Ho '1T06b1 J 06HTbC fI noro COIJ HaJIHCTbI Hy I J aJIHCb B COlO3HHKax npe l J e Bcero H3 KpeCTb fIHCTBa H HHTeJIJIHreHIJ HH obmo Ba I HO HX He ornyrHyTb peBOJIIOIJ HOHHblMH l eCTaMH H paHaTH'leCKHMH J e­ KJIapaIJ H fIMH IIapTH fI KOTOpa fl XO'leT npH J TH K BJiaCTH He J OJI I Ila renpu flaxrep CB fI3bIBaTb ce6e pyKH H J eonOm'leCKHMH nyraMH oc06eHHO eCJIH pe'lb H J eT 0 TaKOH YCTapenOH H J eOJIOrHH KaK MapKCH3M COIJ HaJIH­ 3 lI YAP lI 6EPHblTEAH 11 EfO HAcnE lI I1E cTH'IeCKHe napTHH J OJI l HbI 6bITb OTKpbITbI M fI npHBep l eHueB nlO­ Halmy C npe J OCTepe l eHH fI peBH3HOHH3M OepHlIlTeHHa HMeeT ManO 06rn ero C HbmeI IJ HHMH nOHCKaMH COIJ HanH3Ma C qenOBeqe­ CKHM nHUOM npOTHBHHKH OepHlIlTeHHa - neBble COIJ HanHCTbl ­ 6bIITH He MeHee BepHbl ueHHOCT fIM J eMOKpanmH H ryMaHH3Ma IIpaB­ Aa OHH pe J KO rOBOpHITH 06 3TOM B TeopHH HO JIHlIlb nOToMY qTO Bce HX CHITbl YXO J HITH Ha npeTBopeHHe 3THX ueHHocTeH Ha npaKTH­ Ke CpeiJ H COIJ HaJIHCTOB HHKTO He CTaBHn HX nO J Bonpoc IIpe J no­ naranOCb 'ITO COIJ HanH3M npH3BaH paClllHpHTh c pepy CB060 J b1 YT­ Bep J HTb npaBa OT peanH3aIJ HH KOTOPblX OTpeKnHCb nooepanbl TOJIbKO BparH COIJ HaJIH3Ma YTBep l J anH 'ITO 06rn ecmeHHa fl c06­ CTBeHHOCTb HeH36e l lIO npHBe J eT K 6IOpOKpaTH'IeCKOH BnaCTH nap­ HX TaKTHKa J OJI I Ha 6bITb rH6KoiL Ba l lla 6bIITa He OpTO J OKCaJIbHOCTb a nporpecc B HeH36e KHOCTH KOToporo B 1900-e rO J bl He COMHeBaITHCb HH OPTO J OKCbI HH peBH3HOHHCTbl HH KTO 6bI TO HH 6bmo Pa60'lee J BH I eHHe OCTaBaJIOCb YTonHeH no­ Ka OHO 6bIITO He3peno Tenepb OHO Y l e He MO l eT ornepraTb HeMe J ­ JIeHHble yny'llIleHH fl H elile Toro MeHee OCY l J aTb HX TOJIbKO nOTO­ MY 'ITO OHH npe J craBn flIOTC fI HITJII030PHbIMH H MeJIKHMH B CBeTe na­ JIeKO CTOHrn ero H J eaJIa B 3TOM CMbIcn Te3Hca oepHlIlTeHHa KOTOPbIH ero H npOCITaBHIT KOHe'lHa fl uenb HH'lTO J BH I eHHe Bce B CBoeH rJIaBHOH pa­ 60Te 3BOJIIOIJ HOHHbIH COIJ HaJIH3M OH YTO'IHHJI CBOIO MbICITb no­ THHHblX BepXOB KpHTHKY fI MapKca H J PyrHx OepHllITeHH HHKOrAa He BblcrynaJi npOTHB napTHH 60H Bepbl HX nporpaMMa J OJI I IIa B6HpaTb B ce6H Bce J OCTIDKeHH fI HayK H HCKyCCTB HanpOTHB OH MblCnHJI ce6 f1 npe l J e Bcero Y'laCT­ HHKOM COIJ HanHCTH'IeCKOrO 1 BH I eHH fI H XOTen Bblpa60raTb TeopHlO KOTOpaH 6bma 6bl npHeMneMa M fI ero BO l J eH OepHllITeHHy cny'la­ fICHHB 'ITO 1 BH I eHHe KOHe'IHO HY l J aeTC fI B HanpaBJIeHHH HO ue­ JIH ero J OJI I Hbl pOpMHpOBaTbC fI no Mepe ero ycneXOB 51 eme Bep­ HyCb K 06CY l J eHHIO JIOH H J eH Ho npe l J e HeCKOJIbKO CJIOB 0 ca­ MOM oepHlIlTeHHe nOCb npe J yTIpe l J aTb pa60'IHx qT06bl OHH He O'leHb BepHITH nepBO­ MaHCKHM 0paTopaM Ho OH nO J 'lHH fInC fI napTHHHbIM pelIleHH fIM Bo HMH COIJ HaITH3Ma KOrAa OHH npHHHManHCb comaCHO ycraBY OH C'lHTaJi J eueHTpaJIH3a­ IJ HIO J enOM J 06pbIM HO H3BeCTHO J ocTaTO'IHO npHMepOB KOrAa OH BblCTynaJi H 3a ueHTpanH30BaHHYIO opraHH3aIJ HlO H 3a CTporoe py­ cpe J H101O lllKOny 'ITO no TeM BpeMeHaM 6bIITO B cpe J e pa60'IHx He­ KOBO J CTBO PeBH3HOHH3M I1HTepHaIJ HOHaJIa OepHllITeHHa COOTBeTCTBOBan nepHO J y BToporo npH6JIH3HTeJIbHO C 1880-x rO J OB J O 1914 ro­ Aa KOrAa nponerapHaT Bce ern e poc - pH3H'IeCKH MOpaJIbHO H no­ ITHTH'IeCKH BMeCTe C paclIlHpeHHeM KanHTaJIH3Ma Ha6HpaJiH CHJIY npo pcoI03bI a COIJ HanHCTHqeCKHe napTHH nony'IaJIH Bce rOJIOCOB npH 60JIbllle Ka l J bIX HOBblX BbI60pax I1MeHHo n03TOMY oepH­ lIlTeHH Mor nonaraTb 'ITO He HY I Hbl HH KpOBaBble peBOJIIOIJ HH HH HaCHJIHe Bo06rn e '1T06bI J 06HTbC fI BnaCTH COIJ HanHCTbI yKpen­ JI fIJiH 6bI ee lIlar 3a lilarOM nocpe J CTBOM BbI60pOB a 3aTeM OHH 6bI npe06pa30BaJiH KanHTaJIH3M 3aKOHOnaTeJIbHbIM nYTeM B 60JIee ry­ MaHHyIO CHCTeMY 136 3 J yap J oepHlIlTeHH pO J HITCH B 1850 rO J y B eBpeHCKOH ceMbe Ero OTeu napoB03HblH MalIlHHHCT B OepJIHHe onpe J enHJI ero B 06bl'IH0 3aTeM oepHlIlTeHHa OTAaJIH B Y'leHHKH K 6aHKHPY HO K TOMY BpeMeHH Y l e np06Y J HITc fI ero HHTepec K COUHanH3MY CHa­ qaJIa ero 60JIblile MapKca npHBneKaJI JIaccanb HO CO'lH yqeHHKOB JIaccaIT fl CeKTaHTaMH OH BcrynHIT B MapKCHCTCKYIO cOIJ HaJI- J eMO­ KpaTH'leCKYIO pa60qylO napTHIO 3TO npe J IIO'ITeHHe HHTepeCOB 1 BH­ l eHH fI H J e flM CKa3anOCb H Ha ero 60nee n03 J HHX B3rIT fIAaX B 1875 rO J y oepHlIlTeHH yqaCTBOBan B fOTCKOM Cbe3 J e Ha KOTO­ poM 1 Be repMaHCKHe pa60'IHe napT8H CnHITHCb B O J Hy - COUHaJI­ J eMOKpaTHqeCKYIO napTHIO fepMaHHH CIIf oe l aB OT 6HCMapKOBCKHX aHTHCOIJ HanHCTH'leCKHX 3aKOHOB B UlOpHX oepHlIlTeHH BCTpeTHIT TaM 60raqa- pHnaHTpona Kapna XOX­ 137 6epra KOTOPbIH Ij HHaHCHpoBan eJKeHeJJ enbHHK Der krat Sozialdemo­ JIa Ha KnaCCOBYIO 60Pb6y qeM Ha TeXHOKpaTli'leCKOe nnaHHpOBaHHe XOTH BepHIIITeHH 3Ha'leHHe nora HanpaBJIeHHH nepenpaBmlBIIIHHCH Qepe3 rpaHHl y B fepMaHHIO flOCKOnbKY CBH3lf Me J y COl lianHCTaMlf BHYTPH CTpaHbI 6blnH 3aTpYJJ HeHbI 3TOT C 3HrenbcoM OHO BepOHTHO neqaTHbIH OpraH CTan BCKope CneJJ CTBHH caMbIM BaJKHbIM CBH3YIOIl lfM 3BeHOM MeJK J y HlfMlf B KOHl e KOHl OB ero nplf3Hanlf olj Hl lianbHbIM opra­ 06cYJKnaJI eIl e npOHCHHJIOCb JIH Hero nHIIIb Bno­ a MOJKeT ObITb eMY npocro He XOTeJIOCb OrOp'laTb Heco­ rJIaCHeM CBoero npeCTapeJIOro npyra H HaCTaBHHKa Ho He npoIIIJIo H rO J a rrocne CMepTli 3Hrenbca KaK OH npHHHJI­ HOM napTliH He HCHO npHBneK nlf BepHIIITeHH CHMnaHIH Xox6epra CBoeH YMepeHHocTblO Ho BO BCHKOM cnY'Iae HMeHHO ero TOT BbI­ cH ny6nHKoBaTb CTaTbH B KOTOPbIX aTaKOBan MapKcHcTCKYIO Ij HJIO­ 6pan Ha JJ OJIJKHOCTb OTBeTCTBeHHoro pe J aKropa MapKc If 3Hrenbc COIj HIO H TeopHIO peBonlOl HH OTHecnlfCb C HeJJ OBepHeM K 060HM Ho Kor J a BepHIIITeHH rrOceTHJI BepHIIITeHH He ObIn nepBblM KTO 3aMeTHn HeCOOTBeTCTBHe MeJK­ 3THX M3rpOB COl HanH3Ma B JIoHJJ OHe eMY Y J aJIOCb 3aBoeBarb HX ilY npenCKa3aHHHMH MapKca H peaJIbHblM pa3BHTHeM KarrHTanH3Ma pacnOJIOJKeHlfe B 1888 rOJJ Y eJKeHeJJ enbHHK nepeBenlf B JIOHJJ OH H Ho BbIBOJJ bl KOTopble OH cnenan H3 Toro HaonlOJJ eHHH He Bcer J a BepHIIIreMH CTaJI TaM TaK 6nlf30K K 3Hrenbcy 'ITO 6bm H36paH B yJJ a'IHbl BepHIIIreHH nepeOueHHJI JKH3HeCnOCOOHOCTb MenKoro npen­ ero JJ YIIIenpHKa3'IHKlf BMecre C KapnOM KaYTCKHM 3TliM BepXOB­ rrpHHHMaTenbCTBa H ynenHJI Cl1HIIIKOM Mano BHHMaHHH HbIM JKpel OM oprOJJ OKCaJIbHoro MapKCH3Ma B CTpyKType KanHTanH3Ma 3ro nOBepHe BepHIIITeMH orrpaB J an H3naB cepHIO Dokumente H nepeMeHaM B03HHKHOBeHHIO KpynHoro 6H3Heca MOHOnOJIHCTli'leCKHX opraHH3al HH KOOnepal HH OOHKOB npo­ des Sozialismus B KOTOPOH 6bIJIa BnepBble '1aC fH'lHO orrYMHKoBa­ MblIIIneHHOCTH H npaBHTenbCTB B03pOJKneHHIO KOnOHHaJIbHOH 3KC­ Ha HeMeIJ KaH lfneonorHH naHCHH Bce no nOJJ p06HO KOMMeHTlipOBanOCb H B TeOpeTH'IeCKOM 1890 rony CITr 6bma CHOBa neranH30BaHa HO HaJJ BepHIIITeM­ eJKeHeJJ enbHHKe Die Neue Zeit KOTOPblH H3 J aBan KayrcKHH H HOM Bce eme BHCeJIO CYJJ eOHOe cnenCTBlfe a rrOTOMY OH He rrOKHJJ an B npymx H3JJ aHIDIX C JJ pyroM CTOpOHbI BepHIIITeHH OT'leTJlHBO BH­ B AHrTIHIO BrrnOTb no 1901 rO J a OH HCrrOJIb30BaJI nOT nOJIrHH nocyr JIH H3Y'IeHlfH aHrTIlfMCKOH peBOJIIOl Hlf XVII BeKa H HarrlfcaJI BbIJJ a­ IOIIIYIOCH KHHry 0 paAHKanbHbIX rrypHTaHaX KOTOPyro MaKc Beoep IIpH3HaBaJI cepbe3HbIM BKJIaJJ OM B HayKy rro cymecTBy rrpenBOCXlf­ JJ en Ij YH J aMeHTaJlbHbIe H3MeHeHHH YCJlOBHH H 1j 0pM pa3BHTHH pa60­ '1erO J BHJKeHHH Ho 3Ta HneH 6blJla BbICKa3aHa He TOJlbKO HM CHnHeH H BeaTpH­ ca B366 TonbKO 'ITO ony6nHKoBanH Tor J a CBOIO ITpOMblIIIJIeHHYIO no TliBIIIHM ero c06CTBeHHble H3bICKaHHH BHyTpeHHero CpOnCTBa rryplf­ neMOKpaTHIO TaHCTBa C KaIIHTaJIH3MOM JIeHHHblM '1TOObl 3aTeM CCblJlaTbCH Ha Hero KaK Ha nOKa3aTeJlbCTBO B JIoHnoHe BepHurreHH BCrpe'IaJICH C KJlaCCH'IeCKOe rrpOH3BeneHHe 6blJl0 nepeBeJJ eHo J K0pAJKeM BepHapJJ OM fIloy H IIOCemaJI C06paHIDI $a6HaHCKoro 'ITO caMH paOO'lHe cnOCOOHbl BblpaOOTaTb TOJlbKO TpeJJ 'bIOHHOHHCT­ 06meCTBa OH HaonlO J aJI 3a ycrrexaMH peBOnlOl liH rro KyCO'lKaM CKoe C03HaHHe KOTOPYIO OHO IIPOBO J HJIO ero BOCXHTHJIa pecrreKTaOeJIbHOCTb 1j a6H­ BepHIIIreHH OJJ HaKO H He npereHnOBaJl ObiTb TBOPl OM opHrH­ aHl eB CTOJIb He rrOXOJKaH Ha MaHepbl HeMl eB H OH 6bIJI CHJIbHO Brre­ HaJlbHOH TeopHH OH npOCTO Ha6nlO J aJl TeKymylO npolj COlO3HYlO '1ameH nOCTeneHHblM paCIIIHpeHHeM B AHrTIHH OOmeCTBeHHoro ceK­ npaKTliKY Ho K ero ynHBJleHHIO npolj cOlO3Hble JlH J epbl He npOH­ Topa rrYTCM YKpenJIeHHH HHCTHryTOB OCHOBHblX COl HaJIbHbIX yCJIyr BHJlH oco60ro HHTepeca K a TaKJKe POCTOM neMOKpaTH3Ma B clj epe npOMbllUJIeHHbIX OTHOIIIe­ oe3 TeopHH - des Sozialismus Me J y HlITenneKryaJlaMH Bbl3bIBaJla B HHX JJ oca J y OHH OoRIlHCb peBOJIIOl HH rro Ky­ KaK ObI crropbl He OCJlaOHJIH J BHJKeHHe B rrapTHH rrO J HHllCH porroT HHH B CBoeH KHHre Zur Geschichte und Theorie 190 1 BepHIIITeHH nOJIb30BanCH TepMHHoM HX arrOJlorHH OHH BoOome OOXOJJ HJIHCb peBOJlIOl HOHHOH HJIH KaKOM-JlHOO JJ pyraH Ccopa CO'lKaM HO BrrOCJIeJJ CTBHH peumlOmylO ponb 1j a0HaHl eB B COOCT­ B Die Neue Zeit OblJlH onYMHKoBaHbl pe3KHe OTIIOBenH BepH­ BeHHOM HHreJIJIeKTyaJIbHOM pa3BlfTlflf o TPlfl aJI BblTb MOJKeT OH H IIITeHHY Era oCyJJ HJI C'be3JJ rrapTHH H OH 6bm Obi H3 Hee HCKJlIO'IeH IIpaB $a6HaHcKHH COl HaJIH3M He 6yilY'IH MaCCOBblM nBHJKeHHeM HCKan onopbl y rOCY J apCTBeHHbIX cnYJKamHX H 6narOHaMepeHHbIX ecnH 6bl He era nH'lHaH JJ PYJKOO CO MHOrHMH ee pyKoBoJJ HTenJIMH He rro J J epJKano ero perryTal li1O CpeJJ H pa60'IHx H rrpHrnaIIIeHHe B yrrpaBnHIOIl HX npe l lIpHHTHHMH BepHIIITeHH JKe HarrpOTHB OblJl rro­ BepnHHcKHH YHHBepcHTeT H3nO lfTb CBOH B3rTIHJJ bl rrepeJJ aKaJJ eMH­ rJIOmeH OYAHHMH rrpolj cOlO3HOH paOOTbI KOTopaH 60JIbIIIe rrOXOAH- '1eCKOM aYAHTOpHeH 138 BepHIIITeHH BepOHTHO ObIJI eAHHCTBeUHbIM 139 'fenOBeKOM fie3 aTTeCTaTa 3penOCTH KOTOPbIH YIlOCTOHncH TaKOH CTBHH Bcc el1 e onaCHO fiblJ10 XO lHTb B nHKeTbl H HHKTO HC CTaJI fibl 'feCTH llBallUaTb JIeT CrrYCTH Korlla fibIJIH OTKpbITbI a PXHBbI Tor­ PMCKOBaTb pa lH ClfHTaHHblX KoneeK laIIlHHe nOll03peHHH onpaBllaJIHcb He'fHaH ueJIb H fiYJlYl1 ee H fipaTCTBO pailH KOTOPbIX CTOHJIO fibl CTpeMHnCH Hcrronb30BaTb npYCCKHH MHHHCTP IOCTHUHH oCY KlleHHe EepHIIlTeHHa HalleHCb lfTO yMHpITII KpynHble MaCCOBble 3a6acToBKH B fiOJlbllIHHCTBe cTpaH fihInH nOJlHTH'feCKHe no rroBelleT K pacKony cnr EepHIIlTeHH llaJI CBoeH neKUHH aMfiHUH03Hoe KaHTHaHCKOe Ha­ 3BaHHe B03MO KeH nH HaYlfHbIH CO UHaJIH3M Ero OTBeT CBO lHJI­ HY KHbl fiblJ1H H cpnar M KO­ He 3a 3KOHOMHqeCKHe Bblrollbl a 3a rpa K laH­ CKHe npaBa 3a npaBO rOJlOCOBaTb EepHIIlTeHH Ke YTBep K laJI 'fTO peBonIOUHoHHaH PHTopHKa nap­ TO He HaY'fHO 1l0Ka3yeMaH Heofixo­ THH fiaJlee He COOTBeTcTByeT ee fiYilHHlfHOH pafioTe TO eCTb HMeHHO IlHMOCTb a MOpaJIbHbIH HMrrepaTHB B aYIlHTopliH rrpllCYTCTBOBaJIH TO 'fero napTHH He Kenana cnblillaTb OH rrpe lJ1aran cornaCOBaTb CH K TOMY 'fTO COUHanH3M - raKHe COUHan·mifiepanbHble rrpocpeccopa KaK DYHO EpeHTaHO TeopHIO C peaJIbHblMH OfiCTOHTenbCTBaMH KJIaCCOBOro KOHcpnHKTa BepHep 30MfiapT H repxaplllJ YJIbUe-reBepHHI KOTOPbIX B HaCMeIIl­ HO He 6YIleT nH npM JTOM YTpa'leHO KY Ha3blBaJIH KaTellep-COUHaJIHCTaMH Ho 3TH MeueHaTbl ofiel1 aJI 'fTO fionee Tpe3BMI MlleonorHH COUH­ aJlbHbIX MeponpHHTHH fibIJIH BeCbMa llaJIeKH OT EepHIIlTeHHa Ero fibIJIa He pecpopMa a rrpeofipa30BaHHe KarrHTanH3Ma ero HeofixOIlHMoe MY KeCTBO OH npHBJIeKna fihI fiOJIbille ro­ JIOCOB cpeJJ Hero Knacca HO noro nH XOTen nponeTapHaT e lHHCTBeHHbIH KOTOPOMY MapKC CYJIHn fiYJlYl1 ee OIlHH­ EepHwTeHH COUHanbHaH rrOJIHTHKa 1l0n KHa fibIJIa npoBollHTbCH He pallH pafio­ npellBOCxHl1 an BCeHapOJJ HOe IlBH KeHHe HO napTHHHaH KH3Hb C ee 'fHX a caMMMH pafiO'illMH To B 'feM 3TH npocpeccopa BHlleJIH Heofi­ npocpCOI03HblMH CTonOBblMH nepBOMaHCKHMH TOp KeCTBaMH H Kny­ xOIlHMoe a MO KeT fibITb H 031lopoBnHIOl1 ee perynHpoBaHHe KanH­ TaJIli3Ma lJ1H Hero fibIJIO nHillb nepBblM IIlarOM Ha 1l0JIrOM nYTH K HOBOMY Ofil1 eCTBeHHOMY CTpOIO To 'fTO OHM K laJlH OT npaBH­ 6aMH OCTaBanaCb nponeTapCKOH no neKCHKe MaHepaM Olle Klle Ofibl'faHM H B3fJlH laM Ilpe3IleHCKMH C'be31l 1903 oTBepr peBH3HoHH3M nOllaBnHIO­ TeJIbCTBa OH BocnpHHMMan KaK no6eJlY pafioqero IlBH KeHHH 1la Ke l1 HM fiOJlbIilllHCTBOM ronOCOB_ 3HaMeHaTenbHo lfTO K 3TOMY fionb­ B ero HccnelloBaHHHx '1apTH3Ma H rrypHTaHCTBa YllapeHHe lleJlaJIOCb IIlHHCTBY npHMKHynH H Te KTO cornawanCH Ha caMoopraHH3aUHIO H lleHTenbHoCTb Macc BceM rrpaKTH'IeCKHM BonpocaM HO qyBcTBoBan 'fTO rrapTHH He MO­ C EepHwTeHHoM no Ke B TaKOM cnyqae napTHH fibUla TaK IIlOKHpOBaHa KeT rrO KepTBOBaTb H leOnOfHeH KOTopaH ofieCneqHJIa eH BenH'fHe B3fJlH laMH EepHIIlTeHHa Bellb ee cofiCTBeHHaH nOBceilHeBHaH no­ I1rHaII AYJp IlPyr EepHUJTeHHa CHMrraTH3HpOBaBWHH eMY cyxo 3a­ JIHTHKa rrepeCTaJIa fibITb peBOJIIOUHOHHOH MeTM cnr - KaK rrHCaJI KaYTCKHH no peBonIOUHOHHaH napTHH KOTopaH He 3aHHMaeTCH nOll­ IloporoM MOM 31le rOTOBKOH peBonIOUHH Ho rrapTHH TaK HnH HHa'fe ee K laJIa OHa npo­ CHeTCH B OIlHO npeKpacHoe yTpO H CMoTpHTe-Ka peBonIOUHH Y Ke Ha IlBOpe 4TO Hallo CKa3aTb H cnYlfHnoCb B 1918 rOilY Ho 110 nopbI 110 BpeMeHH napTHH BeJIa cefiH TaK fiYIlTO nonarana lfTO HenpepblBHblH IIlar 3a IIlarOM nporpecc HC TonbKO B03MO KeH fIPH KaH3epoBcKoM pe KHMe HO H BnonHe 1l0CTaTO'feH napTHH poc­ na OHa Y Ke CTana CHnbHeHilleH H3 napTHii KaK nenOCb Bee rHM· He B 1903 roilY OHa nonYlfHna TpeTb Bcex ronOCOB H MO KHO fibIJIO K laTb 'ITO KOr la-HHfiy Ilb OHa nonYlfHT 51 % I1 Bce Ke '1Tofibl He COMHeBaTbCH B 3TOM KOHelJllOM ycnexe napTHH HY K laJIaCb B MapK­ CHCTCKOH TeopHH KOTopaH rrOIlTBep lHna fibl 'fTO B03Harpa KlleHO 'ITO B TeprreHHe fiYllcT KOHelfHOM CqCTe HalfHYTCH 3TH Bel1 H HallO llenaTb HO HHKTO He CTaHeT HMH fiaXBanHTbCH EepHIIlTeHH OCTanCH OIlMHOK TIOKa MHpOBaH BOHHa He 06HapY I HJla qTO rrapTHH CTana ropa31W fianee peBH3HOHHCTCKOM qeM XOTeJI fibl la Ke OH nOHaqany H EepHWTeHH corJlaWanCH 'fTO B BOHHe npOTHB KpO­ BaBoro u aPH HH O lHH COUHanHCT He 1l0Jl KeH OCTaTbCH HeHTpanb­ HbIM - YTBep K leHHe K KOTOPOMY cepllelfHO npHCOe lHHHJIHCb fibI MapKC H 3HrenbC OJJ HaKO OH BCKope nOHHn lfTO repMaHcKHc lIe­ JIH BOHHb 6bIJIH He MeHee OTBpanfTeJIbHbl 'feM u apeKHe M OTlleJIM­ CH OT napJlaMeHTCKOH cppaKUHH cnr KOTOpaH npOIlOn Kana rono­ COBaTb 3a BoeHHble Kpe lHTbl KaH3epy 3a HHM rrocnelloBaJlO He­ TanbHblC nepeMeHbl 'ITO Bce CTpa laHHH H KepTBbl B fiopbfie Y'fTCHbI B peIIlaIOl1 HH MOMeHT H B nOCnCJlYIOl1 HH rrepHoll finarolleH- 140 141 CKonbKO COu HanI1CTOB 113 Hau HOHanbHblX MeHhl1lHHCTB OKa3aJlHCh OOPbOY 3a pecnyonHKY Ha feH n enb6eprcKoM C'be3 n e napTMH npHHll­ C HHM 3aO J H0 H pa J HKanhHble neBble npOTHBHHKI1 BOHHhl OHI1 CO­ na HOBYIO nporpaMMY OCHOBaHHyIO Ha lfAee opraHR30BaHHoro OpanHCh qTOObl OpraHI130Barb HOBYIO napTHIO - He3aBHCHMYIO CO­ KanRTanl13Ma R HanpaBneHHYIO Ha pClleHRc HOBblX npooneM npo­ UlfaJl- n eMOKpaTHlIeCKYIO napTHIO fepMaHHH HC lI1f TaK oepH­ MblmneHHoH n eMoKpaTHR npe n oTBpameHRc KPR3RCOB B COUlfaJlh­ llTeHH BpeMeHHO OO'hC n HHHllCH CO CBOHMH npe I HHMH npOTHBHH­ HOM 3aKOHo n aTenbCTBe napTHll Bce eme nplfAep I HBaJlaCh oepH­ CTapblMH MapKCHCTaMH - KaYTCKHM fHnh«pcp n HHrOM Jlc­ llTeHHRaHCKOH llHHRR pe«POPMHCTCKOro COUlfanR3Ma Ho B03HHKa­ n COYPOM Xaa3e H neBhlMR pa n uKanaMH mna leHMRra R JlROKHCX­ nR HOBbie rmaHTCKMe 3a n at H KOTOPblX OH He Mor npe ll BH n eTb Ta KOTOPblC Bnocnc n CTBRR C03 n anR KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKYIO napTI1IO TPY n Bce 60nblle BTHrHBaJlCH B yqaCTHe npR aJI MHHRCTpaTHBHbIX H KaMH - XOTH HC lIIf COCTaBnHJ1a nRllb MCHhI IIHHCTBO CTapoH CIIf B HCH 3KOHOMRt eCKHX pelleHHllX BMecTO TpaHc«popMaUHH KanRranH3Ma BOnnOTHllI1Cb nY'llIIHe COu HanRCTHlIeCKHC Tpa n Hu HR fepMaHI1R OHa ObIlla pCBonIOu HOHHOH 11 nau H«pRCTCKOH OHa I1Mena KpenKYIO oa3Y TPY n OKa3aJlCH npH3BaHHblM ero cnacaTb B IIpycCHH KOTopaH ObIlla Tenepb caMOH pa3BRTOH qaCTbIO B COBerax Raete KOTophle CKna n blBanl1Cb B CTpol1TenbHOH 11 repMaHCKoro rocy n apCTBa COUHaJl- n eMOKpaTbl nnaHHpOBanH H pac­ OOOPOHHOH npOMbImneHHOCTH OHa npl1BeTCTBOBaJla PYCCKYIO peBO­ I IIHpHllH OOOOmeCTBneHHYIO COOCTBeHHOCTb oepHllTeHH KOTOPhIH rOBopRn 'ITO 1917 ro n y COOblTI1H 1918-1919 nIOu HIO Kor n a OHa pa3pa31maCb B CHnOH peBonIOu HOHHbIX OHa CTana n BI1 1 'mCH rr OHa 3aCTaBI1na n oopoe COUHaJlbHOe 3aKOHo n aTenbCTBO CTORT COTHH HaUlfO­ HallH3an uii peHXCTar no n nl1caTb BepcanbCKuH n orOBOp O n HaKO B nOM pCBonIOu HOHHOM OKpY I CHHH oepHllTeHny Bcer­ n a OblllO HC no ccoc B HOHOpe 1918 ro n a OH llblTanCH npe n oTspa­ THTb nocnellHYIO Hau HoHallH3aUHIO KOTopaH rp03Hlla no n opsaTb npoH3Bo n CTBO BCKope nocne pesonIOUlfH OH BepnyncH B CIIf XOTH He nopBan CBH3eH C HC lI1f Kor n a TaKOe nBOHHoe qneHCTBO Obi­ nO OO'bHBneHO He n onYCTHMbIM OH BblOpan CIIf HO snnOTb n o 1920 ro n a He ocrasnHn YClIJlHH npl1Ml1pl1Th ooc napTUR 3aTeM no­ nOBI1Ha HC3aBI1CI1MbiX obIlla nornOmCHa KOMMYHI1CTaMI1 Tor n a KaK BO l n u CTaporo MapKCI1CTCKOro n CHTpa KaYTCKI1H fl1J1b«pep n HHr s03BpanUII1Cb B npC l HIOIO napTUIO lSYMH ro n aMR n03 J Hee Ha TOp­ cHOBa OKa3anCH n03a n u pa3BHTHll ABTopRTeT ero onHTb norycK­ Hen aero nocne J HRe KHRrR Sbl3blBanR He n OYMeHHe OH CKOHt an­ CH B 1932 ro n y Kor n a RCTOPRH B n peoe3fH pa30Hlla nHoepanbHo­ cOUHanbHyIO lfAeonorHIO R pecnyonRKaHcKHe HllnI03HH CIIf IIeTep faH ero ol1orpa«p onpe n emm Il lIJleMMY n eMoKpaTl1t e­ CKoro COUHanI13Ma KaK BbI60p Me l ll y XaPHO n OH RMllOTeHu HR nepe n BparoM R Cn lIJlnOH npe n aTenbcTBa oomero l eCTBe no cnyqaIO CCMI1 n eCHTHnCTHH KaYTCKoro KaYTCKHH H oepH­ llTCHH BoccraHOBlIJlR CBOIO ObWYIO n PY I OY nOH n OHCKHX BpeMeH 11 Ii B03HHKaeT Bonpoc He1130e I HO nH 3TO licKnIO'IaIOT nR n eMoKpa­ OO'bHBHllI1 0 CBOCM nOlIHOM cornacl1l1 n pyr C n PyroM Qepe3 COpOK THt eCKl1e yoe l J eHHll BOHHCTBeHHOCTb 11 pelll1TenhHocTb neT BO BpeMH IOOHllCHHblX TOP l CCTB Kapno lrIMR n T HMen OCHOBa­ HHll YTBep l J aTb 'ITO oepHllTeHH o n cp l an nooe n y nOBceMeCTHO Usa B3rJUl n a Ha peBOllIOIJ HIO BepHYBllHCb B nOHO npe l HRX C n uHOMblmnCHHHKOB oepHllTeHH nonytjHJ1 MeCTO B peHXCTare R CTan npH3HaHHbiM aBTopHTeTOM nap­ CyTb peBH3RoHR3Ma COCTORT B yoe l J eHRR qro nporpecc COUH­ THH no HanorosblM BonpocaM Eme Ba l Hee Oblno 'ITO KaK ObIBI IIHH anbHoro paBeHcTBa R BnaCTH Tpy n a MO l eT ObITb n ocTRrnyT oe3 ua· He3aBRCHMbIH OH OKa3anCH Ot eHh none3eH napTHH Bee noneMHKe C cHllbcTBeHHoH peBonIOUHR 'ITO 3TH n ellH He MoryT ocymecTBI1TbCH neBblMI1 ero naM«pneTbl nora nepHo n a 3amHmanR nOBe n eHI1C nH­ n eHCTBHllMR HenpeKnOHHoro MeHbI IIHHCTBa HO HY f n aIOTCH B yqa­ 1918 ro n a 11 napnaMeHrapHoH pec­ cTMR 6onbl1lHHcTBa Hapo n a 'ITO peBonIOUHR B COUlfanbHOM CMblcne nyonMKI1 CIIf Bce eme nponaraH n upoBana B Mono n e I HbIX KpY l KaX MapK­ n on l Ha ObITh nOHRIa CKopee KaK MMTenbHbIH npon ecc t eM e n uHO­ n epOB CIIf BO BpeMH peBOnIOn HH CR3M HO K cepe n uHe 20-x BpeMeHHbIH aKT ro n OB CMCHHlla KnaCCOBYIO 6oPboy Ha 143 142 COUH3 JIH3M rrpH IJ eT IDIH BepHee CKa3aTb rrpHXOp HT He KaK JIIOl UfH COIJ HaJIbHO-3KOHOMH'leCKHe H KYJIbTypHbIe rrepeMeHbI npeo­ pe3YJIbTaT BeJIHKOrO rrOJIHTH'leCKOro cromra a B HTore cepHH weCT808aJlU 3aXBaTY rrOJIHTH'IeCKOH BJIaCTH rrpH rrpoJIerapCKOH pe­ 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX H rrOJIHTH'leCKHX rr06e lJ pa60'lero KJIacca B BOJIIOl UfH COUHaJIbHO-3KOHOMH'leCKHe H KYJIbrypHble rrpe06pa30Ba­ pa3JIH'lHbIX 06JIaCTflX ero aKTHBHOCTH HIDI lJ OJI J HbI CJle008aTb 3a HHM He KaK rrOCJIe lJ CTBHe paCTYll HX perrpeccIDi HHll eTbI H YHH J eHIDi a B HTore paCTY­ ll ero BJIHflHHfl H YJIY'IllIemrn 3a KOTopbIe 60POJIHCb pa60' He 3ra CxeMa He 6bIJIa qy J epo IJ HbIM 3JIeMeHTOM B MapKCH3Me OHa COOTBeTCTBOBaJIa BpeMeHH KOr lJ a rrpOJIeTapHaT 6bIJI ell e CJIa6 H COUHaJIHCTH'leCKOe 06ll eCTBO B03HHKHeT He H3 xaoca HO H3 HMeHHO rr03TOMY 6bIJIa IIeJIHKOM BocrrpHHflTa neHHHbIM HO IJ a J e B TBOp'leCKOrO TaKOH pa3BHToii CTpaHe KaK repMaHIDI COTpY lJ HH'leCma B 3KOHOMH'leCKOH c pepe H3 rrJIaMfl BOHHCTBeHHOCTH TBOp'leCKHX rrpe06pa30BaHHH OCYll eCTBJIfleMbIX BOHHCTBYIO­ Bce ell e HY J HO 6bllO rrOMep J HBaTb 3THM rrpopO'leCTBOM 0 ll eH lJ eMOKpaTHeH B rOCY lJ apCTBe H 06ll eCTBe KOM KaTaKJIH3Me 0 lJ He paCrrJIaTbI H 06HoBJIeHHfl HeCMOTpfl Ha BeJIH­ KaK MbI BH IJ e­ KOHTpY lJ aPbl peaKUHH fl rrpe lJ BH J Y 'ITO B KJIaCCOBOH BOHHe JIH IJ a J e rrparMaTHKH H3 COUHaJIHCTH'leCKHX rrOJIHTHKOB rrOHHMa­ lJ orrYCTHMbI JIH 'ITO rrapTHH HY J Ha flpOCTHafl caMbIe lJ eMOKpaTH'IeCKHe pOPMbI H 3TO - JIY'I­ lIIafl rapaHTHfl OCYll eCTBHMOCTH COUHaJIH3Ma peBOJIIOIJ HOHHafl pHTopHKa EepH­ lIITeHH J e C'lHTaJI 310 CKBepHbIM HaCJIep HeM rrOKOJIeHIDI 1848 ro lJ a KOr lJ a Bce pap HKaJIbI OrJIfl lJ bmaJIHCb Ha flK06HHIIeB a HeMellKHe pa­ 3TH pOPMYJIHPOBKH 6bllH rrpHrOTOBJIeHbI EepHlIITeHHoM K IllTYT­ 1989 ro IJ Y H orry6JIHKOBaHbI B KHHre 1922 ro lJ Y 3Ta KOHIIerrIIHfl flBHO 6paJIa B rrapTcKoMY Cbe3 IJ Y crrr B Was ist Sozialismus B Ka'leCTBe MO lJ eJIH B03BbIlIIeHHe 6yp a3HH KOTopafl BbIpOCJIa B rro­ pax peO lJ aJIbHOrO 06ll eCTBa H Ha6paJIa CHJIY ell e rrpH a6COJIIOTH3­ Me PeBOJIIOUHOHHbIM HJIH HepeBOJIIOUHOHHbIM rrYTeM OHa rrpH3BaHa 6blla lJ OCTHrHYTb lJ OMHHHpYIOll erO rrOJIO J eHHfl BO Bcex COBpeMeH­ HbIX CTpaHax B KOTOPbIX OHa CKYIO CHCTeMY pa3BHJIa rrpHCYll YIO eH H rrpoMbIlIIJIeHHOCTb 3KOHOMH'Ie­ MapKCHCTbI 6bllH y6e J IJ eHbI 'ITO pa60'lIDi KJIaCC He MO J eT B03BbICHTbCfl TO'IHO TaKHM J e rryTeM rrOCKOJIbKY OH He BJIa lJ eeT Cpe lJ CTBaMH rrpOH3BO lJ CTBa HarrpOTHB pa60'lHe MorYT rrpH IJ TH K BJIaCTH rrepeBepHYB HaCTaHBaIOT MapKCHCTbI - JIHllIb 06ll eCTBO C rOJIOBbI Ha HorH He 'Iepe3 rrpOIIBeTaHHe a 'Iepe3 KaTaKJIH3M Pa60'lHH KJIaCC He MO J eT BHe lJ pHTb CBOH rrpHHUH­ rrbI B rrpe J HIOIO 3KOHOMHKY KaK ee crrYTHHK rrpOTHBHHK H HaCJIe lJ ­ HHK HY J Ha rrOBHBaJIbHafl 6a6Ka KOTopafl H3BJIeKJIa 6bI HOBoe 06­ ll eCTBO H3 'IpeBa CTaporo - MapKC 6bll CJIHlIIKOM lJ OBep' HB K 3TOMY 06pa3Y KOTOPb H OH YHaCJIe lJ OBaJI OT rereJIfl MapKC COXpaHHJI 310 KOCMH'IeCKOe H HeCKOJIbKO pPHBOJIbHOe rrpe lJ CTaBJIeHHe 06 arrOKaJIHIITH'IeCKOM CKa'lKe C014UllIlb1fiJJl peBo­ JIIOUHfl 6YP J ya3HH 3aBeplIIHJIaCb ell e rrpe J lJ e 'IeM OHa lJ 06HJIaCb CHMBOJIOB BJIaCTH HO Bce J e H 3Ta peBOJIIOUHfl lJ OJI J Ha 6blla 3aBep­ lIIHTbCfl nOJlU1UlJeCKUM aKToM KOTOPbIii YHH'ITO J HJI 6bI Ha lJ CTpOH­ KY peO lJ aJIbHOrO rOCY lJ apCTBa rrapa lJ OKCaJIbHbIM 06pa30M MapKC rrpe IJ YcMaTpHBaJI TY J e p HaJIeKTHKY H Mfl rrpOJIeTapCKOH peBOJIIO­ UHH HO C O IJ HOH CYll eCTBeHHoH pa3HHIIeii eCJIH B 6YP J ya3Hoii peBO­ 144 lJ HKaJIbI K TOMY J e rrO lJ lJ aJIHCb C06JIa3HaM TpHa lJ rereJIeBCKoii p H_ aJIeKTHKH He rrorrap H caM MapKC B 3arra lJ HIO 3THX TpHa n KOTopbIe Tpe60BaJIH KpOBaBbIX Ka'leCTBeHHbIX CKa'IKOB OH He 6bll 6bI CJIerr K B03MO J HOCTflM 60JIee KOM popra6eJIbHOrO lJ BH J eHIDI B 6YAYll ee Ho pa3Be He OTBOeBaJIH pa60'lHe 6Y lJ HH'lHOH 6oPb60H 3a rrOJIHTH'Ie­ CKYIO 3KOHOMHIO rrpOJIeTa pHa Ta rrOCpe lJ CTBOM rrpO pCOI030B H 3aKO­ HO lJ aTeJIbCTBa rrpH rrOMOll H rOJIOCOB a He rrYJIb - CTBY Toro J e KarrHTaJIa - pa60'IHH lJ eHb H COUHaJIbHOe CTpaXOBaHHe 3HreJIbC B rrpep HCJIOBHH rro CBH IJ eTeJIb­ TaKHe YCTyrrKH KaK lJ eCflTH'laCOBOH Pa3Be He HarrHcaJI caM K HOBOMY H3 1J aHHIO KnacCOBoii 60Pb6bI BO DpaHUHH MapKca 'ITO COBpeMeHHoe IIJIaHHpOBaHHe rOpO lJ OB COBpeMeHHoe opY J He H TaKTHKa rrOJIHUHH rrpeBpaTHJIH CTapyIO TaK­ THKY BoccraHHH B aTaBH3M EappHKa lJ bI MorYT Cny J HTb JIHllIb KaK MeTa popa rraMflTb 0 HHX MO J HO rrpoCJIaBJIflTb B rreCHflX H rrOJIOTHaX Ho B caMbIX pa3BHTbIX CTpaHaX p HHeHHbIX IllraTax - B HH IJ epJIaH lJ aX B AHrJIHH Coe­ 3HreJIbC C'lHTaJI BrrOJIHe lJ OrrYCTHMblM 'ITO PbI­ 'IarOM peBOJIIOUHH CTaHeT rrapJIaMeHTCKoe 6oJIblIIHHCTBO HHH crrr Y J e 3aBOeBaJIa 1 MJIH 200 TbICfl'l KPH3HC HaBepHflKa Y lJ BOHT 3TO ' HCJIO B repMa­ rOJIOCOB a CJIe IJ YIOll HH K KOHUY CTOJIeTIDI caM 3H­ reJIbC Ha lJ eflJICfl YBH IJ eTb KaK COIJ HaJIH3M B03bMeT B CBOH PYKH BJIaCTb lJ eMOKpaTH'IeCKHMH Cpe lJ CTBaMH MO J eT 6bITb 3HreJIbC He BrrOJIHe OC03HaBaJI 'ITO BocrrpHHHMafl C raKHM 3Hry3Ha3MoM H36HpaTeJIbHbIe ycrrexH COUHaJIHCTOB OH TeM ca­ MbIM OTpeKaJICfl He TOJIbKO OT HaCHJIHfl H p HKTarypbI HO H OT p H- JIOCO pHH KOTopafl rrpoHH3bmaeT H TeopHIO CTOHMOCTH MapKca H ero TeopHIO rOCY lJ apCTBa 145 MapKCHCTCKaH RAeH peBOJIIOUHH IIpOpOl JllT pa3pbIB BpeMeH BHe­ IJ HaJIHCTH'IeCKOH C03HaTeJIbHOCTbIO H He06XOJJ HMOCTbIO npHBJIeKaTb JaIIHbIH IIOBOPOT HaIIpaBJIeHWI C cerowm Ha 3aBTpa Ho IIapJIaMeHT­ KaK MO I HO OOJIbrne H36HpaTeJIbHbIX roJIOCOB JJ OJI f Hbl JIH COIl HaJIH­ CKaH TaKTHKa IIpenrrOJIaraeT 'ITO OT l eJIbHble rryHKTbI COIl HaJIHCTH'le­ CTbI arHTHpoBaTb 3a IjIHHaHCOBYIO nOMOmh '1aCTHblM KpeCTbllHCKHM CKOrO 3aKOHO r aTeJIbCTBa MOrYT BBO J HTbCH IIOCTeIIeHHO H 'ITO paBHo­ X0311HCTBaM eCJIH MapKC npeJJ CKa3bIBaJI 3THM X0311HCTBaM rn6eJIb BeCHe CHJI MO l eT CnBHraTbCH OT O rQ Ioro KJIacca K APyrOMY Ha IIPO­ KaK MO I HO npHBJIetIb Ha CBOIO CTOpoHY H36HpaTeJIeH H3 cpe rQ Iero TH I eHHH ueJIOrO HCTOpH'IeCKOrO IIepHOAa KaK 6YP l ya3HlI HMeJIa KJIaCCa eCJIH MaPKC yroTOBHJI HM norpeOOHHe Me l J y HCTOpHtIe­ B03MO I HOCTb HCIIOJIb30BaTb rocy r apCTBO B CBOHX ueJIHX eme CKHX Bex JJ O TOrO KaK CHMBOJIbI BJIaCTH OKa3aJIHCb B ee PYKaX TaK H pa6o­ KanHTaJIa H Tpy r a llonycTHMO JIH JJ JIH napTHHHOH ra3e­ Tbl MaJIeHhKOro KHH I eCTBa OnJIaKHBaTb KOHl JlIHY MeCTHOrO CYBe­ ' He MOryT JJ 06HBaTbClI BJIaCTH IIOCTeIIeHHO BeAH 60Pb6y B npOMbIrn­ peHa JIeHHOCTH B rrapnaMeHTe B o6JIaCTH KYJIbTYpbI H IIpaBa BOCTH XOTlI 6bI MOJItIa BCTaBaTh Kor r a npeJJ ce Il aTeJIb JIaJIaTbI no BenH TepMHH peBOJIIOUHH HMeJI eme KaKOH-TO CMbICJ1 ero HaA­ llOJI l HbI JIH COUHaJI-AeMOKpaTHtIeCKHe nenYTaTbI H3 Be l JlH­ OKOHtIaHHH JIe KllJIO onpeAeJIHTb IIO-HOBOM ' OH 60JIee He IIpenrrOJIaraJI BoeHHO­ Ypa 3ace r aHWI peHXCTara no TpaJJ HIl HH npOB03rnarnaeT KaH3epy fuH MOJI'Ia CHJJ eTb fuH Ka KJJ LIH pa3 IIOKHJJ aTb IIOJIHTH'IeCKOH aKIl HH KOTOPaH npH3BaHa ocymecTBHTb HeMeJJ JIeH­ 3aJI B 3HaK npOTeCTa MO l eT JIH napTHliHaH ra3eTa H3 HOMepa B HO­ HyIO Mep nepeIIe'laTbIBaTb I epMHHaJIb 30J11l rJJ e OTBa I Hble npOJIeTa­ CMeHY pe I HMa PeBOJIIOIl HlI B nOM HOBOM CMbICJ1e nOJJ pa3y­ MeBaJIa 3aTH l HyIO 6oPb6y Ha poTlI I eHHH MHOrHX napJIaMeHTCKHX pHH ceCCHH 3a IIpe06pa30BaHHe tIaCTHO-IIpenrrpHHHMaTeJIbCKOH 3KOHOMH­ lllHBaThClI B MeJIK06yp a3HOe JJ eJIO KaJIHTaHa llpeHljlyca KH B CMernaHHYIO CHCTeMY npH KOTOPOH tIaCTHall H KOOIIepaTHBHall M 'HHIl HIIaJIbHall H306pa l aIOTClI 6e3 npHKpac 11 JJ OJI I HbI JIH COIl HaJIHCTbl BMe­ Bo Bcex 3THX cny'lallX HHTepeCbI nporpecca Tpe60BaJIH nOJJ Aep 3­ H rocy r apCTBeHHaH 1jI0PMbI co6CTBeHHOCTH Bce HH1I OTHorneHHH co CTapblM pe I HMOM KOTOPblH 6bIJI oCKop6HTeJIeH BMeCTe IIepe l HBaH IIPOUecc JJ eMOKpaTH3aIl HH 6YAYT KOHKypHPO­ JJ J11I 3THKH H 3CTeTHKH KJIaCCOBO C03HaTeJIhHOrO npoJIeTapHaTa BaTb Me l J y C060H TO l e caMoe 6YAeT cOBeprnaTbClI H co BceMH HaKO nparMaTHKH cpe J H npoljlcoI03HbiX JIHJJ epOB He 3aAYMbIBa­ JJ pyrHMH 06mecTBeHHbIMH ljIyHKIl HJIMH KnaccoBbIe Pa3JIH'lWI 6YAYT JIHCh l epTBOBaTh HAeOJIOrHeH paJJ H peaJIhHOrO YKpellJ1eHWI CBoeH BJIaCTH CTHpaTbCH IIOKa BOBce He HC'Ie3HYT PeBOJIIOIl HJI TaKHM 06pa30M ­ no JJ J1HTeJIbHbIH IIPOUeCC a He eJJ HHO l J bI IIpeJJ IIpHHHMaeMoe XHPYP­ rH'leCKOe BMernaTeJIbCTBO BcrrOMHHall H3JII06JIeHHYIO MeTaljlopy OJJ ­ Me l J y TeM nOJJ 06Hble l e HCTOpHtIeCKHe nepeMeHbl pacnpOCTpa­ HIDIH peljlopMH3M H cpeJJ H Apyrnx IIapTHH I1HTepHaUHOHaJIa Ty­ MapKca MO I HO CKaJaTb 'ITO COUHaJIH3M HeJIb311 H3BJIe'lb Ha CBeT Ke­ paTH cljlopMHpoBaJI capeBbIM Ce'leHHeM KJIIOl JlIB H3 Hee peBonIOUHOHHbIX CHH J HKaJIHCTOB Bo DPaHUHH py_ BOIIJIOmeHHe B l H3Hb OIIHcaHHbIX Bblrne HCTOpH'IeCKHX TeHJJ eH­ uHH pHHeCJIO DepJJ HHaHAY llaccaJIIO 3TOM ' MeTeopoM CBepKHYB­ HlaJIhllHCKYIO COUHaJIHCTHtIeCKYIO napTHIO HC­ KOBOJJ HMall I IOJIeM feJJ e H TIOJIeM llaljlaproM Parti Ouvries 3a­ IIHCaJIa B CBoen IIporpaMMe rneM ' OCHOBaTeJIIO HeMeIl Koro COUHaJIH3Ma IIOCMepTHYIO II06eAY I136HpaTeJIbHOe npaBO npcBpamaeTClI H3 cpeACTBa 06MaHa HaJJ MapKCOM B KpHTHKe fOTCKOH IIporpaMMbI MapKC OTPHn3J KaKHM OHO 6blJI0 IIpe l JJ e B cpeJJ CTBO OCBo60 l JJ eHHJI 'ITO pa60l Jlle MorYT POCTO JaXBaTHTb CTapbm rocy r apCTBeHHbIH anIIapaT llaccaJIh l e HaIIpoTHB YTBep l J aJI 'ITO II06eJJ HB Ha Bbl­ 60pax pa60'lHe MorYT B CBoeH 60PbOO C 6YP l ya3HeH HCIIOJIh30BaTb cymeCTBYIOmHe rocy r apCTBeHHble HHCTHTYTbI B 06'beJJ HHeHHoH He­ MeIl KOH IIapTHH Bce eme COXpaHMH MapKCHCTCKYIO TeopHlO TOp l eCTBeHHbIX CJIY'IaeB JJ JI1I HO B paKTHtIeCKHX IIoBce rQ IeBHbIX Ae­ JIax MapKCHCTCKHH ynPllMbIH rrypHTaHH3M CKopee Mernan tIeM no­ MOraJI na TeopWl Morna OIIpaBAbIBaTh KJIaCCOBYIO 6opb6y HO He HaIIpaBJIlITh ee TIonOMY COIl HaJIHCTHtIeCKHe C'be3Abl 3aIIOJIHHJIHCb 6e3Bpe rQ IbIMH cnopaMH IIO IIOBOAY B3aHMOOTHorneHHH Me l J y CO­ 146 3IOn orOBopKOH XOTeJIH KaK-TO YMHpoTBOPHTh 6eCIIOKonHbIH IIpH­ 3paK MapKca KOHetIHO B caMoAep l aBHbIX H nonyljleo r anbHbIX CTpaHaX rocy r apCTBeHHYIO MalIlHHY Bce eme npcACTOllJIO JIOMaTb npe l JJ e tIeM MO f HO 6blJI0 paCCl JlITbIBaTh Ha KaKoe-JIH60 JJ eMOKpa­ mtIeCKOe pa3BHTHe 11 JJ a l e Ha 3anaAe pa60l Jlle-COUHaJIHCTbI Bce eme IIpeJJ CTaBJ11IJIH ce6e peBOJIIOUHIO KaK OJJ HH AeHb O rQ Ia H3 pa60T KaYTCKoro TaK H Ha3bIBanaCb Ha3aBTpa IIOCJIe peBOJIIOIl HH Ho B nOBceJJ HeBHoH IIpaKTHKe MaCCOBbIe IIapTHH KOHUeHTPHPOBaJIH 147 CBOH YCHlIIDI Ha H35HpaTelIbliOH nOlIHTHKe H COl J l1alIbHOM 3aKOHO­ pa3rOBopbI 0 Il HaJIeKTHKe I1 MapKCOB 3aKOH CTOHMOCTH npenCTaB­ naTelIbCTBe JIHJICR eMY '1HCTeHllleH MeTa j H3HKOH B IO l HOrepMaHCKHX 3eMJUlX fl 1 e KOHCTHTYI J I1H 5bIlIH 601Iee lIH5epalIbHbI 3TH napTHH HHOrna nOlIYtflUIH nOCTaTOtfHO rOlIO­ liTO pa50'lHii HHKorna He nOJIYtfHT nOJIHYIO KOMneHcaUHIO COB tfT06bI C j OpMHpoBaTb 501IblllHHCTBO H na l e MapKCHCTbI-0P­ TOnOKCbl nepeCTalIH OTHOCHTbCH C nOn03peHHeM K COUHalIbHbiM pe­ 3a CBOH Tpyn j 0pMaM Po3a J1IOKceM5ypr Hatfalla CBOM naM j lIeT COl J l1alIbHaH He HY I naeTCH HH B KaKHX nenyKTHBHhlX nOKa3aTeJIbCTBax pe j oPMa WIH peBOlIIOUHH ny KpaCOtfHYIO nOlIeMliKY npOTHB EepHlllTeHHa C YTBep I iJ eHIDI tfTO 3TH nBa TepMHHa He HCKlIIOtfalOT no npOCTO 3MnHpH'leCKHH j aKT KOTOPbIH fipaBWIbHa lIH MapKCHCTCKaH TeopHH CTOHMOCTH BHJIbHa OHa O ll HH npyroH fiepen nepBOM MHPOBOH BOHHOM COl J l1alI-neMOKpaTHH CTaTO'lHa nrrH OCTaBalIaCb MapKCHCTCKOH lIa ClIOBax HO ee neHCTBHH enBa lIH on­ na CJIHlllKOM HeMaTepHaJIbHa nOKa3aTelIbCTBa HaJIH'lHH penemmHCb ee nporpaMMoH Korna EepHIlITeHH npenrrarall OtfHCTHTb MapKcH3M OT rerelIeBCKoro H 51IaHKHcTcKoro HaClIe ll HH Socialism n p 35 fipHCTpaCTHe MapKca K a6cTpaKUHHM OTBJIeKalIO ero OT 3MnHpH­ '1eCKOH CTBHe C npaKTHKoH pealIhHocTH fipencKa3aHHH KOTopbIe OH OCHOBbIBalI Ha CBOHX MHHMhlX 3aKOHax He nOnTBepnWIHCh Tenepb nopa nepeHHf K 3BOJII01 J I10HHOMY C0l J l1amf3MY re KOTopaH npOClIaBWIa HMH EepHIlITeHHa 3TO He TaK-TO lIerKO 6bIJI nOCTaTOtfHO TalIaHTJIHBb H l YPHalIHCT '1T06bI YMelIO nOlIb30' BaTbCH j aKTaMH H CTaTHCTHKOH 110 HelIOBKO onepHpOBalI HneHMH H npoCToe HarrpHMep '1aCTO npHHHMaJI 3a aprYMeHT Ero H31I0 l e­ HHe CWIhHO npoHrpblBalIO OT nBOHCTBeHHoro OTHOllleHHH K OCHOBO­ nOlIO I HHKaM pa60'lero nBH I eHHH I1x 0pTonOKcalIbHbie Y'IeHHKH YKpenHlIHCb B 061IaCTH TeopHH H BMeCTO TOro '1T06hl pa3BHBaTb CBOIO c06CTBeHHYIO rrporpaMMY EepHlllTeHH BbIHY I neH 5bID npen­ CTaBJIHTb CBOH B3rlIR iJ b1 KaK OTKlIOHeHHe OT YCTaHOBlIeHHOH nOKT­ PHHbl BpeMeHaMH pa3nyBaR MalIeHIllHe paCXO l neHHR liTO 5bl HH Ha caMOM neJIe MapKcH3M KaKHM ero EepHlllTeHH 5bIJI npenCTaBJIeH n03 l HHM 3HrelIhcoM H Kap­ 3TO 5bIlI MapKcH3M KOTOPh H npeTeHnOBalI Ha HaYtfHOCTh B TOM CMhiClIe KaK ee nOHHMalI l eCTKO neTepMHHHCT­ CKHH MaTepHalIH3M XIX BeKa CMblClI 3Toro MapKCH3Ma nrrR pa­ 6o'lero nBH I eHHH CBO ll HlICH K YTBep I iJ eHHIO 'ITO n05ena CTOlIb l e HeH36e I Ha KaK eCJIH 6bl OHa BblTeKalIa H3 3aKOHOB rrpHponbl Xo­ TH 3HrelIbC OTpHualI 6ynTO He'lTO MO l eT HerrocpenCTBeHHO BbITe­ KaTb H3 caMOH Il HalIeKTHKH HarrpHMep B AHTH-JIlOpHHre HMeHHO EepHlllTeHH nOCTaBHlI Bonpoc a K '1eMY l e Torna Bo06me 148 KpeCTbHHe lie pa30PHJIHCh CpeiJ IlHH KJIaCC 'lTO-TO MenrrHT KHH- nOCKOJIhKY EepHllJTeHH He 5bIlI CHCTeMaTH'IeCKHM MbiClIHTelIeM OH 1I0M KaYTCKHM EepHIlITeHH 3aMe­ '1aJI B CBoeM l HeBHHKe PeBH3HH H peBH3HOHH3M 3HaJI npH5aBO'lHOrO TPY­ B ero Ha­ MepeHHH He BXO ll HlIO HH'IerO KpoMe npHBeneHHH TeopHH B COOTBeT­ rrOnpa3YMeBalI MapKC rolH Henpa­ COBepllleHHO Heno­ HC'Ie3aTh KPH3HCbI He CTaHOBHTCH 501Iee l eCTKHMH KaK He paCTeT HHmeTa H He YCWIHBaeTCH rropa50meHHe KarrHTaJIH3M HJlrne He 05HapY l HBalI 51IJl30CTH K naneHHIO tfTO nOlI I HO 5bIlIO rrpoH30HTH comaCHO npenCKaJaHHHM 3HreJIbca HanpoTHB OH npOUBeTalI KrraccOBbIe pa31IHtfHH BMeCTO Toro 'lT05hI nOlIHpH30BaTbCH 050ramaJIHCb npOMe yTO'lHhIMJI TOHKHMH OTTeH­ KaMH BMeCTO Toro 'lT05bI CTpeMHTbCH K KOHUY KanHTalIH3M no­ cpenCTBOM KapTelIeH Kpenl-lTa nOMep l KH KpeCTbHHCKHX XO­ 3HHCTB COUHalIhHOH nOlIHTHKH HaYtfHlICH npeOnOlIeBaTb KpH3HCbI Cpe l HHH KlIacc OTHlOnb He HC'le3aJI Hao60poT ero pacllIHpeHHe npH­ naBalIO KpenoCTb 3KOHOMH'leCKOH CrpYKType H CMHr'laJIO npOH3BOn­ CTBeHHbie UHKlIbI Pa60'lHe HaXOnWIH Tenepb 601Ibille B03MO I HocTeH KpenHTb CBOH pHiJ b1 H n05HBaTbCH KOMnpoMHccoB C KaIIHlaJIHCTH'leCKOH CHCTe­ MOH a COUHalIHCTaM Bce IpY l Hee CTaHOBHJIOCh nponoBenOBalb He06XO l HMOCTb TOTalIbHOrO B3pblBa TO eClb peBOJIIOUHH CTalIH noro­ BapHBaTb 0 B03MO I HOCTH OpraHH'leCKOH TpaHc j opMaUHH Hinein­ wachsen 'lero BrrpO'leM HHKOma He nenan caM EepHllJTeHH Ho OCTaBalIOCb HeHCHO nepepaclaeT lIH KaIIHTaJIH3M caM no ce5e B CBoero pona rocynapcTBO Bce05LQeH 05eCne'leHHOCTH HnH pa60tfHe ananTHpYIOTCH K KanHlalIH3MY B 1I1050M ClIY'lae YClIOBHH KlIacco­ BOH 50Pb5bl CO BpeMeH KOMMYHHCTH'leCKOrO MaHH j eCTa KOTO­ 149 •'I • 1 1 t I i pblR BCe elUe OCTaBanCH 6a3HCOM H HCTOlfHHKOM TeOpeTH'IeCKOH 'Ia­ CTH lIpOrpaMMbI lIPHHHTOH cnr B 1891 KPH3Hca HH OTlJaHHHOrO 6pocKa repMaHHH B MHpoBYlO lIOJIHTHKY H rOAY B 3p PYPTe peIIillTeJIb­ ApyrHX CHMIITOMOB KOTopble CBHAeTeJIbCTBOBaJIH 'ITO MHp CTaJI CaM EepHlUTeRH HalIHcaJI BTOpylO lIpaKm'leCKYlO 'IaCTb 3TOH KOM lIOCBlllUeHHOM O'IHlUeHHlO ropH30HTOB JIH TPY Ia lIpH IIJIOAO­ HO H3MemtnHCb CJIHIIIKOM TeceH JIH HaUHOHaJIbHOrO KalIHraJIH3Ma B KHHre Il eJIH­ lIporpaMMbI Tpe60BaHHH KOTOPOH OXBaTbIBaJIH H Bce06lUHe paB­ HOCHlUeM H YCHJIHBalOlUeMCH KalIHTaJIH3Me TPYAHO O l H IaTb Mpa'l­ Hble BbI60pbI rrpH TaiiHOM rOJIOCOBaHHH H lIOAOXOAHbIii HaJIor H HbIX lIpeA'lYBCTBHH Ha L BHralOlUemCH KpH3Hca 3BOJIIOIl HOHHbIR CO­ a l e OnJIa'leHHbIe lIOXOpoHbI HH O HO H3 JTHX Tpe60BaHHH He UHaJIH3M EepHIIITeiiHa He 6YAY'IH KOHCTPYKTHBHOR KHHrOR KaK 6bIJIO HeKOTopbIe CKJIOHHbI ero BOClIpHHHMaTb Il eJIHKOM lIpHHa JIe l HT TaK B3pbIB'IaTO TaK TpaHCIl eH eHTHO KaK 3HaMeHHTbIe eCHTb Tpe60BaHHH C P0pMYIIHpoBanHble B KOHIJ e KOMMYHHCTH­ 'IeCKOrO MaHH peCTa BpeMeHH B KOTOPOM OHa lIOHBHIIaCb CAeJIaB 3BOJIlOUHOHHblii COUHanH3M EepHIIITeiiHa 6bIJI lIocBHlUeH pac­ cMOTpeHHlO HMeHHO 3THX HecoOTBeTCTBHH B lIepBoii 'Iacm OH CYM­ ny 1899 rOAY CYlUeCTBeHHYlO orOBopKY Mbl MO l eM lIpH3HaTb H 3aCJIym EepHIIITeiiHa OH COKpaTHJI pa3pbIB Me l ly cOIl Han-AeMo­ KpaTH'IeCKOM TeopHeii H COUHaJI-AeMOKpaTl f'leCKoii lIpaKTHKOii OB MHpOBaJI OCHOBHble lIpHHUHIIbI MapKCH3Ma BO BTOpoii lIOKa3bIBan 3aCTaBHJI OCYAHBIIIee ero 60JIbIIIHHCTBO OTKa3aTbCH TeM He MeHee 'ITO OT 6JIaHKHCTCKHX panra3HH OB OnHCaJI pa60'lee L BH I eHHe KaKHM 3TH lIpHHUHlIbI He npHIIO I HMbl K COBpeMeHHOMY MHPY TpeTbeii B OH rOBopHT 0 lIpaKTl f'leCKOii AeHTeJIbHOCTH COUHaJIHCTOB OHO 6bIJIO B AeHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH CAeJIaB JTO OH lIpeAOTBpaTHJI lIe­ rrpo pCOlO3Hoe ABH I eHHe KOOlIepaUHH lIapJIaMeHT Oc06eHHO Kpac­ peXOA HeH36e I HOrO pa30'lapOBaHHH B lIaHHKY HOpe'IHBO lIpeACTaBJIeHa EepHlUTeRHOM lIapJIaMeHTCKaH ABH I eHHe H36erno KaraCTpo pH'IeCKHX lIpe laTeJIbCTB Ae A TeJIb­ HOCTb HeMeIl Koe pa60'lee OHO He 3Ha­ JIO HH MHJIJIbepana HH EpHana HH PaMceH MaK IloHaJIb la HH Mycco­ nHHH IleMoKpaTHH eCTb orpaHH'IeHHe KJIaCCOBOro lIpaBHTeJIb­ cma XOTH lIpeOAOJIemfe KJIaCCOBblX pa3JIH'lHii nOJIHOCTblO He AOCTHraeTCH • f136HpaTeJIbHOe npaBO lIpH AeMOKpaTHH AeJIaeT 3TO MO l HO C'IHTaTb pe3YJIbTaTOM ero 3HaKOMCTBa C peBH3H­ OHHCTCKOH TeopHeii a raK I e MYAPOCTH Ee6eJIH KOTOPbIM 06ecne­ 'lHJI MeCTO BHYTPH napTHH peBH3HOHHCTaM - TeM KTO He cneAYH 60JIee 3a MapKCOM ocranCH COIl Han-AeMOKpaTOM ee rpa l u aH ' ' eiiCTBHTeJIbHbIMH lIapTHepaMH a B KOHelfHOM c'Ie­ Te OJI l HO CAeJIaTb HX TOBapHlUaMH KPHTHKOBaTb MapKca He 3Ha'IHJIO rrpOCTO rrepeCMaTpHBaTb TO 06CYAHB CYlUHOCTHbIe B3aHMOAeiicTBHH Me l AY COUHaJIH3MOM H AeMOKpaTHeii EepHIIITeiiH rrOAxOAHT K BOlIpoCY 0 lIaTpHOTH3Me B OTJIH'lHe OT MapKca OH rrpH3HaeT 'ITO pa60'IHe HMelOT OTe'leCTBO H60 6yAY'IH lIapTHepaMH OHH AOJI l Hbl ero 3alUHlUaTb OKOH'Ia­ TeJIbHbIR pa3BaJI HaUHii KacaeTcH HeMIl eB He raKaH Y I KpaCHBaH Me'lTa qTo l e TO OHH HeCYT CBOlO OJIlO lIO'leTHOrO 6peMeHH lIO IJ HBHIIH3aTOpCKoii pa60Te B MHpe H oc06eHHO B KHTae rAe Ila l e KOr la rrOHBHIIHCb 60JIee rny60KHe HCCJIeAOBaHHH HMrrepH­ a OHH CTanH JIHTbCll B e l eHeAeJIbHHKe Die Neue Zeit - OAHO 3a APyrHM rrOHB­ EepHIIITeiiH IIITeHB OT6poCHJI MapKCHCTCKHH EepB­ M H p MapKCHCTCKHe 3aBepeHHH 6YATO HMeeTCH Bceo6'beMJIlOlUaH PHJIOCO PHH KOTopaH HaAe I HO ra­ panmpyeT a 'ITO 3a KanHTaJlH3MOM 06H3aTeJIbHO BocnoCJIeAYeT COIl HaJIH3M 6 'ITO COIl HaJIH3M 6YAeT COBepIIIeHHO He lIOXO l na KanHTaJIH3M B 'ITO COUHaJlH3M 06H3aTeJIbHO 6YAeT JIY'IIIIe HJlH Bepnee 6YAeT HaHBbICIIIeH cTaAHeii B pa3BHTHH 'IeJIOBe'leCTBa KaR3ep TOJIbKO 'ITO 3alIOny'IHJI 6a3Y B KHao'lao aJIH3Ma H KOJIOHHaJIH3Ma HJIH HAoe em rrOJIO l eHHe B CBeTe rrOCJIeAYlOlUero pa3BHTHll He CMor OIl eHHTb HX no AOCTOHHCTBY COBepIIIeHHO TaK l e KaK ero OlITHMH­ cTH'IeCKHe lIporH03b1 OTHOCHTeJIbHO KalIHTaJIH3Ma 6a3HpOBamiCb Ha EepHIIITeiin ne C'lHTan 'ITO KaKYIO-nH60 MapKCH3M clIoco6en nOATBepAHTb H3 3THX rrpeTeH3HH 'ITO OH MO l eT 6bITb OAHOBpeMeH­ HO H HaY'lHbIM H OCTaBaTbCH CBH3aHHblM C OlIpeAeJIeHHOH rrapTHeii HnH KJIaCCOM ne MO l eT no ero MHeHHIO HHKaKoii rraprHiiHoH HaYKH 6btTb BbDlomaeMOCTH MeJIKOrO lIpeAIIpHHHMaTeJIbCTBa a He Ha AeiicTBH­ TeJIbHO HOBblX HBJIeHHllX MOHOrrOJIHllX H pHHaHCOBOM KalIHTaJIe EepHIIITeiiH He lIOHHJI CMbICJIa HH 6YPCKoii BoiiHbI HH paIIIoAcKoro 150 151 KaK He MO KeT 6b1Th JIH6epanbHOH XHMHH TaKOH Ke He­ Ta KOHCTHTYU HH OT KpHTHKH CJIeBa CMhICJI KOHCTHTYU HH OH nOHH­ nenOCTbIO npeACTaBnHeTCH MHe H COLI HanHCTHtleCKaH COLI Hono­ Man Teneph KaK 3aKOHHOCTb H nopHAOK AeMOHCTpaHTOB paCCTpe­ nUl JIHBMH pa3rJIaillaTeneH BoeHHblX ceKpeTOB ca l MH 3a peilleTKY Sozialistische Monatshefte 1901 CTp IIOHH KaH pom MapKCH3Ma AO OAHoro H3 npHeMoB COLI HMbHO­ ro aHaIDI3a u eH30phI 3aTbIKanH poT npecce H TeaTpaM pacnYCKanHCb AeMOKpa­ 32 ·1 BepHIllTeHH He TOJIbKO JIHll IaJI ero npHTHraTenbHOCTH KaK nOIDITH'leCKOH QJHnOCOQJHH OH OCB060 K J an pa60'lee ABH Ke­ HHe OT HAeonorHH 6e30TBeTCTBeHHocrn a COLI HaIDI3M - OT ero npe­ TeH3HH 6bITb penHTHeH cnaceHHH TeopHH AeMoKpa11lH YTpara MHQJa 6YAeT CIDIIllKOM BblCOKOH u eHOH ecnH He HaHTH eMY 3aMeHbI IIpep naran IDI BepHIllTeHH KaKYIO-HH6YAb 3aMeHy Bcex ero pa60Tax nerKO 06HapY KHTb PYKOBOJl llIU yIO MeIO - Bo Heno­ TWleCKH H36paHHhle npaBHTeJ1bCTBa 3eMeJIb npe3MeHThI pecny6­ JIHKH npaBHnH Ha OCHOBe qpe3BhIqaHHbIX 3aKOHOB - H Bce 3TO BO HMH npaBHJIbHOrO ompaBneHHH pecnyfiJIHKaHCKHX npou eAYp Tor­ ' I II p a oooapY I HJlOCb 'ITO npH3hIBbI BepHIllTeiiHa K AeMOKpaTHH Be­ JIH He K pa3pYIlleHHIO craryc KBO B repMaHHH a K KOMnpoMHC­ cy C HHM Bo BpeMH peBOJIIOU HH 1918-1919 rr OH 3alU HIU M nOBe­ AeHHe IDIAepoB CIIr H TaKHM 06pa30M HeceT AOJIIO orneTCTBeHHO­ CTH 3a KpYIlleHHe AeMoKparn'leCKHX qaHHHH peBOJIIOU HH AeHcTBHTenhHo Ha nOBeCTKe peBOJIIOU HH U HH 1848 1918 AHH Co14U1l1luC1U'IeCKQ fI Torp a He CTOilJIa HO rop a He ocymeCTBHna Aa Ke nporpaMMhI peBOJIIO­ rop a a pecny6nHKaHcKaH nOJIHrnKa KOTOPOH npMep KH­ BanaCb CIIr Bce 14 neT BeHMapCKOH pecny6nHKH He 6hlJIa p a Ke pe­ QJOPMHCTCKoH HrIH no KpaHHeH Mepe ee MO KHO CnOJIHbIM npasoM Kone6HMYIO npep aHHoCTb AeMOKpaTHH H ee u eHHoCTHM BnpO'leM BepHIllTeHH He pa3pa60TaJI c06cTBeHHoH TeopHH Ae­ BHHHTb 3a TO I J TO OHa 6bIJIa HeAOCTaTOl HO peQJOPMHCTCKOH MOKparnH IIOA06HO ApyrHM COLI HMHCTaM CBoero nOKoneHHH OH PeBH3HOHH3M JIH 6bm B TOM nOBHHeH HnH Heycnex CIIr OKa3M­ 6hm CKnOHeH CMelllHBaTb nOJIHTH'IecKYIO H 3KOHOMHtlecKYIO AeMo­ cH pe3ymTaTOM JIH'lHbIX npoMaXOB H CTe'tJeHHH HCTopH'tJeCKHX cny­ KparnIO AeMoKparnIO yqacTHH H AeMoKpaTHIO npeACTaBHTenbCTBa qaHHOCTeH AeMoKpaTHIO KaK 06pa3 KH3HH H AeMoKparnIO KaK rocyp apCTBeH­ npep aHHaR npHHU HfIaM AeMOKpaTHH H npoBOAHlU aH HyIO cHcTeMY AeMoKpaTHIO KaK BnaCTh Hapop a H AeMoKpaTHIO CKyIO TaKTHKY COU Han-AeMOKpaTHqeCKaH napTHH KOTOPaH 6blJIa 6bl KaK MHpHoe YJIa KHBaHHe KOHQJnHKTOB KaK rapaHrnIO 3aKOHHO­ TeM He MeHee H AHHaMH'lHOH H pelllHTeJIbHOH H BOHHCTBeHHOH IIo­ crn H npaBonOpHp Ka CKpeIllHBaH TpaAHLl HH Pycco H JIaccaJIH OH rOBOpH Teopern'tJeCKH BnOJIHe MbICJIHMa MaCCOBaH 3TOMY H He 6yAY CTOJIb HecnpaBep nHB 'tJT06bI nOJIb3YHCb npoIllJIbIM nuTan nO'lrn HaHBHoe AOBepHe K npauoTe 60JIhIllHHCTBa H cnpaBeA­ ou eHHBaTh JIHBOCTH a6cTpaKTHOH AeMoKpaTHH post hoc He 06H3aTenbHO 03HaqaeT propter hoc a OH KaK H Bee COLI HaJI-AeMO­ HCTOpHtIeCKOe KpaThI 6hm y6e KtJ eH 'ITO COU HanH3M HeMbICJIHM 6e3 AeMOKpaTHH AOJI KeH 6hITb nOHHT H 'ITO AeMOKpaTHH nOApa3YMeBaeT COU HaJIH3M OKono K HeCqaCTbIO peQJopMHCT­ 3HaqeHHe peBH3HOHH3Ma B HCTOPHH peBH3HOHH3M HCX0Jl ll H3 YCJIOBHH KOTophIe CJIO KHIIHCb 1900·x rOAOB TO I J TO nOCTYIDIpOBanOCb KaK BeJIHqeCrneHHaH 3a npeAIlleCTBYIOIU yIO nOJIOBHHY CTOJIeTHH pa60'llHH KJIaCC npo­ u eJ10CmOCTh HAeH ypop nHBO Pa3ABOHnOCb Korp a TeopHH 6bma Ha­ HHKCH AeMOKpaTH'tJecKHMH CTpeMJIeHHHMH KOTOphIe yrpaTHJI cpeA­ KOHeu npeTBopeHa B npaKTHKY B 1917 roAY 60JIbIlleBHCTcKaH peBonIOLl HH BO HMH TpHYMQJa COLI HaJIH3Ma YHHqTO KHna AeMoKpa­ 1918 roAY CIIr npeHe6pema COU HaIDI3MOM qT06bI cnaCTH AeMoKpaTHIO - rnIO B HHii KJIacc OHH coorneTCTBOBaIDI ero c06cTBeHHbiM HHTepecaM H MOTHBHpoBaIDIcb nOTpe6HOCTHMH pa3BHTHH KJIaCCOBOH 6opb6hl IIpoQJeccHoHMbHhIe COI03bl 6b1ID1 3aHHTepeCOBaHhI He TOJIbKO B Ma­ H BeCbMa nOKa3aTeJIhHO TO 'ITO 6oeBoe AeMOKparn­ TepHanbHbIX BhIrop ax HO H B fie30naCHOCTH KOTOPaH rapaHTHpoBa­ qeCKOe ABH KeHHe OKa3MOCb 3aMOpO KeHO 60eBbIM AeMOKpaTHqe­ JIaCb 6hl HM CHCTeMOH 3aKOHOB KaK OTtIeTJIHBO nOHHMM no JIeHHH CKHM nOpHp KOM qeJIOBeK CKa3aBllIHH I J TO ABH KeHHe - peBOnIOU HH He COBnap aJIa C HenocpeACTBeHHbIMH HHTepecaMH pa Bce 6hIn 3aHHT Tenepb cocraBneHHeM KOHCTHTYLI HH KOTopaH He pac­ 6oqero Knacca TOJIhKO YBJIe'tJeHHble CBoeH yronHeH HHTeJIIDIreHThI u eHHBanaCb 60nee KaK 0pYAHe COU HaJIbHOH nOJIHTHKH a npeBpaTH­ CMOTpeIDI C npeHe6pe KeHHeM Ha JIeraJIH3M npoQJCOI03HbIX JIHAe­ JIaCb B u eJIh caMa no ce6e rnaBHOH TeMOH BepHIllTeHHa CTaJIa 3a1U H­ 153 152 1 pOB Ho 'IT06b1 paCTH 'lT06b1 rrnaHHpoBaTh CBoe 6YAYmee pa60'lee ABH eHHe AOn HO 6bInO CTpeMHTbCH He TonbKO K neranbHOMY rrpH3HaHHW H 3amHTe co CTOPOHbI 3aKOHa OHO AOn HO 6bInO caMO OCTaBaTbCH CTporo neranbHblM lIpeACTaBHTenH opraHH30BaHHblx pa60'IUx 3aKnW'lanH KOHTpaKTbI 3aKnW'lanH H rrOnHTH'IeCKHe CO­ rnaIlleHHH I1 Ka33anOCb BrrOnHe rrpHeMneMblM KOrAa nHAepbI pa­ 60'lero ABH eHHH Aa e rreperH6anH rranKY rro 'IaCTH neranbHOCTH H pecrreKTa6enbHOCTH - TaK HarrpaBnHHCb B peiiXCTar Be6enb Bcer­ Aa HaAeBan cppa' HyW rrapy H HaCTaBnHn MOnO ll bIX AerrYTaToB OAe­ BaThCH C AOCTOHHCTBOM I1MeHHo TaK rrOHHManH AeMOKpaTHW peBH3HoHHCTbI rrpeAIIo­ naranOCb 'ITO cymecTBywmuH rropHAOK AOn eH rrpH3HaTb pa60'lee ABU eHHe KaK CBoero paBHorrpaBHoro rrapTHepa a cneAOBaTenbHO pa60'lee ABH eHHe caMO 06H3aHO CTaTb OTBeTCTBeHHblM H 3aKOHO­ rrocnyUIHblM I1 HMeHHO B 3TOM - KOHe'IHaH rrpH'lUHa rro'leMY BepH­ IllTeiiH TaK CTpeMHnCH H36aBHTbCH OT peBonwn uoHHoii cppa3eono­ rHH rro'leMY OH TaK rrpoTHBuncH crrOHTaHHbIM BOnHeHHHM pa60'le­ ro Knacca BO BpeMH peBonwIUfH He COBeTbI He BOHHCTBeHHble aKTHBHCTbI He He3aBHCHMble rrpocpCOW3b1 He ManOHaAe Hble MeCT­ Hble opraHH3an uH a rrpo'IHo ueHTpanH30BaHHble COW3b1 pa60THHKOB rrpH3BaHbI 6blnu peIllaTh CYAb6y Pecrry6nHKH EcnH rrpe l naranaCb Han uoHanu3au HH ee AOn eH 6bIn rrpHHHTb peiiXCTar KaK 3aKoH HO Ha l ne ano peIllHTenbHO oCTeperaTbCH peBonwn uoHHoro BMeIllaTenb­ CTBa B 3TO Aeno HapoAMblx KOMHCcaPOB TO eCTb BpeMeHHoro rrpaBH­ TemCTBa KOTopoe rrpaBHno AO HHBapH 1919 rOAa B caMble aP­ KHe AMH peBonwUHH BepHIllTeiiH C naKOHH3MOM AenbcpuHcKoro opaKyna cCPOpMYnupoBan CBoe orrpeAeneHHe COn uaJIH3M eCTb COBOKyrrHOCTb con uanbHblX Tpe60BaHuH H eCTeCTBeHHbIX cTpeMneHuii pa60'IUx KOTopble AopocnH AO rrOHHMaHHH CBoero rrOnO eHHH B cOBpeMeHHoM KarrHTanucTH­ 'IeCKOM 06mecTBe H CBOHX KnaCCOBbIX 3aAa'l PeBonwu HH C03Aana HAeanbHble rrpeAIIOCbUIKH AnH rrepexoAa KnaccoBoii 60Pb6b1 B rrpaBorropHAoK KOHeu rrpHcny HH'lecTBY rro­ •••••• 'IeCKaH MHCCHH HeH36e H0 AOn Ha rrpeTeprreTb rrpH 3TOM orrpeAe­ neHHble rrepeMeHbI I1cTOpH'leCKOe 3Ha'leHHe peBH3HOHH3Ma 3aKnW'lanOCb cneAOBa­ TenbHO B TOM 'lT06bI 3aHOBO rrOA'IepKHyTh BTOpyW 'IaCTb Ha3BaHHH rrapTUU con uan-oeMOKpaTWl He COIUfanHCTH'IeCKaH AeMOKpa­ THH a AeMOKpaTH'leCKHii cOIUfanu3M I1MeHHo TaKOBO 6bInO rrOHHMaHHe 60nbIllHHCTBa pa60'lHX xo­ TH neHHHCKaH HCTopHorpacpHH Aonroe BpeMH 3aTeMHHna 3TY HCTH­ RY H Aa e HeKOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHe HCTOPHKH rrpH3HaBanH ee He 6e3 corrpoTHBneHHH COIUfan-AeMOKpaTbI BOBce He rrpeAaBanH HAea­ nOB peBonwUHH H60 y e 40 neT He 3aHHManHCb ee rroAroTOBKoii OHH He pa3pbIBanucb Me AY XapH6Aoii TeopHH H CII HJInoii rrpaK­ THKH H60 pa60'lee ABH eHHe BorrnOmano cKopee HHTepecbI 'IeM HAew I1CTOPHKH KOTopble C'lUTaWT 6YATO peBonwn uH AOn Ha 3a­ ceCTb B ronOBe Ka AOrO pa60'lero 3aAawTcH nO HbIMH Borrpoca­ MH OTKYAa B3HnCH peBH3HoHH3M KaK 3Ta H3BpameHHaH TeopHH oBnaAena con uan-AeMOKpaTHeii KOTOpaH HHa'le OCTanaCb 6bI peBo­ nWIJ HOHHoii OHH Ha3bIBaWT rrpH 3TOM COBpaTHTenHMH TO rrpocp­ COW3HbIX 60CCOB lIHTep f3ii TO rrapTuHHbIX 60CCOB P06epT MH­ 'Ienc TO pa60qyw apHCTOKpaTHw JIeHHH TO H36HpaTenbHble 3a­ KOHbI H rrapnaMeHTCKHe rrOpH l KH MaCCOBoro 06meCTBa MapKY­ 3e unH rrpocTO HeAOCTaTO'lHO yMenyw MapKCHCTCKYW rrporraraH­ AY TpOIJ KuH A Ha Moii B3rnHA COBpaTHTeneM 6bIna HHep­ n uH H rronoMY OTBeT O'leHb rrpocT A rro'leMY 6bI peBH3HoHH3MY H He YTBepAHTbCH B 06'bHCHeHHH KaK pa3 HY AaeTCH HBY­ 'IeCTh caMoro MapKCH3Ma BeAb nWAH He AYMaWT 0 peBonWIUfH rrOKa HX Ha HX e 6eAY He crrpoBon upYWT H Aa e B peBonwUHH OHH rrpeAIIO'IHTaWT rreperropY'lUTb rrpoBeAeHHe ee B u3Hb COOTBeT­ cTBywmHM opraHH3an uHM Con uan-AeMOKpaTH'IeCKHe rrapTHH rrpo­ BOAunH rrparMaTH'IeCKYW rrOnHTHKY CTapanHCb C03AaTb HHCTHTY­ TbI HaH60nee 6narorrpHHTHble l nH noii rrOnHTHKH H cynHnH CO­ n uanH3M nHIllb KaK OTAaneHHblii HAean K KOTOPOMY MO HO aCHMrrTOTH'IeCKH rrpH6nH3HTbCH B xOAe rrocneAYwmeii HCTOpHH nHUHH rrepeA X03HeBaMH KOHeu ueH30BoMY H36HpaTenbHOMY rrpa­ BY rrOKOH'leHO C apHCTOKpaTaMH Ha BepIIIHHe rOCYAaPCTBeHHoii He­ papXUH Terrepb Bce yrrHpanocb B COXpaHeHHe AeMOKpaTH'leCKUX yc­ TaHOBneHuii rrpH KOTOPbIX pa60'lee ABH eHHe Morno 6ecrrperrHT­ CTBeHHO BblCT 'IIaTb B 3amHTY HHTepeCOB TpYAHmHXCH Ero HCTOPH­ 154 3TH'IeCKuH cou uanH3M KaK H y e cKa3an BOHHcTBywmHM aKTHBHCTaM HY Ha Bepa CHMBonHKa MHcp Ha060poT AeMOKpaTHH KaK cpopManbHaH CH­ CTeMa rocYAapCTBeHHoro YCTpoiicTBa oc06eHHO KOrAa OHa y e YT­ 155 BepJ WIaCb Ha IIplmll HIIaX 3aKOHHOCIH 06bI'1H0 HC BOCIIJIaMeHHeI ayX CKOllbKO 6bI l H3Heil HH 6blll0 3a Hee OTnaHO COll Hamf3M l e neHHe nOllb30BaHHJl 'IeJIOBeKOM KaK CpenCTBOM nJlH KaKoil-TO ll CJIH I' J1neH na - neMOKpanf4eCKaH HO BOBce He 06H3aleJlbHO COll HaJIH­ BHOCHT B nOJIHTH'leCKYIO neHTeJIbHOCTb H3BeCTHbrn npHBKYC IpaHC­ CTH4CCKaH EepHWTeHH - ll CHneHTHOCTH a MapKCH3M KaK BeJIHKaH IeopHH He TOJIbKO PHCY­ 'ITO 06mCCIBeHHbiC HaYKH cnoco6HbI cHa6MTb COll HaJlHCTOB npaKTH­ eT HnCaJI HO H OKpY I aeT ero opeOllOM pIillOC0 pCKOH H HCTopH4e­ 'IeCKHM HHCTpYMCHTOM nnJl nOCTH I eHHH HX ll eJIeH HO Hecnoc06HbI CKOH Heo6xonHMocm C03 l l lBaH CTmaB Toro 'ITO nOJI I HO 6blTb C onpenCJIHlb caMH 3TH ll eJIH OTKyna l e OHH Torna 6epYTCJl OTBe­ OIIHlb-TaKH B KaHTHaHCKOM L1 Yxe ClfHTaJI TeM 'ITO 6yneI Ho nOCKOJIbKY peBH3HOHH3M OIBepr HnelO napIHiI­ TOM H HBJIJlCTCJl JIH'ICCKHii COll HaJIH3M UeHCTBHleJIbHO MHOrHe pe­ HOCTH HaYKH nOCKOJIbKY OH OIKa3aJICH CMcllntBalb HaYlfHble H MO­ BH3HOHHCTbi HCKaJIH HCTOlfHHK CBoeH Bepbl B JTH'IeCKOH pIillOCO- paJIbHble CY l neHHH OH He Mor nallee KaK 3TO neJIaJI MapKCH3M IillH peJIHrHH CaMblMH H3BeCTHbIMH H3 HHX 6bUlH KaH Kopec npeTCHnOBalb Ha np04TeHHC paKTOB KOTopoe 06113aIeJIbHO npH­ H KYPT 3HCHCP TOBapHm EepHWTeHHa BOMJIO 6bl K ec MyqeHHK a TaK I C pIillOC0 pbI HpaBCTBeHHblM BbIBOnaM Ua l e eCllH 6bl HCTopH4e­ no llapmH He3aBHCHMbIX H epMaH KOH Kapll 1 oplleHnep CKHii MalepHaJIH3M OKa3aJICl1llpaB eCJIH 6bl 3a KaIIHIaJIH3MOM neil­ H IlaYJIb CTBHleJIbHO 06H3aTeJIbHO CJIenOBaJI COll HaJIH3M 4eMY EepHlJlIeMH JIe H nOCKOJIbKY OHH 6bIflH enHHCTBCHHblMH He BHneJI y6ero1TeJIbHblX nOKa3aIeJIbCTB pIillOCO paMH KOTopble HcnOBenOBaJIH COll HaJlH3M CTano npHHJlTO OIClOna cme BOBce He BbITeKaJIO 4TO COll Maml3M npenCTaBJUIeT He IOJIbKO BeCbMa 803­ CBoil rJIaBHblM Tpyn EepHWleHH n03BOJIIill ce6e 3aKOH4HTb Ka­ KCCTKHH nelepMHHH3M pIillOC0 pHH HenocpenCIBeHHbiX HaCJIen­ JIaM6ypOM MOJI0JJ bIX MapKcHcTOB na J1300BJIHHCb OT xaH I eCIBa Ma PKCHCTCKOH IIpOnaraHJJ bI - H caM MaPKC npH3HaBaJI B IlepBoM Ie3Hce 0 1 cilepooxe 4TO HneaJIH3M ny4WC 4eM MaTepHaJIH3M 060CHOBblBaJI 'IeJIOBe'lecKYIO aKTHBHOCTb PeBH3HOHH3M KOIOPblH ClpeMHJICH 06ecilelfHTb pa60­ 'ICMY J BH I eHHIO cB060ny MaHeBpa B neTepMHHHCTCKOM pIillOCO- HC HY I Jl aJICJl BOBce EepHllITeHH npHHHMaJI 3KOHOMHlfCCKoe HCTOJIKOBallHe HCTOPHH HO C cymccTBeHHoil oroBopKoM KeJIe3HaH npo peCCHOHaJIbHbIMH CBH3bIBaTb peBH3HOHH3M C KaHIHaHCTBOM MO JICHYIO HO H BeCbMa l eJIaTeJIbHYIO aJIbTepHaIHBY HHKOB MapKca cMymaJI MHOrHX 60JIee HaIopn IlocJIenHHe npHHanne l aJlH K KaHTHaHCKOH WKO­ He06xoMMOCTb nOJI I Ha 6bITb BaHa TaK 4T06bl pacwHpHTb rpaHHll bI MOJUI pHII HPO­ COll MaJIbHO-nOJIHTH'Ie­ CKOH IIpaKmKH 'I BOCKJIHJJ aJI OH ­ naBaHle OCB060MMCH H OT ee l aprOHa cant BepHeMCH Ha­ 3an K KaHTY H 6yneM pa3pa6aTbIBaTb 'nponerOMCHbi COll Ha­ JIH3Ma' KaK KaHT C03naJI 'ilpoJIeroMeHbl BCHKOH 6YL1 YmeH MCTa pH3HKH' EepHIIITeHH 3HaJI npo KaHTa H3 nonYJIHpHOH l1CTOPHH MarepHaJIH3­ Ma 1 pHnpHxa AJIb6epTa J1aHrc - HCTOlfHHKa Ha KOTOPblH OH caM 'IeCTHO YKa3aJI Ho npyrHe ero pa60Tbl He 06HapY l HBalOT HH nOHH­ 380AlOlIUOHHblU COllUilIlU3M MaRlUI KaHTOBCKOH pIillOC0 pHH HH na l C 3HaKOMCTBa C HeH qTO l e KacaeTcH COlfHHeHHiI lex Ho TeM caMblM OH HaTaJIKHBaJICJl Ha BOIIPOCbl KOTOPblC 1130 BCCX CHJI nblTaJICJl 060ilm CO l1aJIHCIOB-HeOKaHTHaHll eB KOTOPblX H TOJIbKO 4TO Ha3BaJI OHH IIbITaJIHCb CneJIaTb HMeHHO TO '110 6bVlO He­ npHeMJIeMO nnH EcpHWTeHHa nCnYll HpOBaTb COll HanH3M OIKyna l e 6CPCICJl Bawa COll HaJIHCTH4eCKMI Bepa OTKY­ H3 KareropH4ccKoro HMIIepaTHBa - npeL1 lIpHHTHe a priori B ero rJIa3aX He MeHee onaCHOC 4eM Hrpa B rereJIeBCKYlO nHaJIeKmKY K TOMY l e na HBlillaCb COll HaJIHCTH'ICCKaJl MOpaJIb H3BeCTHbI HCOKaHmaHll bI KOTopble BOBce He 6blllH peBH3HOHHCTa­ ECPHWTCHH BCC l C IIPH6JIH3HJICJl K OTBeTY B CBOCM aKaneMH'IC­ CKOH JICKll HH B03MO l CH JIH HaYlfHbrn COll HaJIH3M CaMa 3Ta KaH­ MH HaIIpHMep MaKc Annep KOTOPblii CBHJI CBoe pIillOco pCKoe me­ 3nO B cpene KpaMHe JIeBblX aBClpHHCKOH COll HallHCTHlfeCKOH nap­ THaliCKaH nOCTaHOBKa Bonpoca IIOKa3bIBaCT 4TO EepHWTCMH HCKaJI THH EblJIH IaK I e H 3IH'IeCKHe COll HaJIHCTbl HO OTBeTa HCCOMHeHHO Ubi MO I HO 3neCb Ha3BaTb XOIH 6bl TOJICIOrO ycTaBa J1aHnaY3pa nOnpa3YMeBaCI rny60KYlO Bepy B paBeHCTBO lllOnCH a TaK I e OCY I ­ OCKapa YaHJIbna EepTpaHa Paccena PaMCCH MaK UoHaJIbna npH­ 156 B KaTeropH4eCKOM HMIIepaTHBe KOIOPbIH BOBce He KaHIHaH­ 157 ' ' f 'IeM HeKOTOpbIe H3 HHX 6bmH 60JIee paAHKaJIbHbl 'IeM MaPKCHCThI r 'B- r' a HeKOTopble -- MeHee JtIcTOlJHHKH 3TH'IeCKOrO COIUlaJIH3Ma COCTaB­ i BO Bce06Illero 6JIarococToHHHH npennOJIaraeT ropa3 J 0 60JIee rny60­ KYIO KoonepaIUlIO MelKJJ Y COlUlaJIbHhlMH napTHepaMH tfeM milOT llIHPOKHH cneKTp H XOTH MapKCHCTbl 06paIllaJIHCb C KaHTOM tDlH 6bI JJ onycrnMbIM KpaHHe HeJJ 06pOIKeJIaTeJIbHO npeJJ OCTaBJIHTb eMY MeCTO B HCTOPHH TeJIH pa60'lero JJ BHIKeHHH H3 nOKOJIeHHH BepHlllTeHHa co­ JJ aIKe caMbIe pe$opMHCTCKHe npe J CTaBH­ cOUHaJIH3Ma HeT HHKaKHX OCHoBaHHH HH H rl eH BepHIllTeHHa HH CerO J HH COIUlaJI- J eMOKpaThl J OJIJlCHhl nblTaTbCH CTpaXOBaTb Ka­ MeH UlHa l opeca HJIlI KaKOrO-JIH60 JJ Pyroro COlUlaJIHCTa He Haxo­ nHTaJIH3M OT KpH3HCOB HH$JIHUHH KaTaCTpo$HlJeCKHX CJIyqallHO­ WITCH B TaKOM IKe OTHOIlleHHH K KaHty B KaKOM MapKCHCTbl Haxo­ CTeH HeB3rOJJ crapocrn H T JJ OHH JJ OJIJlCHbI ynpaBJIHTh TaK 'lT06bI WITCH K fereJIIO MexaHHKa HX MblllIJIeHHH HHKOHM 06pa30M He CBH3aHa C 3THM MbICJIHTeJIeM Ho XOTH no JaCTaBHTb CHCTeMY pa60Tan a He npe06pa30BbiBaTb ee npe06pa­ 30BaHHH CTHMYJIHpYIOTCH Tenepb HHatfe He 06nHCHeHO CaMHM BepHIllTeHHOM H He 06HaPY­ MeIKJJ YHaPOJJ HbIMH Kopno­ paUHHMIf COlUlaJIHCrn'leCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCmaMH HaIUlOHaJIbHbIMH KHBaeTCH CTHJIeM ero $HJIOCO$cTBoBaHHH H JJ YMalO 'ITO He TaK YIK peBOJIIOIUlHMH H MeIKJJ YHapO J HbIMH 0praHH3aIUlHMH nporpaMMbI CJIOJICHO KOTopble B HalliH JJ HH JJ OJIJlCHbI npe J JIaraTh H OCYIlleCTBJIHTb COIUlaJI­ peIllHTb cnop HaC'IeT HCTOKOB 6epHIllTeHHHaHCKoro CO­ lUIaJIH3Ma OH 6bIJI rny60Ko CBH3aH C pa60'IHM JJ BHIKeHHeM OH 6bIJI J eMoKpaTbI TOIKe ropa3 J 0 60JIee np0JaHlJHhl tfeM 'lTo-JIH60 MbICJIH­ ero 'laCThIO H BbITeKaJI H3 OnbITa ero PHJJ OBbIX yqaCTHHKOB T eopHH Moe BO BpeMeHa BepHlllTeHHa HalUlOHaJIbHOe llJIaHHpoBaHHe npo­ BepHIllTeHHa OTpaIKaJIH nOHHMaHHe CMblCJIa JJ BHIKeHHH caMHMH pa- MbIIIIJIeHHOCrn H ceJIbCKOrO X03HH CTBa PYKOBO J CTBO HaIUlOHaJIH­ 6o'IHMH OH H3BJIeKaJI CBOH 3TH'IeCKHe npe J fmcaHHH H3 JlCH3HH nap­ 3HpoBaHHbIMH THH Ero ueHHOCTH 3TO COllUOOPHOCTb cnpa6eOllU60CTb pa6eHCT­ OTpaCJIHMH npOMblllIJIeHHOCrn nepepacrrpe J eJIeHHe J OXO J OB 06IllecTBeHHoe 3 J paBOOXpaHeHHe J OMoCTpoHTeJIbCTBO H 60 0006000 npozpecc TaKOBbI IKe H 3K3eCTeHIUlaJIbHble JJ eTepMH­ J pyme HaHTbI opraHH3alUlH pa60'lero KJIacca 3TO - Y'lacTHe pa60'IHx B ynpaBJIeHHH KopnOpaUHHMH Bee 310 rro 60JIb­ He a6CTpaKTHbIe $HllO­ rry6JIHlJHbIe c$epbI 06crryJICHBaHHH perYJIHpOBaHHe ueH OHH He 3aJJ aHbI Illell 'laCTH Tpe6yeT COTpY J HHlJeCTBa a He KOH$poHTaIUlH JII060H HO onpeJJ eJIHIOTCH TeM Arbeiterwelt B KOTOPOM IKHBeT JII060H pa60­ KOH$JIHKT HHTepeCOB HJIH KOHuenmm JJ OJIIKeH peIIIaThCH nYTeM ne­ qIDf OHH COCTaBJIHIOT npHHlU1llbl KOTOPbIMH PYKOBo J cTByeTcH JJ BH­ perOBopoB IKeHHe HanpaBJIHIOT era PeaJIH3M BepHIllTeHHa - 6bl CHJI co$CKHe nOHHTHH H OHH HeJJ eJJ YIUIPYIOTCH a priori 'IeCTBO HO rH6KOCTb He npHcnoc06JIeH­ PeBH3HOHH3M 'laCTO 06BHHHJIH B OnnopTYHH3­ H ap6HTpaJKa He J OBO lJ l J O B3pbIBa J O OTKPbITOH npo­ Pe$OpMHCTCKaH rrOJIHTHKa rrepBOH nOJIOBHHbl CTOJIeTHH 6bma AHrJIHH HJIH Kypra 3HCHepa B BaBapHH BO BpeMH nepBOH MHPO­ JJ YKTa KOTOPaH J OJIJKHa rrpHHa J JIeJKaTb KaJlC J oMY KJIaccy Co06pa ­ BOH BOHHbl nOJJ CKa3blBaeT COBceM HHoe a BepHIllTeHH BeerJJ a nOHH­ IKeHHH nepepacnpe J eJIHTeJIbHoll 60Pb6a IIIJIa 3a JJ OJIIO npo­ Me HO n03HUHH BepHIllTeHHa H JJ pyrHx XOTH 6bl MaKnOHaJIbJJ a B B CYIIJ HOCTH Bce06Illell 3KOHOMHlJeCKOH H COIUlaJIbHOH nOJIHTHKH Bce MaJI pa60'lee J BHIKeHHe KaK CO J PYIKeCTBO 60puOB 3a 06IIIHe rYMa­ eIlle 6a3HPOBaJIHCb Ha J orrYIlleHHH 'ITO nJIaHHpoBaHHe npoH3BOJJ CT­ HHrapHbIe If TpYJJ oBble ueHHOCTH Ho C J PyroH CTOpOHbl B OTJIHlJHe Ba JJ OJIJlCHO OCTaBaTbCH B Be J eHHH npennpHHHMaTeJIeH a leHbl OT COpeJIH OH He BocnpHHHMaJI pa60'lee JJ BIfIKeHlfe KaK ueJIb B ce6e ryJIHpoBaTbCH pbIHKOM OJJ HaKO cerOJJ HHIIIHHe pe$opMaTopbI YIKe H He C'lHTaJI 'ITO eMY He H 'JlCHbl MaTepHaJIbHble ycnexH H J OCTHIKe­ He MorYT nOJIaranCH npH CTOJIb J1CH3HeHHO BaJICHbIX peIlleHHHX Ha HHH CJIenylO Hrpy crnXHHHbIX CHJI npeJlC J e Bcero OHH - pe­ COIUlaJIbHbIe perYJIHpoBIllHKH a nOTOMY pelllHTeJIbHO OTJIH'laIOTCH OT npo$COI03­ no ty CTOpoHY peBH3HOHH3Ma HbIX BOJKaKOB KOTopbIe 6opoJIHCb C OTJJ eJIbHbIMH rrpennpHHHMaTe­ JIHMH B J HH nepBOH pecny6JIIfKH H OC06eHHO co BpeMeHH BTOPOll MH­ JI rOBOpHJI paHee 'ITO 6epHlllTeHHOBCKHH aHaJIH3 COBpeMeHHoro poBOll BOllHbI COIUlaJI- J eMoKpaTHH paCTepHJIa 3Ha'IHTeJIbH '1O J OJIIO KanHTaJIH3Ma COBepmeHHO ynYCKaJI H3 B 3HatfeHHe KpynHoro CBoero MOpaJIbHOrO Boo J YIlleBJIeHHH OHa npeBpaTHJIaCb B aJJ BOKa­ npennpHHlfll4areJIbCTBa H MOHOnOJIHCTHtfeCKHX CTPYKTYP OH He rro­ TYPY HHTepeCOB B IllKOJIY yupaBJIeHHH Tenepb OHa 60JIbIlle 0OO3a­ cneBaJI 3a C06bITHHMH JJ aIKe CBoero BpeMeHH CerO J HH pe$opMH3M Ha KeHHCY H $a6HaHU aM 'IeM MapKCY HJIH BepHIllTellHY 06IlleCT­ noro THlla CTOJIb IKe YCTapeJI KaK H MaPKCHCTCKaH MOJJ eJIb peBO­ 158 159 r 1 moUHH OepHIIITeHH BepHO OrrHCbIBaJI B03MO l OCTH ycrreIIIHorO KJIaCCOBOrO J eHCTBIDI i lIo3e¢ ITo KWTe¢1I B MHpe KOTOPbIH CYIl eCTBOBaJI J O rrepBOH EUlE PA3 0 SInTE MHPOBOH BOHHbI HO eMY rrpHIIIJIOCb 6bI MHOroMY y'lHTbCH JaHOBO qT06bI He rrOTepHTbCH B rrOJIHTHKe 06Il eCTBa Bce06Il ero 6JIarOCOCTO­ fiRHH IIocrre BBe J eHHH B IIorrbIIIe BoeHHoro rrOrrO KeHHH B BbIcTyrrrre­ OHO rrpe J IIOJIaraeT 60JIee IIIHpOKHH Kpyr030p qeM TOT KOTOPbIH HHHX MHorHX 3arra J HOeBpOrreHCKHX rrOrrHTHKOB H 0603peBaTerreH 06eCrre'lHBaJICH rrpocpCOI03HbIMH IIIKOJIaMH B J HH oepHIIITeHHa pa­ CHOBa CIarro MerrbKaTb crrOBO HrrTa IIorrHTHqecKHe KpyrH 3arra J ­ 60qee J BH KeHHe J OJI I O 6bmo rrpHcrroca6JIHBaTbCH HOH EBporrbI CCbmarrHCb Ha HrrTY J JIH 060CHOBaHHH cBoeH 6e3 J eHcT­ K rrpeBpaTHO­ CTHM KarrHTaJIHCTHqeCKOrO pa3BHTIDI CerO J HH 3KOHOMHKa J OJI I a H MO KeT cpopMHpoBaTbCH COOTBeTCTBeHHO KOHuerrUJUIM COUHarrb­ Horo rrrraHHpOBaHHH BeHHOCTH rrepe J rrHUOM HaCHJIIDI Ha J BorreH rrorrbCKoro r BeHrepcKHMH C06bITHHMH KHH B lTepeeooE LUpacUHa Hapo J a B rrpoIIIJIOM HrrTY BCrrOMHHaJIH rro TeM Ke rrpHqHHaM B CBH3H C 1968 1956 rO J a H oKKyrraUHeH qeXOCJIOBa­ rO J Y IIpHqeM rrOHHTHe HrrTa J orr KHO 6bmo C03 J aTb BrreqaTrreHHe qTO y COBeTcKoro COI03a eCTb He TorrbKO rrorrHT ec­ Koe HO 06pa30M crryqae - H IOpH J eCKOe rrpaBO J eHCTBOBaTb COOTBeTCTBYIOIl HM TOr J a KaK IOpH J eCKaH 06H3aHHOCTb 3arra J a B 3TOM He rrpe J IIpHHHMaTb HHqero B Haqarre HbIHeIIIHero rO J a B ra3eTe HbIO-MOPK TaHMC KaHUJIep 3arra J HOH repMaHHH rerrbMYT IIIMH J T rrHcarr IIoqTH 40 rreT Ra3a J Ha KOHcpepeHUHH B Hme peIIIeHO 6bmo pa3 J errHTb EBporry Ra ccpepbI BrrHHHHH MHorHe rr03 Ke paCKaHBarrHCb B Ha qTO Y Ke Ha rrpoTH KeHHH 40 3TOM HO HeCMOTpH HH rreT rrpH3HaHHe 3arra J OM cpaKTa qTO CTpaHbI Ha BOCTOK OT 3rrb6bI He BXO J HT B ero ccpepy BrrHHHHH COBepIIIeHHO OqeBH J HO DpaHUY3CKHH rrpe3H J eHT MHTTepaH HCXO J HT H3 aHaJIOrH'lHOH rrpe J IIOCbmKH XOTH rrOrrHrnqeCKaH HarrpaBrreHHOCTb ero BbIBO J OB HeCKorrbKO HHaH Obmo 6bI rrorre3HO Bce qyO crroc06CTBOBaJIO 6bI aHHyrrHpoBaHHIO HrrTbI rO J HeM BbIcTyrrrreHHH - 3aHBHrr rrpe3H J eHT DpaHUHH B HOBO­ HO rrHIIIb B TOM crryqae ecrrH KerraeMOe He 6Y J eT BbI J aBaTbCH 3a J eHCTBHTerrbHOCTb K AHCKYCCHH 0 HrrTHHcKoM corrraIIIeHHH rrO J KrrIOqHJIHCb H COBeT­ CKHe rrpe J CTaBHTeJIH B KOHue HHBapH TeKYIl erO rO J a rro MOCKOB­ CKOMY TerreBH J eHHIO BbIcTyrrHrr COTPY J HHK OT J erra Me K J yHa PO J ­ HOH HHcpopMaUHH UK KITCC B K06bIIII Ha Borrpoc rrOqeMY Ha 3arra J e CTarrH Bce qaIl e BbIcTYrraTb rrpoTHB HrrTHHcKoro corrraIIIe­ HIDI K06bIIII OTBeTHJI IIpHHUHrrHarrbHbIe rrorrHT eCKHe rrepeMe­ HbI B IIorrbIIIe K KOTOPbIM OTKPbITO CTpeMHJIaCb CorrH J apHocTb OKa3arrHCb 6bI B rrpoTHBOpe'lHH C corrraIIIeHHHMH J OCTHrHyTbIMH B HrrTe II03ToMY BaIIIHHrTOHCKHe rrpaBHTerrH cTapaIOTcH oCBo60­ J HTbCH OT aMepHKaHCKHX 06H3aTerrbcTB KOTOpbIe rrpHHHlI B HrrTe 160 161