IN BONN CUNTACTt0 TNlS FRENCH CDNPANY ANO REQUtST U IT TO MANUFACfU f SELLO S PREVIOUSLY THlS-CONPANY HAO NOT - •UAiEO UN ANY PART OF THE fRENC ENTH Fu P OGRANi BUY tT · M O WURKEU ON •so E OTHER-NUCLEiR-PROJECT IHITIAL Y hHlLE UTILIZING EXl TlN TECHNO O Y AND EWUlPMENT TriE FREN n CONPANY CDU D-NdT - PAOOUCE B LLD S TO ijEtT THE - - PAK1STAHI3' NEEu$ • AFTER THIS Tl E TH -PA lSTANIS PROVIDEO T t COHPANY NiTH DETAILEU P ClFlCATiONS FUR THE 8£LLO S IN JUNE 1 77 THE FIRST CONTRACT B TMlfN THE PAKISTAN EMBAS Y lh BONN AN fA O S AT AS I N D SECRET _ NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF Tf -xecunve p • • ' -- PAGE SJ • SECRETARY UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 - -· UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 SECRET PAGE l ACTION N005•0B INf'il OCT• 1 AMI 21173 AD •Bi NOOJSlei 02 UF 02 291 1 Z 11181 h ·······-·-······-•e J P 29l 47Z JUN 7 FN AHE ASSY PAHIS fU SECSTATE NAS U RIORITY 2 2 29161512 41 - SECRET SfCTlON 12 OF i2 ARIS 21 7 FORT P UUUCT10 OF AN UNSPEClFlEU N 8EH OF fLLU S BET EEN J N i977 AND SEPTENBER 15178 · 21 PROTOTYP BELLOHS fR PROUUCfD ANO DELI ER o · ro AN UTT AT TH£ PAKISTAN t BAS5Y IN BONN• THIS IS PR SUNAbLf SijjfIQ 4HN•D 6UTT SCIENTIFIC iNiSf k•CU NSELOH IN PAKISTAN EH A St IN PARZS IN S PlEKBER li7ti AN ADDITIONAL 2i BELLOWS WERE PRUOuc£o AND UE IVERED TO Tht SAME PE SON 1N UCTOSER 1978 A DR ER •s PLAC D w rH TPili SAMf COl'IPANT THNOUGH Tt1t PAI InANl ENdASSY IN F ANCE TO PROUUct · 1 ee 8ELLU• - ' fSE LLOWS EHE TO H VE 8EEN PRDUUCtD ITH NE- ELLDN fOR ING EQUIPhENT TN15 N • 6EL DftS FDRHlNG EQulP ENt •s ANUFlCTURED BY- ALORSTAT AtC RUING- Tb TECNNICAL SPECIFlCATlOHS HlC NERE PROVIDEU dY T PAKISTANIS• AFTfR ThE CUNTMACT AS I N D 2 P OTOTYP A 0 tHEN-18 BELLO S NtRt PRODUCtO ANO DELlVEREO lN FEbRUARY-15170 2 8 bELLO S W R PROO C D AND D L V£Rf0e -iN ttAT 1919 ij00 aELLOWS wtRt UfLlVfHE 1D PA lSTAN THIS LASt SHIP fNT AS ROP RLT MAR ED TD AYDXD FRE CH CUSTU CONTRU S THt K NCH HAVE AODEO oELLUWS TD T EiR-EXPDRT CONTROL L S1 -AND HAY TOLD THE CD PANT TNAT IT MUST NUT SHIP ANY BELLOW OR 'HEL O S FDR ING E UiP ENT TD A l T N DURING T t A TfHNuDN SE SlO ThE FN NCH STATED ThAT T EY HAD ND DiRECt EYlOtNCE THAT PA STiN HAD ACTUALLY 5 • • • SECt ET • NOT TO BE REPRODUCE WITHOUT THE AUTHOIUZATION OF THE • rxecurrve SECRETARY ·- I UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M 2016-02 103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 PB10130 - 17oE i -_ _ INCOMING Department of State TELEGRAM · _ • iO · - • -·' · r • _ - 't I SECRET PAGE ra2 PAHI 2Ji73 2 UF 02 291617Z ADE ANT ROTOHS UUT o ARAGING srEEL bUT THEY BELIEVE T · TO Bt TN CASE bASED 0 THEiM ANALYSIS DF THE TECHNICAL SPEClFltATIUNS PROVI0£0 CALOR TAT AND THE GQF KNO LfUijf - Oi RtNCO DESIGNS DURlNG T AT DlSCU SIDN -Tnf·F EhCH STATED THAT TH Y - hAO A COPY OF A UfffkCO OESI N i WHICH T E · us UELfGAtiuN OtLifYED WAi OIFFERE T FHOM ThE PAKISTANI OESI N -TNf FRENCH ASKEU THE US TO PRDYIOE INFOMNATIDN HitH HAD LtO US TD CONCLUOt TH4T TH PA ISTANlS ARE uSINij A UESlGN WITH -Fou ALUMl UN tub 5 SEPARATEU jy·a LLD S AS Au PffEYlDU LY EEN-TDLO U THE US DiLE A ON C0nNENTE THAT •E OULO ATTEMPT TO PROYIOt LN ON ATIO AT A LATiR DATE IT NAS StATEU THAT THE PAKlSTA I COULD E UTlt IZING UR T' 1AN · D E OES1Gth - - - - - · 6• IH HESPUNSE TO wUESTIO PNOVIDEU ijy lNN STA THt FRENCH STAT U T iT ALORSTAT HA O E T ANY 8 L OWS _· _ __ I _ 11 FORM NG EQUIPNfNT SOCH IS fLU Tu hl G fQUlPMENT TD PA ISTAN lHt FRENCH 8fLIEVEu TriAT ' TMt PA ISTANIS cou u IMPORT QUlPMENf tRUM EUROPfAN CDUNTRlES ANO - S CCESSFULLY ' t · etLLD-s WHEN ASKEO y THE PAKISTANIS NOSE TD PuRCHAS ELLD S FRO F ENCN CO PANY GO Of IClALS STATED THA PA ISTA HAD lMPORlEO 8ELL0MS s ciu e- lT WAS EASlER • · 11 AS ALSO SUGGESTtO THAf A SHORTAGE OF SKiLLfO EfH lClAN lN PAKiSTAN HOULO AKE 'THe ' PROUUCTION r•SK OIFFICULT fV THOUGH THE TfCHNOLD6Y WAS AVAliASLE · rnE fHENCN ALSU 8fLIEVEO tHit-Tnt PiKS COULD ANUrA TuR STEEL WDTOHS THE FRENCH lMPLiE THRDUGhDUT THEIR- oistussio THiT ' PAKISTAN A CDhTINUlNG TO RECEIVE ELP FHO I JVIUUAL • 7 • • StCRET - - • - • '-· -_··· NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION OF THE EXECUTIVE SECRHARY I - UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 I UNCLASSIFIED U f' Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018 • ' a INCOMING ' -·- _ • • • ·' Department of State TC'L-W il •'J·I' 11111 · ·_ • · ' l 11 11 1 L' 1 U • ·- ' ' - ' • · _ st CNET PAI £ vJ3 02 OF mi PAHi$ 21073 291b17Z WHO ARE ASSOCIATtC lTH URENCU a TNE F E Ch ASKEU HETHEH ACLESS ru AO AhCED TfCHNOLOGV WOOLU NELP THE PAK1STANIS to PRDUUCE A ALONER TEC ND D6Y ENTHIFUGE ·us iNbitAT THAT SUMt TECHNICAL AUVANTAGE- OULU BE GAINE0 aut JHAT 1STA E$ COULD dE NADE I MODIFYING TECHNOLD Y HETHER INCREASING OR D CHEASIN ITS SD hISTI ATIUN T E FH NCH ALSO 4SKED HY CtRTAlN FIBER AND HfSI ATEMIALS EHE NUT ON rHE u ' LlST ME ANSNE EU rhAT s E tILA ENTARY HATERIALS N ALREADY UNOEK CD TNDL ECAUS TH Y M RE ON THE coco MijA GO LI T - 9 DEPT AY HI H TU NEPEAT ThIS Ad c ANENdASSY LUNDDN AN ANtNbA SY HARTHAN - i sC• -c FD - SECRET ' NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT THE AUTHORIZATION Of THE E ECUTIVE SECUTARY ' ·- - -1' ' - I UNCLASSIFIED U S Department of State Case No M-2016-02103 Doc No C06088742 Date 01 11 2018