23 X 1981 z 13 HblO-i10PKCKOM YHueepCUTeTe COCTOMaCb HaYIl­ Hafl KOHgiepeH14Wl nOCeRUleHHafl 25-u zoooeUlUHe eeHzepCKoil pe­ eOIlIOl UU 1956 zooa KOHgiepeHijWl OIlU laCb I3cezo OOUH oeHb HO ee npozpaMMa 6blila O'leHb 06W UPHOil Ha 130npoc KTO OKa3allCJ no6eoUTeIleM OOKllaO'lUKU OTl3ellallU no-pa3HoMY HeKoTOpble C'IUTaIlU 'ITO n06eoU la KOHTfJpeeOIlI014Wl 'ITO eeHzepCKaR peeo llo­ 14UR 6bllla nOIlHOCTbIO pa30013 leH a coeeTCKUMU mHKaMU Ho opyzue CKIlOHHbl OYMaTb 'ITO OTHOCUTeIlbHafl ceo60oo Cfloea T80p'leCTea nepeOI3UJlCeHWl npeOnpUHUMaTellbCTI3a xapaKTepH aR Q l R coepeMenHOU BeHzpuu npRMoil pe3YIlbTaT C06blTUU 1956 zoOO B npoUliloM nOMepe Mbl ne'laTaIlU oea npo'lUTaHHblX Ha KOHgie­ pen14uu pegiepam HUJlCe Mbl npU1300UM I3blcrynileHUe npogieccopa KaH aOCKOZO YHueepcuTem Po6epm EIlYMcToKa B CfleoylOUlux HO­ Mepax Mbl npooOIlJICUM ny61lUKa14UIO COeJUlHHblX H a Kongiepe H14UU OoKllaOoe - Peo HCTOPHH nOAoonoc rrpeAIIpHHTHe H BOBce COMHHTeJIbno HecKoJIbKO npoIll e B3rJIHHYTb B npollIJIoe H cpaBHHTb cro C HaCTOHIllHM TorAa JICrKO 3aMCTHTb 'ITO KH3Hb BCHrpoB HHKOrAa HC Obma nOpMaJIbHa HnH HHa'iC rOBopH OC06CHHO 'ITO PC Kf MbI KOTopble HMH yn­ paBJIHJill KaK npaBHJIO HC OTBC'IaJIH HY KJJ aM HHTcpecaM H KeJIa­ HHHM HapOAa CKa KeM JICT 50 Ha3aA B CTPaHC rocrrOACTBOBaJIa apH­ cToKpaTHH KOTopaH BblpoAHnaCb B aHaXpOnl13M 11 6bIJIa 03a60'lC­ Ha JII111Ib TCM '1T06bI cnaCTH CBOH np BHJIerll a AJIH nora cACP l l1­ BaTh naTHCK AHHaMI1'IHoro XX CTOnCTI1H OHa KYJIbTHBHpOBana B CTpane caMble HH3MCHHbIC ypa-naTpHOTH'IeCKHC CTpaCTH BHHa 3a TH KcnOC nOJIO KCHHC naccnCHHH rrcpenaraJIaCb Ha CBpCCB IIOCTbIA­ HaH npoI I CHTHaH HopMa BBeAcna ObIJIa Aa Ke B CBOA 3aKOHOB KpeCThHHCTBO B 60nbllIHHCTBC CBOCM 6C3ponOTHO CTpaJI aJIO KaK Bnpo'lCM H 3a HCCKOJIbKO BCKOB AO Toro 3arJIHHYB B rrpollIJIOC HeCKOJIbKO rJIYO Ke B03BpaTHBnrnCb K 1906 roAY TO CCTb Ha 75 JIeT Ha3aA MbI rrorraAaCM B lrroxy KOTO­ pyro HHOrAa CKJIOIIHbI C'lMTaTb Ha'laJIOM BCHrepcKoro 30JIOTOrO BeKa Po6epT EIlYMCTOK IIocne Toro KaK ObIJI 3aKpenncH KOMnpoMHcc 1867 rDAa BCHr­ pHH AOOHJIaCb nOnO KCHHH paBHoro XOTb H HCycTOH'lMBOrO napT­ qTO TAKOE HOPMA Hcpa B ABoiicTBeHHOM MOHapXH'ICCKOM COID3C IIOJIY'ICHHaH CID aBTD­ HOMHH BO BHYTPCHHHX ACJIax crroc06CTBOBaJIa nOAbcMY aKTHBHOCTH HaBpHA JIH YoM apHT Mll mK0PllilJI - nOT pynop KamuaJIH3­ nOAXOAHIlI CC MeCTO '1T06bI CnpaBJIHTb TOp KeCTBa no nOBOAY H Ha'laJIY HHAYCTpHaJIH3alum BYAanclIIT H3 rrpOBHHUHaJIbHOrO 3axo­ JIYCTMI npCBpaTHJICH B rrcpBbIH B EBporrc ropoA C CHCTCMOH MeTpo­ 25-JIeTHH BCHrcpCKOH PCBOJIIDUHH IIy6JIHKaUHH nHM opraHOM nc­ rrOJIHTCHa OAHaKo HMCHHO TorAa HHIllCTa ACpeBHH H CBOCKOPbICTHC 'laTH 20 OKTHOPH 1981 roJI a rrpaBHIlI erO MeHbllIHHCTBa BbIHYAHJIH MHorHX BCHrpoB HCKaTb yJI a­ oonrnpHoro Ha 6 nOJIOC MaTepHaJIa B KOTOPOM npeB03HocHTCH OTKpbIBIllHeCH B COBPCMCHHOH BCHrpHH AeJIOBble H q HHaHcoBbIC B03MO Kf OCTH TeM OOJICC MO KCT BOcnp ­ HI1MaTbCH KaK CBocro POJI a YHHKaJIbIlOC CBHAeTCJIbCTBO 0 ncpeMC­ '1M Ha llIaXTaX H B rrpepHHX AMepHKH MO Kf o B3BCllIHBaH rrOJIO l l1TeJIbHble H HeraTHBHble acnCKTbI BCHrcpcKoH HCTOPHH 3arJIHHYTb H eIll e AanbIll e B rnyob BeKOB 'ITO­ Hax KOTopble COBcpnnmHCb B BCHrpl1H nOCJIC TparH'ICCKHX C06bl­ ObI YOCAHTbCH 'ITO H TOrAa rrpaBHTeJIH OOJIbIll e Bcero H3 Bcex pecyp­ THH 1956 roJI a COB CTpaHbI ECJIH BCpHTb MaKJIID3HY H CCJIH AeHCTBI1TeJIbHO JIIDOaH HHq 0PMll­ rrpcHe6peraJIH H 3noynoTpeMHJIH cooCTBeHHbIM Hapo­ AOM MbI 06HapY KHM 'ITO B BCHrpHH BcerAa 6bmo 60JIbIll C HeyJI a'l­ UHH HC'ITO COOOIll aCT TO ynOMHHYTbIH peKJIaMHbIH MaTCp aJI npeA­ HHKOB '1eM C'laCTJIHBu eB OOJIbIIle JIIDAeH KarrHTYJIHpOBaBnrnx nepeA Ha3HaqCH YOCAHTb 'lMTaTCJIH B TOM 'ITO HaIlCPCKOP 113BeCTHblM OC­ 06CTOHTenbCTBaMH '1eM OBJIaAeBnrnX HMH JIO KHCHHHM B 3TOM yroJIKC BoCTO'lHOH EBponbI IlbITaIDTCH BepHYTb­ HeH3MCHHO OKa3bIBaJIHCb 06MaHYTble HaAC KAbI ArrOKanHIICHC BTO­ CH K HOpMaJIbHOH K113HH J1 rJIaBHOH H3 nOTepb POH MHPOBOH BOHHbI Ka3aJIOCb AOJI KeH ObIJI HaBeKH 3aKpbITb B03­ J1 Ho 'ITO TaKOe HopMa BpaT K IIPOllIJIOMY na Ke npH oOJIee HCHbIX OOCTOHTeJIbCTBaX HCJIerKO 6bIBaeT YCTa­ BepAHJICH pe KHM PaKOIlIH BepHYJIaCb H TpaAHUHoHHaH HeHOpMaJIb­ HOBHTb B '1CM HMCHHO OHa COCTOHT A B KOHTeKCTe BCHrepcKoH HOCTb - Bce Ke Bcero '1Cpe3 HeCKOJIbKO JIeT KOrAa YT­ IlOA HOBbIMH JIH'lMHaMH H KJIH'IKaMH HO rropa3HTeJIbHO no­ XO KaH Ha npC I l1IDID OllHTb npaBHIlI aH KaMapHJIbH rrOKYlllaJIaCb Ha 110 '1CJIOBCQCCKOe AOCTOHHCTBO BCHrpoB a TO H Ha HX I l13Hb 111 l Jr3Hb CTana BbIrnH­ Pa60qee BeHrepCKoe rOCYAapCTBO Ka l eTCH Terrepb rroTpe6HTenb­ AeTb 60nee HopManbHo qeM KorAa-nH60 rrpe K J e O l HnH HaAe l ­ C06bITIUi 1956 rOAa rrpe06pa3HnH cTpaHY CKHM paeM rro KOHTpaCTY C rrOCTOHHHbIMH HeXBaTKaMH H rrYCTbIMH AhI KOTopbIe CTonbKO pa3 OKa3b1BanHCb 06MaHYTbI rronKaMH Mara3HHOB CKa l eM B PyMbIHHH IIonwTwqecKHe AHCKYC­ PeBOmOIJ llH 1956 rOAa rronO l Hna KOHeil rrOrrbITKaM CAenaTb H3 CHH rnaCHOCTb rrOAOrqeTHOCTb rrpaBHTenbCTBeHHbIX qHHOBHHKOB BeHrpoB 6eccepe6pHHHKoB qTO Tpe60Bano 6eCKOHeqRbIX YBelIle­ KOTopbIe Bamm H HeycbIIIHoH 6AHTenbHocTH OTKa3 OT HHX 03HaMeHOBanCH KaK 6bI OTTeHHIOT BOeHH3aIJ llIO xapaKTepHYIO il nH BOCTOqHOrepMaH­ AOn l HbI qaCTO rrOHBnHTbCH Ha 3KpaHax TeneBH30pOB n03YHroM KTO He rrpornB Hac TOT C HaMH Bepa B HAeIO rrpeAaH­ CKoro pe l HMa KCTarn BeHrepCKHe carnpHKH AaBHO rrp03BanH Bo­ HOCTb eH yCTyrrHnH MeCTO Ha llIKane A06pOAeTeneH Tpe60BaHHHM CTO yIO fepMaHHIO Ka3apMoH PaCIIBeT B BeHrpHH qaCTHOH HHH­ rrpocpeCCHOHanbHOH IJ IIaTHBbI rrOAqepKHBaeT RAeonorwqeCKYIO l eCTC KOCTb TaK I e H qe­ KOMrreTeHTHocrn AKIIeHT Ha 3cpcpeKrnBHOCTb pea6HnHrnpoBan CTpeMneHHe K BbIrOAe 3a60ry 0 nHqHbIX 6narax xocnOBaIIKoro pe l HMa qeXOB H cnOBaKOB rrOHY I AaIOT Terrepb AO­ H I1enHx XOTH rrOA06HbIe rrepeMeHbI He HaX0AHnH HHKaKOH BonbCTBOBaTbCH ycnoBHHMH y60rocTb KOTOPbIX MorYT rro AOCTO­ RAeo­ norwqecKoH orropbI B MapKCHCTCKOH AorMe caMbIe rrpeAaHHbIe rrap­ TRW 3KOHOMHCTbI H HHTenneKTyanbI HCXOAHnH H3 rrpOCTOH HCTH­ HbJ rryqIlle qT06bI nIOAH XOAHnH rro Mara3HHaM qeM AeMOHCTpHPO­ lIepe3 25 neT rrocne c06bIrnH 1956 rOAa rrpeACTaBnHeTCH cOBep­ IlleHHO 6eccrropHbIM qTO BeHrepcKHH COIJ llanH3M rrOManCH AOBOAaM paccYAKa H Tpe60BaHHHM l H3HH IIpaBHTenbcTBo TaM AeHCTBHTenb­ BanH Ha ynHIJ aX 3TOT rrOBopOT BeHrepCKoro COIJ llanH3Ma K peanbHOH l H3HH Ha­ qanCH B HHCTBY OIleHHTb TonbKO OHH caMH 1968 rOAY KOrAa 6bill BBeAeH HOBbIH 3KoHoMwqecKHH HO rrbITaeTCH 3acnY l HTb nOHnbHOCTb K HeMY HaceneHHH a He YCTa­ HaBnHBaTb ee AHpeKTHBHO OCTaBIllHeCH orpaHwqeHHH HarrOMHHaIOT AeIleHTpanH3aUHIO CTapbIe CTorrTaHHbIe HO YA06HbIe AOMaIllHHe TycpnH KOTopbIe MHr­ 3KOHOMHqeCKOrO rrnaHHpoBaHHH H rroolIlpHn cTpeMneHHe rrpoMbIIll­ KO o6neraIOT M030nH HO MorYT 6bITb nerKO c6poIlleHbI ecnH Y I neHHbIX H cenbcKox03HHcrneHHbIx rrpeAIIpHHTHH 6bITb peHTa6enb­ oqeHb 3aXOTenOCb rrOIlleBenHTb rranbIJ aMH MexaHH3M H3M KOTOPbIH rroApa3YMeBan HbIMH XOTH C Tex rrop H3M HeOAHOKpaTHO rroABepranH KpHrnKe 3a rrocneACTBHHMH H3MeHeHHH H HOBIlleCTB Ha6nIOAaIOT caMbIe H BHAoH3MeHHnH B AeTanHX OH rrpoAOn l aeT OCTaBaTbCH BeAYIIIHM KpyrrHbIe B BOCTO OH EBporre cOUHonorwqeCKHe opraHH3aIJ llH I1x cpaKTopoM rrpeBpalIleHHH BeHrpHH H3 cTpaHbI pa60nerrHo rroBTopHB­ HccneAOBaHHH KOTopbIe HerrpepbIBHO COBepIlleHCTBYIOTCH 6billH Ha­ IlleH rrpoBanbI cOBeTcKoH 3KOHOMHKH B CTpaHY HOBaTOpcKH a rro­ qaTbI C KOHIJ a 1950-x rOAOB POH H MY l ecTBeHHo rrponaraIOIIIYIO HOBbIe rryrn B crreIJ llcpwqeCKHX He TonbKO BnHHIOT Ha rrOnHTHqeCKHe peIlleHHH HO HHOrAa H orrpe­ ycnoBHHX BOCTO OH EBporrbI AenHIOTCH HMH HaH60nee rrOKa3aTeneH caM cpaKT HX rrpoBeAeHHH HOMHHanbHbIM ecnH He AeHCTBHTenbHbIM nHAepOM 3Toro ABH I e­ HHH OCTaeTCH J HOIll KaAap 113 rrocnYIllHoH MapHoHeTKH OH rroA06­ HO EypaTHHo rrpeBpaTHncH B l HBOrO ManbqwIllKY a HHTOqKH rrpHBH3bIBaIOIIIHe ero H BeHrpHIO K COBeTcKOMY COI03Y BRAHbI Te­ rrepb TonbKO rrOA orrpeAeneHHbIM yrnoM 3peHHH KOHeqHO rrYTbI XOTH pe3ynbTaTbI 3THX HccneAOBaHHH EonbIlle Bcero HCCneAOBaHHH AO CHX rrop rrpoBenw H orry6nHKo­ BanH I1ccneAoBaTenbCKHH I1eHTp cpeACTB MaCCOBOH HHcpopMaIJ llH H I1HCTHTYT COUHanbHbIX HccneAOBaHHH CYlIlecTByeT H AOCTaTO Oe KOnHqeCTBO 3arrpeTHbIX TeM a MOTHBbI 3THX OrpaHwqeHHH OqeBRA­ HbI Henb3R HarrpHMep COMHeBaTbCH B 3aKOHHocrn rrpaBneHHH KOM­ 3TH CYlIleCTBYIOT H CeHqaC HarrpHMep rrpHCYTCTBHe Ha TeppHTopHH MyHHCTHqeCKOH rrapTHH B HCTHHHocrn H BenH'Um MapKCH3Ma-ne­ BeHrpHH COBeTCKHX BOHCK - HHHH3Ma B H KOHeqHO l e pe l HM rro-rrpe I HeMY He06xoAHMOCTH rrpHCYTCTBHH COBeTCKHX BOHCK Ho a6COnIOTHO HeTeprrHM K TeM KTO YCOMHHnCH 6bI B I1eneC006pa3HO­ BCe-TaKH MHoroqwcneHHbJe rry6nHKaIJ llH AaIOT rrYCTb H He rronHbIe crn il nH BeHrpHH OCTaBaTbCH B COBeTCKOH ccpepe BnHHHHH HO BeCbMa I1eHHbIe CBeAeHHH 0 TOM qTO rrpOHCXOAHT B BeHrpHH B HTore BceB03MO I HbIX KOMIIPOMHCCOB B CerOAHHIllHeH BeHr­ pHH cnO l HnaCb cpaBHHTenbHO MHrKaH H cB060AHaH CHCTeMa KO­ TOPaH rrOOlIlpHeT H crnMYnHpyeT TO qTO xapaKTepHO il nH 3arraAHbIX HapoAOB - I1ccneAoBaHHH BeHrpoB 3aTparHBaIOT rrpaKTHqeCKH Bce CTOPOHbI HX l H3HH HO H3-3a HeAOCTaTKa MeCTa MbI rrOrrbITaeMCH OTMeTHTb nHIllb HeKOTopbIe H3 HMeIOIIIHXCH pe3ynbTaTOB AenaTb H TpaTHTb AeHbrH CTpeMHTbCH K xopOIlleH l H3­ HH 113 112 Ha eHmHH KOTopble COCTaBIIHIOT CeHqaC CpeJl CTBa MaccoBoji HH4»OPMaIJ HH 44% aKTHBHOH pa60­ qeH cHnbl HapHJJ Y C JJ OMaUlHHMH 06H3aHHoCTHMH na J aeT H npoH3­ BOJJ CTBeHHaH HarpY3Ka CTpeMJIeHHe MHOrHX eHIUHH BblIIOnHHTI PalUfOIIpHeMHHKOB H TeneBH30pOB MHOrO H HaCeneHHe nrnpoKO IIonb3yeTcH HMH HeT HeJJ OCTaTKa H B ra3eTaX KOTOphIe paCC'lHTa­ HhI Ha pa3HOo6pa3HbIe BKYCbI XOTH MHOrHe cnyUlaIOT PaJJ HO H CMOT­ TpaJJ HII HOHHYIO ponb X03HHKH JJ OMa OKa3blBaeTCH B poTHBOpe'IHH C norpe6HocTbIO yqaCTBOBaTb B 06mecTBeHHoM TpYJJ e MHoBle eH­ mHHhI pa60TaIOT He palUf caMoBblpa eHHH a no MaTepHaJIbHOH He­ pHT TeneBH3HOHHbIe npOrpaMMbI TO eCTb nOnb3YIOTCH meKTpoHHbl­ 06XOlUfMOCTH TaKaH JJ BOHCTBeHHOCTb He B036Y J aeT HH npoTeCTa MH cpeJJ CTBaMH HHCPOPMaLI l'IH OOnbUlHHCTBO BeHrpoB nO-npe J HeMY HH npOTHBOJJ eHCTBHH BocnpHHHMaHCb KaK pOHBneHHe TpalUfl HOH­ HO TH KOH eHCKOH JJ onH B nOHCKaX HOBOCTeH 06pamaeTCH K ra3eTaM OJJ HaKO BHYUlaeT Tpe­ Bory TaKOR HanpHMep BbIBOJJ nOIIyqeHHbIH Ha OCHOBe npoBeJJ eH­ HblX HCCneJJ OBaHHH I1HTeHcHBHoe nOnb30BaHHe CpeJJ CTBaMH HHCPOp­ Mal HH He npHBOlUfT K nOBblUleHHIO ypoBHH OCBeJJ OMJIeHHOCTH oco6eHHO cpeJJ H HH3nrnx COl HaIIbHO-3KOHOMH'leCKHX rpyuII 06 3TOM HaH60IIee HarIIHJJ HO CBHJJ eTeIIbcTByeT TOT cpaKT qTO npOMbIUl­ IIeHHbie paoo'IHe H KpeCTbHHe He HHTepeCYIOTCH ra3eTaMH KOTopbIe IIOBblUleHHe 3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH cenbCKox03HHCTBeHHoro H npo- MblUlJIeHHOrO npoH3BOJJ CTBa He 060UlJIOCb 6e3 cepbe3HbIX CMemeHHH B COl HaIIbHOH CTpYKTYpe B BeHrpHH KaK H B nI060H JJ PyroH cOBpe­ MeHHOH CTpaHe 3KOHOMH'leCKHH nporpecc H IIOBblUleHHe lf3HeH­ Horo ypOBHH C03 J aeT Hble TpYJJ HOCTH Jl J1H eHmHH H ceMbH MHorO'IHCneHHble IIH'l­ JJ eIIaIOT OCHOBHOH ynop Ha TeKymHe C06hITHH H nOIIHTHqeCKHH aHa­ IIH3 C JJ PyroH CTOPOHbl caMble 06pa30BaHHhIe cnOH BeHrepCKoro HaceIIeHHH MeHbUle 06pa30BaHHe HHTepeCYIOTCH MaCCOBOH HHcpopMal HeH qeM IIIOlUf cpeJJ Hero 06pa30BaHHH Kro HMeeT JJ OCTyn K HHhIM HCTO'lHH­ IIocne IIpeBpameHHH nonycpeOJJ anbHOH BeHrpHH B CTpaHY rJJ e KaM HHcpopMaD HH BHJJ HMO CKenTHqeCKH OTHOCHTCH K ocpHl HaIIb­ npHCYTCTBYIOT XOTH H He BnOJIHe CPYHKl HOHHpYIOT Bce OCHOBHbIe HOH nponaraHJJ e Ha 3IleMeHTbl COBpeMeHHOH H3HH HOBbIe HarpY3KH IIa J aIOT Ha HH J HHX cTyneHHx 06meCTBeHHOH IIeCTHHrQ 1 H3Hb HaIIOIIHe­ Ha 3IIeMeHTapHOH 60PbOOH 3a cymecTBOBaHHe l1JJ eOIIorHH TaM MaJIO Koro BonHyeT Ho H OOIIee 06pa30BaHHble rIIy6 e BOBIIeqeHHhIe B 06meCTBeHHYIO H3Hb IIIOJJ H TaK e 6e3pa3IIHqHhI K HJJ eOIIOrHH H60 JJ apCTBeHHYIO CHCTeMY 06pa30BaHHH 3a rrOCneJJ HHe CTO cepbe3HblH CJJ BHr rocy­ 25 IIeT HMen Me­ OT arpapHoH JJ eHTeJIbHOCTH K HRJJ YCTpHaIIb­ HOH OT PY'lHoro Tpy J a K MexaHH3HpoBaHHoMY 3TO OKa3aIIO rnyoo­ Koe BIIHHHHe Ha CTpYKTYPY BeHrepCKoro 06mecTBa nOBblCHB 06­ pacnOIIaraIOT HeJaBHCHMblM 3anaCOM 3HaHHH HCIIOIIb3YIOT He Tonb­ mHH rrpocpecCHOHaIIbHhIH YpoBem OTKpblB HOBbIe B03MO J HOCTH KO OCPHl HaJIbHhIe HO H HeocpHl HaJIbHble HCTO'lHHKH HHCPOPMaII HH JJ JUI rrepeMemeHHH BBepx no COII HanbHoH neCTHHI e COII HanbHOH M06MJIbHOCTH • CeMLII XOTH npH 60IIee 3penOH 3KOHOMHKe B03MO HOCTeH B TOM OT­ HOUleHHH 60nbille COII HanbHaH M06MJIbHOCTb rrOCTerreHHO 3aMeJJ IIH­ I1ccneJJ oBaHHH ceMeHHblX OTHOUleHHH H nOIIO eHHH eHIriHH paCKPbIJIH CIIO HYIO KapTHHY B KOTOPOH HeYCTOH'lHBOCTb COqeTa­ eTCH C HCroBOH npHBep eHHOCTbIO K CPOPMaJIbHOCTHM 6paKa KaK HH­ CTHTYTa IIpoIl eHT KaK 6paKOB TaK H pa3BOJJ OB BbICOK a po J a­ eMOCTb HH3Ka HeCMOTpH Ha npHHHMaeMble C YBenHqeHHIO 'lHCIIeHHOCTH HaceIIeHHH 1974 rOJJ a Mepbl no B qaCTHOCTH B BeHrpHH 3a­ TpYJJ HeHbl a6opTbl K rJIaBHblM npH'lHHaM OTpHIJ aTeIIbHO BaIOmHMCH Ha po J aeMOCTH OTHOCHT xpoHHqecKYIO MJIbH H HeJJ OCTaTOK MeCT B HCIIHX H JJ eTCKHX ca J aX 114 CKa3bl­ HexBaTKY eTCH rrpe u rrOIIaraeT oonee CIIel HanH3HpOBaHHbIH xapaKTep 3HaHHH H HaBbIKOB IIpocpeCCHOHaIIbHaH CTpYKTypa CTpaHbl y e He MO eT p a3MemaTb H B03Harpa J aTb BceX Tex KTO CTpeMHTCH BBepx BbIXOJJ rQ 1 H3 rrpHBMJIerHpoBaHHhIX CIIoeB IIonyqaIOT B TaKOH 06CTa­ HOBKe OOIIbUle UlaHCOB B OOPb6e 3a caMble BbITOJJ HbIe H rrpeCTH Hble MeCTa IIpeHMYmeCTBa rroIIyqeHHble TeMH KTO ycrren BbIJJ BHHYTb­ CH B nepHOJJ 6ypHoro pa3BHTHH BeHrpHH roTOBbI rrpeBpaTHTbCH B orrpeJJ eIIHIOmHH cpaKTOp HOBoro JJ eneHHH Ha KIIaCCbI 11 Bce e HMeIOLl HeCH rrepcrreKTHBbI POCTa rrYCTb H orpaHH'leH­ Hble nOKa He rrOraCMJIH aM6HuHH yqameHCH MOIIOJJ e H H ee pOlUfTe­ 115 neiL Tpyp Ho 3aMeTHTb A'DKC KaKHc-nH60 npH3HaKH 6ccnoKoifcTBa nOllHTHKa H lleOllOrJm AHCCH lleHTCKOe llBH f eHHe no 3TOMY nOBOAY MH CTpaHbl B uenOM xapaKTepeH onTHMH3M XO­ TH BeHrpbI npCKpaCHO 3HalOT H nOHHMaIOT KaKI1C TPYp HOCTH HX Y f e I l 'T I1pe06naAaHHe cpeAH HacencHHH n03HTHBHOH TO'lKH 3PCHWI Ha 6YAYmcc COUHanl1CTlf'leCKHX 06mecTB cBHAcTenbcTByeT 06 ycncxax CCH'IaC MO f HO CKa3aTb 'ITO BCHrpbl HC OTHrOTHB ce6H CKonbKo-HH6yJ b ccpbe3HbIMH HAeonOrH'ICCKHMH 06H3aTCllbCTBaMH npHHHJIH perpopMhl cnOKoHHO BOCllHTaTenbHoM pa60Tbi rocYAapcTBa XOTH CpCACTBa MaCCOBOH HlirpOpMa­ lJ HH H BCH CHCTCMa 06pa30BaHHH HC nepCCTaIOT TBCPAHTb 0 Hc06xo­ AHMOCTH yKpCnmlTb COUHanHCTH'IeCKYIO C03HaTCJIbHOCTb pCBonIOll H­ Tpy ll OHHblH npOllCTapHaT TaK H HC 1l0HBHnCH 3TO 03a o a' HBaCT HeKOTO­ HanOMHHM CTapoc WYTnHBoe Ha6n1OAcHHe KaK Ha pa3Hbix H3bl­ pblX napTHHHblX ' HHOBHHKOB Ho C ApyroH CTOpOHbl HACOnOfH'IC­ Kax Ha3blBalOT A06bIBaHHe CPCACTB K cymecTBoBaHHIO AHrmi'laHHH CKOC 6e3pa3nH' HC Macc He npCABCmaCT HH onn03HUHH HH nOHBnc­ 3apaooTbiBaeT cams B03Harpa f AeHHe 3a CBOI TPYA rppaHUY3 ero HMH epCCH OHO BH l HMO nHllIb OTpa f aCT OTCYTCTBHe anbTcpHaTHB BbIHrpbIBaeT gagnc HCMCU BbICJIY f HBaCT verdicnt a aMcpHKaHcu cymCCTBYIOmHM HACHM H COlJ HanbHbiM CTpYKTypaM npH'lYAJIHBOC AcnaeT makcs AeHbrH LITO f C KacaeTCH BCHrpa TO OH HmCT keres ncpcrrnCTeHHC KOTOPblX onpCIlCJIHeT HbIHellIHHH 06pa3 f H3HH BCH­ repCKoro HapoAa MO f HO l106aBI1Tb 'ITO PYCCKHM npoCTO nonY'laCT nony'IKY · ­ HancpcKop MapKcHcTCKOMY nocTynaTY 'ITO 6bITHe onpCAcnH­ E l HHCTBeHHaH rpynua KOTopaH HaXOAHTCH B OTKPblTOH orrrr03H­ eTCH npOH3BOACTBeHHOH ACHTCJlbHOCTbIO BCHrpbl HanpH f CHHO CTPC­ 1I HH K rOCllOIlCTBYlOmHM COBpCMeHHblM HaCTpoCIIHHM COCTaBHJ1aCb Peel MHTCH HaHTH TaKI1C BI1Abl ACHTCJIbHOCTH KOTOPblC KaK MO f HO 6b1­ B OCHOBHOM XOTH H He HCKJIIO'IHTCJlbHO H3 Y'lCHHKOB H COTpYp HH­ CTpCC npHHOCHT OmYTHMYIO BbIrOAY I1ccncAoBaHHH nOKa3aJIH 'ITO KOB f'copra nYKa'la KOTOPbIC Ha3blBaIOT CCfiH cro IlCTbMH H BeHrcpCKHC pa60'lHC B nepBYIO O'lepeAb 03a60'leHbl 3apa60TKOM H BHYKaMH 3Ta rpynna BrrcpBbIe 3aHBHJm 0 CBOCM OTpMuaTenbHoM nOHCKaMH nY'Inmx ycnOBHM Tpy o a lITO f C KacacTcH HACOnOrHH OTHOllIeHHM K orpHUHaJIbHOH rrOJIHTHKe B CBH3H TO pafiO'lHC naCCHBHO BocnpHHHMalOT ec KaK o aHHOCTb KOTOpyIO HC CKMX BOHCK CTaBHT nOA COMHCHHC H npHHHMalOT 3a HC'ITO caMO C060M pa3YMCIO­ KOMblCJIHC rrpOHBHJIOCb B CTpCMnCHHe BCHrpoB ACnaTb ACHbrH H 6bmo nOAMe'leHO 1l0JIHTH KaMH KOTOPbIC npoBenH 3KOHOMH'ICCKHC PCrpOpMbI H Y3aKOHHnH 1982 1974 C Y'laCTHCM BeHrep­ 1968 r I103 l Hec HHa­ rOAY Ha npouecce MHKJlOliia Xa­ pa llITH KOTOPbIH HanHcan KHHry 0 TH f enOM nOJIO f CHHH pa60'lHX meCCH '1aCTHOC B OKKYlJalJ HM LICXOCJIOBaKMH npeAllpHHHMaTeJIbCTBO B pa3BHTHC JTHX roAY O f H aIOTCH o anbHcHnmc ncpeMcHbl TCHAeHIJ kiH B npcAllonaraeTcH Ha nJIOXO yrrpaBJIHeMOH rpa6pHKc HaKoHcu orrrr03H1I HOHHOCTb nOH rpyrrubl Bblpa3JmaCb B 3aHBJIeHHHX nOMCp f KH '1CXOCJIOBaUKoro rrpa Bo3a mHTHOrO iJ BH f eHHH XaPUUI 77 I1HTCPCCbI noro BeHrepcKoro BapHaHTa Orrn03HlJ HH XOTH H HC­ pa3pCllII1Tb '1aCTHbIC rpHPMbI C Orpamf'leHHOH OTBeTCTBCHHOCTblO KO­ JIerKO onpCAeJIHTb cocpeAOTO'leHbI B OCHOBHOM Ha crpcpc HiJ eOJIO­ TOPblC 6YAYT cnoc06Hbi KOHKypHpoBaTb C rocy o apcTBeHHblMI1 npcA­ niH H MopanH 3TO npWITHHMH 3TH KoollcpaTHBbl CBO JJI K MHHHMYMY pHCK HeYAa­ 11 rroTpefiMTeJlbCKHM HacTpocHHHM B rrapTMH H npaBHTCJIbCTBC KOTO­ OTKPblTblH Bbl30B KOMMCp'leCKOH opHCHTalJ HH '1M CMorYT pacnpCAcnHTb npH6bIDb npOAaBaH CBOH aKIJ ki11 TeM KTO PbIC cBHAeTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 HBHOM npcHc6pe f CHHH K CO'lTCT AJIH CC6H BbiroAHblM rpMHaHCHpOBaTb HX BbIXOA Ha pbIHOK nepBoocHoBaM Emc HCMHOrO M OTKPOIOT Ey o anCllITCKYIO 6HP y onpaBAbIBaHCb BepoHTHO HC06xOAHMOCTblO BBCCTH 3rprpCKTHBHblC McxaHH3MbI CO­ 1I HanMCTH'IeCKHX HaKonnCHHH rpHnocorpcKHM Orrno3HllHoHepoB HCKJIIO'IaIOT H3 napTHH a l fHor­ iJ a nHllIaIOT BHp HbIX nOCTOB HeKoTopblC caMble H3BCCTHble npeAcTa­ BHTcnH 3TOM rpynrrbl nOKHHYJIH BCHrpHIO a iJ pyrHc rroTcpHB pa60 TY JIHllICHbI B03MO f lWCTH 3aHHMaTbCH YMCTBCHHbIM TpYAoM I1x rrpoH3BCiJ CHWI KaK npaBHJIO Mano iJ OcTynHbI BCHrcpcKoMY ' HTa­ TCJIIO HO rry6JIHKYIOTCH nO-aHrJII1MCKH H Ha ApyrHx H3blKax HCKO­ Topble H3 HHX pacxoAHTCH B CaMH3iJ aTc 116 117 OTHOlUeHHe BllaCTeM K HHaKOMbICmnO rro cpaBHeHHIO C ApyrHMH CTpaHaMH BOCTo'llIOH EBporrbl MOJKHO Ct I1TaTb M IrKHM HHKTO H3 BeHrepCKHX HHaKOMbIen llI HX He CHAHT B TlOpbMe CaMbIM rnyMHblM Jl HCCHAeHtaM BllaCTH KaK fibI MOJI'IammO rrpeWIaralOT PaJl H Bora rrpoTectyHTe pa30filla'IaHTe rrpoTHBOpe'IHH AorrYCTHM B ABcTpallHH HHKaK L aeT pe3YllbTaTbI 'ITO nO-BHJl HMOMY H orrpeAell lleT L OBepHe HacelleHHH K PYKOBO L CTBY CTpaHbI Koropoe C BeHrepcKoH 1KH3HH Ho rrO'IeMY fibI BaM He AellaTb no Ha 3a­ rra L e - raeT BeHrpaM HaHllY'IIIDIM ofipa30M CrrpaBll llTbC II C TpY L HOH CHTY­ aAHeH KOMIIPOMHCC KOHe'IHO YHH3HTelleH H HeYAofieH HO OH KaK­ Ha L nocTpoHKOH 1956 rOAa TPYAHTC l nOM HeYKlllO I eM rpOM03 L KOH HO Bce-TaKH l H3­ HecrrocofiHOH CHCTeMbI TaM BbI HaMAeTe 60llee 3aKllIOqeHHe qyTKYIO aYAHTOpHIO L a H 3apafioTaeTe fiOJIblUe BllHHHHe nOM Orrrr03HAHH CJIeAYeT rrpH3HaTb BeCbMa orpaHH'IeH­ YCHllHH Ka L apa Hero CTpaTerOB rrpHBellH K TOMY 'ITO Terreph HbIM IIO L aBllHlOmee 6ollblUHHcTBo ee rrOTeHAHallbHbIX CTOPOHHHKOB 6ollhlUe 'IeM KOr L a-llHfio npe l l e BeHrpbI 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI B CTa­ rrpHMHpHllOCb C AeHcTBHTenhHocThlO 1 OPMOH a L arrTaAHH CTaHOBHT­ fiHllhHocrn H HaAe l HOCTH rrOllHTHqeCKOrO H 3KOHOMH'IeCKOro COCTO­ cH rraCCHBHoe rrpHcrrocofilleH'IeCTBO H MaHeBpHpoBaHHe B paMKax lHH l CBoeH CTpaHbI CIIO l HBlUHXCH yenoBHH OrrpeAemllOmHM MOTHBOM rrOBeAeHHH BYAYmee KOHe'llIO rrpeABH L eTb TpYAHO Ho CY L H no rrJIaHaM 60llhlUHHcTBa BeHrpoB CTaHOBHTCH rrOHCK YIOTHoro MeCTe'IKa B KO­ KOTopbIe Y I e Ofib llBlleHbI nOJIHTHKY BeHrpHH MO I HO cpaBHHTh TOPOM MO l lIO HaClla l l aTbCH 1KH3HblO He 3aTpat l1BaH 'Ipe3MepHOH rOJIOBOllOMKOH PyfiHK-KyfiHK cyn KOTOPOH 3aKlllO'IaeTC l B TOM nyXOBHOH mepnm Ha nopbIBhl K HeAOCTH I HMOMY 'ITofihl rrOCJIe Toro KaK 3TO rrO L TBep l l aeTCH TaK I e H OTHOlUeHHeM BeHrpOB K Bonpocy C KBa L paTHKH nepeCtaBJIeHbI BepHyn HX B HCXO L Hoe nOJIO l eHHe CAeJIaB rrpH nOM HaHMeHblUee KOllH'IeCTBO o AOBOllbHO MHOrOt l1ClleHHOM BeHrepCKOM MeHhIllHHCTBe B PyMbl­ XOAOB Terreph KOr L a ofiecrre'IeHa JIO llJIhHOCTh IlUipoKHX Macc Hace­ HHH IIpoHBlleHHH HaAHOHallH3Ma lleHHH B CKY'llIOBa TOH BeHrepCKOM l H3HH BnOJIHe B03MO l HbI H BOCTO'llIOH EBporre no Ha60lleBlUee MeCTO BO BceH KOHe'IHO He HC'Ie3alOT Ho nHThAeCHT lleT Ha- 3a L no BeHrpHH pa3HOCHllCH KllH'I HHKOr L a H TpefioBaHHH BOC­ HeKOTopbIe HHoro COPta nepeMeHbl IIpoBecTH HX On lTh-TaKH He­ JIerKO XOT l Y I e HaJIHIlO npH3HaKH 'ITO CB II3H C 3ana L OM Y L aeTC II­ coeAHHeHHH BeHrepCKOH ofinaCTH TeppHTopHH KOTOPOH BXOJl HT B TaKH paCllUipHTb npH MHHHMaJIbHOM KOJIH'IeCTBe XO L OB AeMCTBHe COCTaB PyMbIHHH CeH'IaC fiecrroKOHCTBO 0 BeHrepCKOM MeHhIllHH­ cBo60 L Horo pbIHKa rrpHHeceT BepO llTHO CBOH ITJIO l bJ CKOJIb LlaJIe­ CTBe 3a rpaHHlleH KO 3aHAYT 3TH nepeMeHbI nOKa He IICHO OrpaHH'IHBaeTC l enOBOM KOr L a-HHfiYAb 3TO rrpHrnYlUeHHe HaAHOHallbHoro C03HaHH II npOJl HKTOBaHO CTpaXOM rre­ peA rroClleACTBH IIMH KOTophle MornH fib HapYIllHTb cymeCTBYlOmee BeHrpbI MHoro BeKOB I HJ1H B Y I e He cymeCTBYlOmHX HMnep­ CKHX rOCYLlapCTBax BeHrpHH BXOAWIa TO B OTTOMaHCKYIO TO B faficfiyprCKYIO HMrrepHH HbIHe COBeTCKHH COlO3 rOTOB npHMHpHTb­ ceH'IaC paBHOBeCHe TaK I e rrpOTHBOpe'IHBO H OTHOlUeHHe K IIollblUe C O l HOH CTOPO­ HbI BeHrpbI CO'IYBCTBYIOT CTpeMlleHHIO rrOll llKOB HcrrpaBHTb rpyfibIe CH C HeH KaK C caMbiM fiJIarOnOllY'llIblM H3 CBOHX BaccallOB 3TO JIH rrpH3HaTh 3a HOPMY OIllHfiKH 3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO H nOllHTH'IeCKOrO PYKOBO L CTBa KOTO­ pbIe npHBellH CTpaHY K fiaHKpOTCTBY Ho C L PyroH CTOPOHbl eCTb H orraceHHe 'ITO COBeTCKaH peaKAH II Ha COfihlTHH B IIollhlUe MO l eT 3a­ L eTb H BeHrepCKHe peCPOPMhI H3 CKa3aHHoro O'IeBHAHO 'ITO BeHrpbl CeH'IaC l HBYT nyqrue qeM npe l l e H XOT IIT H3fie l aTb nOMex J J aJ1bHeMlUeMY rrOBbIlUeHHIO HX 1KH3HeHHoro ypOBH II IIpoTHBope'I HH KOHe'llIO OCTaIOTC II HO KaK rrperpa L a KOTOpylO ny'l lUe 060HTH qeM rnryPMOBaTb HeKOTopbIX BepmITHO He YCTpaHBaeT 'ITO llH'llIbIe HHTepeCbI OKa3amiCh BhllUe HAeallOB COAHaJIbHOH crrpaBeWIHBOCTH HO Be l b HMeHHO no rrOMO­ 118 119