lOrocnaBHH OrKpbIJ1a CBOH rpaHHUbI JUlH TYpH3Ma 3aKOH H npa­ BonopHJ OK CranH 60nee 06H3arenbHbi a Ke JUlH HX 0 pHlUtaJIblibIX 6mOCTHreneH H3MeHHnHCb pOPMbl npecneJ OBaHHH nomUWleClCHX npOTHBHHKOB HaKa3aHHH 6bIflH CMHftleHbl H craH apTH3HpoBaHbI IlOKYMEHTbl Q l HaKO J a Ke ceH' ac nonHTH' eCKHX npOTHBHHKOB Moryr a ' acTO H J eikTBHreJlbHO npHrOBapHBaIOT K 3aKJlIO' eHHIO Ha J oJlrne CpOKH OTPblBOK H3 IlOK JlAJlA IIPE IlCEJlATrnJl COBETA HAPO IlHbIX KOMHCCAPOB H HAPO IlHOfO KOMHCCAPA HHOCTPAHHbIX Ilrn MOnOTOBA HA 3ACE IlAHHH BEPXOBHOfO COBETA COIOlA CCP 31 OKTJlBPJl1939 fOllA npOCTO 3a nepeCKa3 KaKoro-HH6yJl b aHeKJ OTa HnH BbICKa3blBaHHe ''Bpa KeCKHX'' MbIcneii B Kpyry J pY3eH MexaHH3M nOJlHTH' eCKOH Cne I KH Ja rpa K aHaMH H3MeHeHHH He npeTepnen • ilepe80a M MuxaUIl08a TOBapHIUH J enyraTbI 3a nOCne l HHe J Ba MeCHua B Me K l yHapo l Hoii 06CTaHOBKe npo­ H30wnH Ba KHbIe nOnO KeHHIO B H3MeHeHHH EBpone HO 3TO o rHOCHTCH npe K l e Bcero K TaK Ke H K J anelCO 3a npeJ enaMH EBponbI B CTpaHaM HaXOJ HIUHMCII CBH3H C 3THM HaJ O YKa3aTb Ha TpH OCHOBHbIX 06croHTenbCTBa HMeIOIUHX pewaIOIUee 3Ha' eHHe Bo-nepBbIX HaJ O YKa3arb Ha H3MeHeHHH npOHCWeJ WHe B OTHO­ IIIeHWlX Me KJ y COBeTCKHM COI030M H fepMaHHeH Co BpeMeHH JaKnIO' eHHH 23 aBrYCTa coBeTcKO-repMaHCKOrO J oroBopa 0 HeHa­ naiJ eHHH 6bIfl nOnO KeH KOHell HeHOpMallbHbIM OTHOIIIeHHHM cy­ U ecTBoBaBWHM B Te' eHHe PH a neT Me KJ y COBeTCKHM COI030M H fepMaHHeii Ha CMeHY Bpa K l bl BCH' eCKH nOJ orpeBaBweHCH co cropOHbI HeKOTopbIX eBponeHCKHX J ep KaB npHWnO c6nH KeHHe H ycraJlOBneHHe J pY KeCTBeHHbIX OTHoweHHH Me K l y CCCP H fepMa­ HHeiL IlanbHeHwee ynyqweHHe 3THX HOBbIX XOPOWHX OTHOWeHHH HalUJIO CBoe BbIpa J eHHe B repMaHO-COBeTCKOM J orOBope 0 J pY Kfie H rpaHHlle Me K l y CCCP H fepMaHHeii nOJ llHcaHHOM 28 ceHTH6pH B MocKBe I1poHcweJ WHH KPYTOii nOBopoT B OTHOWeHHHX Me K l y COBercKHM COI030M H fepMaHHeii Me KJl Y J BYMH caMbIMH Kpyn­ HbIMH rocYJl apCTBaMH EBponbI He Mor He CKa3aTbCH Ha BceM Me K­ Jl YHapo l HOM nOnO KeHHH PH nOM C06blTHH ll enHKOM nOJ TBepJ H­ nM ry OlleHlCY nOJlHTH' eCKoro 3Ha' eHHH COBeTCKo-repMaHCKoro c6mDKeHHH lCOTopaH 6bma aHa Ha npownoii CeccHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa Bo-Bropblx HaJ O YKa3aTb Ha TaKoii paKT KaK BoeHHbIH pa3rpoM I10JlhU H H pacnaJ IlOJlbCKOro rocY apcrBa I1paBHIIJ He KpyrH I10JlbIllH He Mano KH'IH1IMCb npo' HOCTbIO CBoero rOCYJl apCTBa H 282 283 MOIll blO CBOeH apMllli OJ Q1aKO OKa3aJIOCb nOCTaTOqHbIM KOpOT­ l10nblTKH aHfJIHHCKOrO H $paHIO'3CKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTB onpaB­ KOrO ynapa rro 110JIbille co CTOpOHbl CIIepBa repMaHCKOH apMlflf naTb ny CBOlO HOBYlO rr03HUHlO naHHblMH 110JIbllle 06H3aTeJIbCTBa­ a 3aTeM KpaCHOH apMllli qr06bI HlfqerO He ocraJIOCb OT 3T0ro ypOJ1lllfBOrO neTHIlI a BepcaJIbCKOrO norOBopa l HBlllerO 3a CqeT yrHeTeHIDI HerrOJIbCKHX HaUHOHaJIbHOCTeH ''Tpa o HUHOHHaH rrOJIIf­ TlfKa 6ecrrpHHUHIIHoro JIaBlfpC BaHHH If Hrpbl Me KJly fepMaHlfeH If CCCP OKa3aJIaCb HeCOCTOHTenbHOH If rrOJIHOCTblO 06aHKpoTH­ MH pa3YMeeTCH HBHO HeCOCTOHTenbHbl B-TpeTblfX cnenYeT rrpH3HaTb qrO BcnblXHYBlllaH B EBporre 60nbillaH BOHHa BHecna KopeHHble H3MeHeHHH BO BClO MeJKnyHapon­ BOCCTaHOBJIeHHH CTapoH 6eccMblcneHHblM HBJIHeTCH npOnOJIJKeHHe TenepelllHeH BOHHbI non $naroM BOCCTaHOBJIeHIDI npeJKHero 110nbcKoro rocynapcTBa 110HHMaH 3TO npaBHTeJIbCTBa AHfJIHH H llpaHUHH OJ Q1aKO He XOTHT npeKpaIll eHIDI naCb 0 110nb1llH KaK Ka ll OMY nOHJ'lTHO He MOJKeT 6blTb H peqH l103TOM ' BOHHbl H BOCCTaHOBJIeHIDI Mlfpa a HIlI yT HOBoro onpaBnaHIDII1 J1H nponOnJKeHIDI BOHHbl nponm fepMaHHH B nocncJ Q1ee BpeMH npaBHIlI He KpyrH AHfJIHH H llPaHl HH nblTa­ ce6H HYlO 06CTaHOBKY 3Ta BOHHa HaqaJIaCb MeJKnY fepMaHHeii H 110nb­ lOTCH H306pa3HTb llleH H npeBpaTHJlaCb B BOHHY Me KJly fepMaHHeH C 0J Q10H CTO­ npaBa HapOnOB rrpoTHB rHTJIepH3Ma npnqeM aHrJIHHCKOe npaBH­ C npyroH CTOpOHbI BOH Ha MeJKnY TenbCTBO 06bHBHJlO qTO 6YnTo 6bl Il JlH Hero l eJIblO BOHHbl npoTHB POHbl AHrJIHeH H tllpaHUHeH B KaqeCTBe 6opl oB 3a neMOKpaTHqeCKHe nOJIHoro fepMaHHH HBnHeTCH He 60nbille H He MeHbllle KaK YHnqTOJKeHHe 6aHKpoTCTBa nOJIbCKHX PYKOBO o HTeneH 110nbllle KaK H3BeCTHO rHTnepH3Ma 110nyqaeTCH TaK qrO aHrJIHHCKHe a BMeCTe C HHMlf fepMaHHeH H 110nbilleH 3aKOHqI JIaCb 6b1CTPO BBHny He nOMOrJIH HH aHrJIHHCKHe HH $PaHIO'3CKHe rapaHTHH llo CHX H $paHIO'3CKHe CTOPOHHHKH BOHHbI 06bHBHJlH npoDm repMaHHH nop co6cTBeHHo TaK H HeH3BeCTHO qTO 310 6blJIH 3a rapaHTHH qTO-TO BpOne 06 ijuU cMex HaqaBlllaHCH MeJKnY fepMaHHeH H aHrJIO-$paH- penHrH03Hbie BOHHbl lleHCTBHTeJIbHO B CBoe BpeMH peJIHfH03Hble HneOJIOrnqeCKOH BOHHbI HaDOMHHalOIlI eB CTapble 1O'3CKHM 6rrOKOM BOHHa HaXO o HTCH JIHlllb B cBoeH rrepBoH CTanHH BOHHbl npoTHB epeTHKOB H HHOBepl eB 6bIJlH B MOne OHH KaK H nO-HaCTOHIlI eMY eIll e He pa3BepHYJIaCb TeM He MeHee rrOHJITHO H3BeCTHO rrpHBenH K THrqaHIllHM Il JlH HaponHb1X Macc nocnencT­ qrO raKaH BOHHa nOJIJKHa 6bIJla BHeCTH KopeHHble H3MeHeHHH B BHHM K X03HHCTBeHHOMY pa30peHHlO H K KYJIbTypHOMY O o HqaHHlO nOnOJKeHHe EBponbI na H He TOJIbKO EBporrbl HaponOB Hnqero npyroro 3TH BOHHbl H He MOrJIH naTb Ho 3TH B CBH3H C 3THMH BaJKHblMH H3MeHeHIDIMH MeJKnYHa poJ Q10H BOHHbI 6bIJlH BO BpeMeHa cpeJ Q1eBeKoBbH He K 3THM nH BpeMeHaM 06CTaHOBKH HeKOTopble CTapble $opMYnbl KOTOPblMlf Mbl rrOJIb­ cpenHeBeKOBbH 30BaJIHCb eIll e HenaBHO - KYJIbrypHoro O o HqaHIDI THHYT Hac CHOBa rocnOnCTBYlOIlI He KJIaCCbl H K KOTOPbIM MlfOrHe TaK npHBblKJIH ­ K BpeMeHaM peJIHrH03HbIX BOHH cyeBepHH H naBHO ycrapeJIH H Terrepb HerrpHMeHHMbI Hano OTnaTb ce6e B 3TOM AHrJIllli H tllpaHUHH Bo BCJ'lKOM cnyqae rron HneOJIOrHqeCKHM OTqeT qT06bl H36eJKaTb rpy6blx 01llH60K B oueHKe CnOJKHBlllerOcH $JIarOM Tenepb 3aTeHHa BOHHa eIll e 60nbillero MaClIITaOO H eIll e 60nblllHX HOBoro nOnHTHqeCKOrO nOnOJKeHIDI B EBpone 113BecTHO RanpHMep qTO 3a nOCJIeJ Q1He HeCKOJIbKO MeCHl eB yaKHe nOHHTIDI KaK arpeCCHJ'l arpeccop nonYqHJlH HOBoe orracHocTeH J1lIH HapOnOB EBponbl H Bcero MHpa Ho raKoro pona BOBRa He HMeeT I1 J1H ce6J'l HHKaKoro orrpaBnaHIDI I1neonorHlO fHTJIepH3Ma KaK H BCHKYlO npyrylO H o eonornqecK 'IO KOHKpeTHOe COnepJKaHHe npH06peJIH HOBblH CMbICII He TPYnH 0 cHcTeMY MOJKHO npH3HaBaTb HJlH OTPHl aTb 3TO - noranaTbcJ'l qTO Tenepb Mbl He MOJKeM nOJIb30BaTbCH 3THMH nOHJI­ qeCKHx B3fJIHnOB Ho nlO60H qenOBeK rroHMeT qTO H o eOnOrHlO THHMH B TOM JKe CMblcne KaK CKaJKeM 3-4 MeCJ'll a TOMY Ha3an· neJIO rrOnHTH­ HeJIb3J'l YHHqTQJKHTb CHJlOH Henb3J'l rrOKOHqHTb C HelO BOHHOH 1103­ Tenepb eCJIH rOBopHTb 0 BeJIHKHX nepJKaBaX EBPOIIbI fepMaHIDI TOMY HaX0nHTCJ'l B nOnOJKeHHH rocynapcTBa CTpeMHIlI erOCJ'l K CKopeH­ BOHHY KaK BOHHa 3a ''yHnqTOJKeHHe flunepH3Ma npHKpbIBaeMaH He TOJIbKO 6eccMblcneHHo HO H npeCTyrrHo BeCTH TaKyro llleMY OKOHqaHHlO BOHHbl H K MHPy a AHrJIHJ'l H tllpaHUHJ'l Bqepa $anblllHBblM $naroM 6opb6bI 3a neMOKpaTHlO B caMOM nene eIll e paTOBaBIllHe npoTHB arpeCCHH CTOJ'lT 3a npOnOJIJKeHHe BOHHbl HHKaK H rrpOTHB 3aKnlOqeHIDI MHpa PonH KaK BHnHTe MeHJ'llOTCJ'l KaK 3aKpbITHe KOMMYHHCTHqeCKOB napTHH BO tllpaHl HH apecTbl Henb3J'l Ha3BaTb 60pb60H 3a neMOKpaTHlO TaKHe neHcTBIDI KOMMYHHCHTHqeCKHX nerrYTaToB 284 tllpaHIO'3cKoro napnaMeHTa lUIH 285 arpeccop He TPYAHO BHAeTb qTO yrroTpe6neHHe 3THX cnOB B ype3bIBaHHe rrOnHTH'leCKHX CB060A B AHrnHH Heocna6eBalOmuH HalJ HOHWbHbIH meT B I1HAUH H T rr qeM rOBopHT B 0 JlHIJ HWbHbIX BbIC1 'IIJ1eHHHX MH IllHpoKoro Kpyra cnYIIIaTeneH BO I PaHUHH H AHrnHH TO eCTb He B 60Pb6e 3a AeMoKpaTHIO a B qeM-TO ApyroM 0 qeM He rOBopHT 3TH rocrro­ a OTKPbITO CKHM COlO30M H fepMaHHeH H AO Haqana 60nbIIIoH HMIIepuanHcTH­ qeCKOH BOHHbI B EBporre - QT06bI 3Toro He cnyqunOCb MbI He AOn l bI AorrYCKaTb HeKpHTH­ qeCKOrO OTHOIIIeHHH K TeM CTapbIM rrOHHTHHM KOTopbIe HerrpHeM­ lleHcTBHTenbHaH rrpHquHa aHrno- JlpaHuY3cKoH BOHHbI rrpoTHB 6bI BOCCTaHOBHTb rrpe l lOlO IIonbrny H KOHe o He B TOM 'ITO neMbI B HOBOH Me AYHapoAHOH 06CTaHOBKe TaK ApyrHe rrpaBllmHX KpyroB AHrnuH H I PaHIJ HH eCTb pa3YMeeTcH 60nee AeHcTBHTenbHbIe MOTHBbI MH BOHHbI rrpoTHB fep­ MaHHH 3TH MOTHBbI OTHOCHTCll He K 06naCTH KaKOH-nu60 HAeo­ nonrn a K c Jlepe HX cyry60 MaTepHanbHbIX HHTepeCOB KaK Mory­ meCTBeHHbIX KonOHHWbHbIX Aep aB EpHTaHCKaH HMIIepHH HaceneHHe KOTOPOH AOCTHraeT nHOHOB BnaAeeT KonOHHHMH C HaceneHHeM B 480 47 42 MHnnHOHOB OXBaTbIBaeT 70 MHn­ MHnnHOHOB MHnnHOHOB HTeneH BO JlpaHuY3CKHX KonOHHHX BnaAeHHe 3THMH KonOHHHMH AlllOmee B03MO l OCTb 3KcrrnyaTHpoBaTb COTHH MHnnHOHOB nlOAeH HBnHeTCH OCHOBOH MHpoBoro rocrrOACTBa AHrnHH H I paHUHH CTpax rrepeA repMaHcKHMH rrpHTH3aHHHMH Ha 3TH KonOHHanbHbIe BnaAeHHH ­ BOT B rrpOTHB qeM rrOAorrneKa TerrepelillIeH BOHHbI AHrnHH H I PaHUHH fepMaHHH KOTopaH cepbe3HO YCHnunacb 3a rrOcneAHee BpeMH B pe3ynbTaTe pa3Bwa BepcanbcKoro AorOBopa OrraceHHH 3a rrOTeplO MHpoBoro rocrrOACTBa Me JJ YHapoAHaH 06CTaHOBKa B rrOCneAHHH IIepeHAeM K H3MeHeHHHM rrpOHCIIIeAIIIHM BO BHelillIeM rrono­ eHHH caMoro COBeTCKoro COI03a 113MeHeHHH 3AeCb rrpOH30IIInH He ManeHbKHe HO ecnH rOBopHTb 0 rnaBHOM TO Henb3H He rrpH3­ HaTb cneAYlOmero CBoeH MHPHOH 6narOAapH BHelillIeH rrocneAoBaTenbHoMY rronHTHKH HaM rrpoBeAeHHIO YAWOCb 3HaqHTenbHO YCHnHTb CBOH rr03HIJ HH H Me JJ YHapOAHbIH Bec COBeTCKoro COIO­ qenOBeK KonoHHanbHaH HMIIepHH I PaHIJ HH HaceneHHe KOTOPOH He rrpeBbIIIIaeT cnO HnaCb rrepHOA OHH peIIIHnH 6YATO 6bI B3HTb Ha ce6H 3aAaqy 6oPb6bI 3a AeMoKpa­ Y MO eT rrOpO AaTb TonbKO rryTaHHuY B ronOBax H HeH36e H0 6YAeT TonKaTb K OIIIH60 bIM BbIBOAaM fepMaHHH He B TOM qro AHrnHH H I paHIJ HH rrOKnHnHCb 6YATO THIO TO eCTb KaK 3TO 6bInO AO rrOcneAHero peIllH­ TenbHoro rroBoporn B rrOnHTHqeCKHX OTHOIIIeHHHX Me AY CoBeT­ He llCHO nH qTO uenb TerrepelillIeH BOHHbI B EBporre He B TOM o CTapoM cMbIcne - J HKTyIOT rrpaBHmHM KpyraM AHrnHH H I PaHIJ HH rronuTHKY pa3 HraHHH BOHHbI rrpoTHB fepMa­ HHH TaKHM 06pa30M HMIIepHanHCTHqeCKHH xapaKTep 3TOH BOHHbI OqeBHAeH Mll Ka AOrO KTO XOqeT BHAeTb AeHCTBHTenbHoe rrono­ eHHe Aen KTO He 3aKpbIBaeT rna3a Ha JlaKTbI 113 Bcero 3Toro BUAHO KOMY HY Ha 3Ta BOHHa BeAYmaHCH H3-3a MHpOBoro rocrrOACTBa KOHe o He pa60qeMY Knaccy TaKaH BOHHa He CynuT pa60qeMY Knaccy HHqerO KpoMe KpoBaBbIx epTB H 6eAcTBHH IIocne 3Toro CYAHTe caMH H3MeHHnOCb HnH He H3MeHHnOCb llpoiJollJ CUTellbHble an rzoiJucMeHTbl 3a HaIllH OTHOIIIeHHH C fepMaHHeH KaK H y e CKa3an ynyqIllH­ nHCb KopeHHbIM 06pa30M 3AeCb Aeno pa3BHBaeTCH rro nHHHH yKperrneHHH Apy eCTBeHHbIX OTHOIIIeHuH pa3BHTHH rrpaKTHqeCKOrO COTpYAHHqeCTBa H rrOnHTHqeCKOH rrOAAep KH fepMaHHH B ee CTpeM­ neHHHX K MHpy 3aKnlOqeHHbIH fepMaHHeH AorOBOp 0 TeTY Me JJ Y COBeTCKHM COlO30M H HeHarraAeHHH 06H3bIBan Hac K HeHTpanH­ B cnyqae yqaCTHH fepMaHHH B BoHHe MbI rrocneAOBaTenbHO rrpOBOAHnH 3Ty nHHHIO qeMY OTHIOAb He rrpOTHBopequT BCTyrrneHHe HaIllHX BOHCK Ha TeppHTOpHIO 6bIBIIIeH IIonbIIIH HaqaBIIIeeCH ceHTH6pH 1l0CTaTo 0 HarrOMHHTb 'ITO TOrAa e 17 17 ceHTH6pH COBeTCKoe rrpaBHTenbcTBo pa30cnano BceM rocYAllpCTBaM C KOTO­ pbIMH OHO HMeeT AHIInOMaTH'leCKHe OTHOIIIeHHH CrrelJ HanbHYIO HOTY C 3aHBneHHeM 0 TOM qTO CCCP H BrrpeAb 6YAeT rrpoBOAHTb rronHTHKY HeHTpanHTeTa B OTHOIIIeHHHX C HHMH KaK H3BeCTHO HaIIIH BOHCKa BCTYIIunH Ha TeppHTopHIO IIonbIllH TOnbKO rrocne TOro KaK IIonbcKoe rOCYAllpCTBO pacrranOCb H JlaKTHqeCKH rre­ peCTano cymecTBOBaTb OCTaBaTbCH HeHTpanbHbIM H K TaKHM JlaK­ TaM MbI pa3YMeeTCH He MornH TaK KaK B pe3ynbTaTe 3THX C06bI­ Tuii rrepeA HaMH BCTanH OCTpbIe BorrpOCbI 6e30rraCHOCTH HaIIIero rocYAapCTBa K TOMY e COBeTCKoe rrpaBHTenbCTBO He Morno He CquTaTbCH HCKnlOquTenbHbIM C rrOnO eHHeM C03AaBIIIHMCH 3a rrOcneAHuH rrepHOA COAep aHHe TaKHX rrOHHTuH KaK arpeCCHH 287 286 AJIH 6paTCKOrO HaCeJIeHHH 3ana D HOH YKpaHHbI H 3ana D HOH EeJIo­ llpoHCllle lJ lllHe PYCCHH KOTOpoe B pa3BaJIHBllleHCH IloJIbllle OKa3aJIOCb 6pOllleHHbIM B nOJlHTH'leCKOH 06JIaCTH C03 lJ aJIH 6JIarOllpHHTHble IIpe lJ II0CbInKH Ha npoH3BOn Cyw 6bl IloCJIeAYIOIIUfe B COBeTCKo-repMaHCKHX OTHOllleHHHX H3MeHeHHH AJIH pa3BHTHH COBeTCKo-repMaHCKHX X03HHCTBeHHbIX OTHOllleHHH C06bITHH 1I0JIHOCTbIO 1I0 lJ TBepAHllH 'ITO HOBbIe COBeTCKO-repMaHCKHe OTHOllleHHH 1I0CTpoeHbI Ha llPO'IHOH 6a3e IlocJIe HHe X03HifcTBeHHble lIeperOBopbI fepMaHCKOH lJ eneraUHH B MOCKBe H llPOHCXOAHIUHe B a aHHbIH MOMeHT lIeperOBopbI Co­ B3aHMHbIX HHTepeCOB IlocJIe BCTynJIeHHH 'IaCTeH KpaCHOH APMHH MTCKoii He TeppHTOpHIO 6b1BlllerO IloJIbcKoro rocy a apCTBa B03HHKJIH cepb­ lllHpoKYIO 6a3y AJIH pa3BHTHH TOBapoofiopora Me KAj' COBeTCKHM e3Hble BonpoCbI pa3rpaHH'leHHH rocy a apCTBeHHbIX HHTepeCOB CCCP COI030M H fepMaHHeii X03HiicTBeHHOH lJ eneraUHH B fepMaHlIH 1I0 lJ rOTOBJIHIOT H fepMaHHH 3TH BOllPOCbI 6bIJIH 6bICTPO yperyJIHpOBaHbI 110 B3aHM­ Tenepb pa3pelllHTe OCTaHOBHTbCH Ha C06bITHHX HenOCpe lJ CTBeH­ HOMY cornaCHIO fepMaHO-COBeTCKHH lJ OrOBOp 0 lJ pY K6e H rpaHH­ HO CBH3aHHbiX C BCTYllneHHeM HalllHX BoiicK Ha TeppHTopHIO 6b1B­ ue Me KJJY CCCP H fepMaHHeH 3aKJIIO'IeHHbIH B KOHII e ceHTH6pH lllero IloJIbcKoro 3aKpenHn HaIIIH OTHOllleHHH C fepMaHCKHM rocy a apCTBOM BaTh XO lJ nHX CofiblTHH OTHOllleHHH 6yp a3HbIMH fepMaHHH C rocy a apCTBaMH onpe lJ eJIHJIHCb llpe K lJ e Bcero lJ pynlMH 3a 3aJIa D H0-eBponeifcKHMH 1I0CJIe D HHe CTpeMJIeHHeM Sa lJ eCHTHneTHH fepMaHHH pa3fiHTb rOCY lJ apCTBa 060 MHe HeT Heo6xO lJ HMOCTH OIlHCbI­ BceM 3TOM 1I0 lJ po6HO rOBopHTCH B Hallleii lIe'laTH H Bbl TOBapHIUH lJ eIlYTaTbI XOpolllO 3HaKOMbI C paKrH'leCKOii CTOpoHOii CKa nHlIIb 0 caMOM CYlUeCTBeHHOM He'lero lJ OKa3bIBaTb 'ITO B MOMeHT 1I0JIHOrO pacna a a IlonbCKoro nyTbI BepcanbcKoro lJ OrOBOpa TBOpuaMH KOToporo fiblJIH AHrJIHH rocy a apcTBa Hallle IIpaBHTeJlbCTBO 06H3aHo 6bInO IIPOTHHYTb PYKY H cDpaHUHH IIpH aKTHBHOM Y'laCTHH COe HHeHHbIX IlIraToB AMepH­ nOMOIUH IIpO KHBaIOIUHM Ha KH 3ro B KOHe'IHOM C'IeTe H IIpHBeJIO K rellepelllHeH BOHHe B 3alla lJ HOii EBpolle EeJlOpyccHH TeppHTopHH 3ana Hoii 6paTbHM-YKpaHHuaM YKpaHHbI H H 6parhHM-6enopyc­ caM 0HO TaK H nOCTYllano Eypllbte npoooflJ CuTetlbllble onflOOUC­ OTHOllleHHH COBerCKoro COI03a C fepMaHHeH CTPOHJIHCb Ha M ellTbl lJenyraTbt 6CTOIOT U YCrpOU60lOT 06014UIO KpaCHaH apMHH lJ pyroH OCHOBe He HMeIOlUeH HH'IerO ofilUero C HHTepecaMH YBeKO­ BcryIlHJIa B 3TH paiiOHbI Be'leHHH 1I0CJIeBOeHHOH BepcaJlbCKOH CHcreMbl MbI BCer lJ a fibInH H 6enopYCCKoro HaCeJleHHH BCTpeqaBlllerO HalIIH BoiicKa KaK CBO­ roro HX OCBOOO HTeJIeii or lIaHCKoro rHeTa OT rHeTa nOJIbCKHX 1I0Me1UH­ MHeHHH 'ITO CHJlbHaH fepMaHHH HBJlHeTCH Heofixo HMblM yCJIOBHeM llpo'IHoro MHpa B EBpOlle EblJIO fibl CMelllHO a yMaTb 'Iro fepMaHHIO MO KHO lIpocro BbIBecrH H3 CTpoH H CKHHYTb co C'IeTOB llep KaBbl JleJleIOIUHe ny IIpH Bce06IUeM COqYBCTBHH YKpaHHcKoro KOB H KanHranHCTOB IlpH 6oeBoM npo SH KeHHH KpaCHOH apMHH 110 3THM paHOHaM rJIYIIYIO H OllaCHYIO Me'lry He Y HalllHX BOHHCKHX 'laCreH fibIJIH MeCTaMH cepbe3Hbie CTbI'IKH C Y'IHTbIBaIOT ne'laJlbHOrO OllbIra BepCaJlH He or a aIOT ce6e or'lera B 1I0nbCKHMH qaCTHMH a CTaJIO 6bITb 6bIJIH H KepTBbl KaKOBbI B03poCllleii MOIUH fepMaHHH H He 1I0HHMaIOT TOro 'ITO nOllbIrKa 6bInH 3TH KepTBbl BH HO H3 CJIe a yIOlUero Ha 6enopYCCKOM pPOH­ nOBTopHTb BepcaJIb npH HbIHelllHeH Me KAj'Hapo lJ HOH ofiCTaHOBKe Te B qaCTHX KpaCHoii apMHH C'lHTaH HaqaJIbCTBYIOIUHH H PH lJ OBOH 1914 B KopHe OTnH'laIOlUeHCH OT 06cTaHoBKH rO lJ a - MO KeT KOH­ 'lHThCH AJIH HHX KpaxoM 749 Mbl HeYKJloHHO CTpeMHJlHCb K YJIY'IllleHHIO OTHOllleHHii C fep­ MaHHeH H BceMepHo COCTaB MbI HMeJIH y6HTbIX H paHeHblx 503 a Bcero ­ lllero H pH lJ OBorO COCTaBa 491 H paneHbIx - 1 850 CJle lJ OBa­ TaKoro pO lJ a CTpeMJIeHHH TeJlbHO 06IUee KOnH'IeCTBO KepTB 1I0HeceHHblX KpacHoii ApMHeii B caMOH fepMaHHH Tenepb HalllH OTHOllleHHH C fepMaHcKHM rocy­ Ha TeppHTopHH 3arra HoH EeJIOpyccHH H 3alla HOH YKpaHHbI coc- a aPCTBOM rorOBHOCTH BMeCTe nOCTpoeHbI npHBeTCTBOBaJiH 246 Ha YKPaHHCKOM PpoHTe MbI HMeJIH y6HTbIX H3 Ha'lanbcTBYIO­ Ha 6a3e lJ pY KeCTBeHHbIx OTHOllleHHH 1I0Mep KHBaTb CTpeMJIeHHH fepMaHHH K MHpy Ha TaBJIHeT H 2 599 C reM Ha KenaHHH BceMepHO CO lJ eHCTBOBaTb pa3BHTHIO JleMeTOB BbIrO lJ e BHHTOBO'IHblX 288 rocy a apCTB Ha lJ o CneUHaJIbHO OTMeTHTb 'ITO paHeHbIx - 1 862 TO eCTb B ueJlOM 900 C nHlIIHHM opY Hii CBbIllle 10 000 IIY­ 300 TbICH'I BHHTOBOK ooJlee 150 MHnJlHOHOB TO OHH COCTaBnHIOT COBeTCKo-repMaHCKHX X03HHCTBeHHbIX OTHOllleHHH KO B3aHMHOH 060HX 737 y6HTbIX qeJIOBeK qTO KacaeTCH HalllHX 60eBbIX Tpo peeB B Ilonbllle CBblllle lIaTpoHoB OKOJlO 1 MHJIJIHOHa apTHnnepHHCKHx 289 CHapH 1 OB 1 O 300 caMoneTOB H PoCCHH 3BepCKH ymeTaBlIIeii Manble HaPO 1 bI He aBaBlIIeii HM T 1 ITepelIIe 1 lIl1fe K CCCP TeppHTopHH no CBOHM pa3MepaM paBHbI TeppHTOpHH 6onblIIoro eBponeHcKoro rocY apCTBa TaK TeppH­ 198 TbICH'I KBa 1 paTHblX KHnOMeTpOB C HaceneHHeM B 4 MHnJIHOHa 800 TbICH'I 'IenOBeK TeppHTopHH 3ana 1 HOH YKpaHHbI COCTaBnHeT 88 TbICH'I KBa 1 paT­ HbIX KHnOMeTpOB C HaceneHHeM B 8 MHnnHOHOB '1enOBeK TaKHM TOpHH 3arra 1 HOH 06pa30M BMeCTe oenopyccHH 1 OCTHraeT nepelIIe 1 lIIaH C TeppHTopHeH K HaM TeppHTopHH 3ana 1 HOH Ha eBpeeB 60nee CBbllIIe ITonHTH'IeCKOe 3 HHX HeMano THrOCTHblX BOCnOMHHaHlI1f onblT Cne 1 yeT npH3HaTb 'ITO HCTeKIlIHX J1 Byx 1 eCHTIDIeTHX pa3BHTHH 1 pY l eCTBeHHbIX COBeTCKO-3CTOHCKHX COBeT­ CKo-naTBHHCKHX H COBeTCKO-JIHTOBCKHX OTHOlIIeHHH C03 1 aJI 6na­ rOnpHHTHbIe npe 1 llOCblJlKH JJ IJI 1 aJIbHeiilIIero yKpenneHHH nOJIH­ TH'IeCKHX H BCHKHX 1 pyrHx OTHOlIIeHHii CCCP C npH5anrHHCKHMH COCe 1 HMH 3TO nOKa3anH H nOCJIe 1 HHe 1 HIInOMaTH'leCKHe nepero­ MHnnH­ BOPbI C npe 1 CTaBHTenHMH 3CTOHHH JIaTBHH H JIHTBbI H Te 1 OrOBO­ fionee MIDillHOHOB rronHKOB 7 13 MHnnI10HOB CBbllIIe 1 MIDlnHO- 1 Ml1nnl10Ha 3Ha'leHHe caMOCTOHTenbHoro HanuOHanbHD-rocy­ 196 COCTaBlIHeT TbICH'I KBa 1 panlblx KHnOMeTpOB a ee HaceneHHe OKono 6enopyccoB B03MO I HOCTH apCTBeHHoro pa3BHTHH H ocraBHBlIIeii y 3arra 1 HOH YKpaHHbI oenopYCCHH OHOB '1enOBeK H3 KOTOPblX YKpaHHlI eB KaKoii-nH60 pa KOTopbIe 5blJIH nO 1 llHcaHbl B MOCKBe B pe3YJIbTaTe 3THX nepe­ roBOpOB BbI 3HaeTe 'ITO COBeTCKHii COI03 3aKnIO'IMJI TaKHe naKTbl B3aH­ JTHX COfibITHH TPY 1 HO nepeOll eHHTb MonOMOmH C 3CTOHHeii JIaTBHeii H JIHrnoH KOTopbIe HMeIOT KPyrr­ Bce coo6lIIeHHH C 3ana 1 HOH YKpaHHbI 11 3arra 1 HOH oenopyccHH Hoe nOJIHTH'leCKOe 3HaqeHHe ITPHHUHllHaJIbHaH OCHOBa 3THX naK­ CBl1 1 eTenbcrnYIOT 0 TOM 'ITO HaCeneHl1e C HeorrHcyeMbIM BOCTOP­ TOB O UIHaKOBaH DHH OCHOBaHbl Ha B3aHMOnOMOmH Me l 1 y COBeT­ rOM BCTpeTl1nO CBoe oCB06mK 1 eHHe OT rronbCKoro rHeTa H ropH­ CKHM COI030M - '10 np BeTCTBOBaJlO HOBYIO BenHKYIO rrofie 1 y COBeTCKOH BnaCTH C 1 pyrOH CTOPOHbI BKnIO'IIUl H BoeHHYIO nOMOmb 1 pyr 1 pyry B B3pb18 i OIl2UX anlloi ucMellToB ITpolIIe 1 lIIHe B nocne 1 HHe 1 H11 C O 1 HOH CTOpoHbl 3CTOHHeH JIaTBHeii H JIHTBOH ­ cnyqae Hana 1 eHHH Ha Koro-nH50 H3 HHX BBHJ1 Y oc050ro reorpa­ BbI60pbI B HapO 1 Hble C06paHI1H 3ana 1 HoM YKpaHHbl H 3arra 1 HOH j H'leCKOrO EenoPyccHH 1I0 1 CTyrraMH K CCCP oc05eHHO co CTOpoHbl EanrniicKoro MOPS KOTopble 3 1 eCb 6bIJIH BrrepBbIe opraHH30BaHbl Ha 1I0nO l eHHH 3THX CTpaH HBnHIOmHXCH CBoerO PO a OCHOBe Bce06mero rrpHMoro H paBHoro H36HpaTenbHoro HpaBa 3TH C raMHoH HMeTb BoeHHO-MopCKHe fia3bl H a3pO 1 pOMbI B onpe 1 eneHHblX lIyHK­ 9 10 rrO a'leH ronOCOB nOKa3anH 'ITO 110 KpaMHeM Mepe HaCeneHI1H JlHX 06nacTeH naKTbl npe 1 OcraBnHIOT COBeTCKOMY COI03Y B03MO I HOCTb 6blJIH Y I e aBHO HO 1 rOTOBneHbI Tax 3CTOHHH H JIaTBHH a B OTHOlIIeHHH JIHTBbl YCTaHaBJIHBaIOT J JIH BOCCOe 1 HHeHHH C COBeTcKHM COI030M M3BeCTHble Y I e Tenepb COBMeCTHYID C COBeTCKHM COI030M 3amHTY JIHTOBCKOH rpaHHUbI BceM HaM pelIIeHHH HapO 1 HbIX C06paHHH BO JIbBOBe H oenOCTOKe C03 1 aHHe CBl1 1 eTenbCTBYIOT 0 HonHOM e 1 HHO 1 ylIIHH HapO 1 HbIX H36paHHHKOB Ha TeppHTOpHH 3CTOHH1i JIaTBHH H JIHTBbl H BBO 1 HeKOTOporo BO Bcex nOJlHTH'IeCKHX Borrpocax ITepeH 1 eM K HalIIHM OTHOlIIeHHHM C npHfianTHHCKHMH CTpaHa­ 3THX KOJIHqeCTBa COBeTCKHX BoeHHO-MopCKHX KpaCHoapMeii cKHX ' aCTeii 1 JIH 003 H a3pO 1 poMOB OXpaHbl lTHX 003 H alpo 1 poMOB 05ecne'IHBaIOT Ha 1 e IO onopy o60pOHbl He TonbKO MH KaK H3BeCTHO H 3 1 eCb npoH30lIInH cymecTBeHHble H3MeHe­ JJ IJI COBeTCKoro COI03a HO H 1 JIH caMHX IIpH5anTHiicKHx HHH aPCTB H TeM caMblM cny l aT 1 eny coxpaHeHHH MHpa B KOTOPOM B OCHOBe OTHOlIIeHH COBeTCKoro COI03a C 3CTOHHeH JIarnHeH H JIHTBOH ne l aT COOTBeTCTBYIOlIIIle MHpHble 1 OrOBOpa 3aKnIO'IeH­ Hble B 1920 ro 1 Y ITo JTHM 1 OroBopaM 3CTOHI1H JIaTBHH H JIHTBa rocy­ 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI HallIH Hapo 1 bl HMeBllIHe MeCTO B nOcne 1 Hee BpeMH 1 HllJIOMaTH'leCKHe nepe­ rOBopbl C 3CTOHHeii JIaTBHeii H JIHTBOii 1I0Ka3aJIH 'ITO Me l 1 y nony'IIDIH caMOCTOHTenbHoe rocY apcTBeHHoe cymecTBoBaHHe npH­ HaMH '1eM 3a BeCb HCTeKlIIHH nepHO 1 COBeTcKHH COI03 Hel13MeHHO IIpO­ He05xo UIMOCTH cymecrnyeT 1 OCTaTO'IHOe ocymecTBneHHH 1 OBepHe lTHX H ny I Hoe nOHHMaHHe BoeHHo-o60pOHHTenbHblX BO 1 Hn 1 PY I eCTBeHnyIO nOrll1THKY B OTHOlIIeHHH 3THX BHOBb C03­ Mep B HHTepecax KaK COBeTcKoro COI03a TaK H caMHX 3THX rocy­ 1 aHHbIX ManblX rocY apcTB B 3TOM HalIIJlO CBoe BbIpa l eHHe KopeH­ 1 apcTB Hoe OTJIH'IHe nonHTHKH COBeTCKOH BnaCTH OT I10nHrnKH uaPCKOH y' aCTHHKOB K 290 B neperOBopax nOnHOCTblO BbIHBIDIOCb CTpeMneHHe HX coxpaHeHHIO MHpa H K o6eclleqeHHlO 5e30naCHocrn 291 550 J IH Haurnx Hapo OB 3aHHTbIX MHpHbIM TPY OM Bce 310 H 06ec­ CBOIO TeppHTopHIO YBeJIH'IHBaeT Ha rrelJHJIO ycrreurnoe OKOHlffiHHe rreperOBOpOB H 3aKJIIO'IeHHe rraKTOB JIeHHe H rrOJIY'IaeT ropo BHJIbHO ' HCJIO lfTeJIeH KOToporo rrO'lTH B3aHMOrrOMOIl H HMelOIl HX Ba l l Oe HCTOpH'IeCKOe 3Ha'leHHe B J Ba pa3a rrpeBblIIIaeT HaCeJIeHHe TerrepeurneH DHTOBCKOH CTOJIH­ OC06bIH XapaKTep YKa3aHHbIX rraKTOB B3aHMOrrOMOIl H OTHIO J b He 03Ha'laeT KaKoro-JIH60 BMeIIIaTeJIbCTBa COBeTCKoro COlO3a B eJIa 3CTOHHH DaTBHH H DHTBbI KaK 310 rrblTaIOTCH H306pa3HTb TbICH'I '1eJIOBeK CBoe Hace­ II bI COBeTcKHH COlO3 rrOIIIeJI Ha rrepe aqy ropo a BHJIbHO DHTOB­ CKOH pecrry6JIHKe He rrOTOMY 'ITO B HeM rrpe06JIa aeT JIHTOBCKoe HaCeJIeHHe HeT B BHJIbHO 60JIbIIIHHCTBO COCTaBJIHeT HeJIHTOBCKoe HeKOTopble opraHbI 3arpaHJf'lHOH rre'laTH HarrpOTHB Bce 3TH rraKTbI HaCeJIeHHe Ho B3aHMOrrOMOIl H ropo BHJIbHO KOTOPbIH nOJIbIIIeH 6bIJI HaCHJIbCTBeHHO OTTOPrHYT TBep 'o orOBapHBalOT HerrpHKOCHOBeHHOCTb cy­ BepeHHTeTa rrO J IlHcaBIIIHX HX rocy apCTB H rrpHHII HII HeBMeIIIaTeJIb­ OT CTBa B eJIa pyroro rOCY J apCTBa 3TH rraKTbI HCXO J HT H3 B3aHMHO­ KOTOPbIM rO YBa eHHH rOCY J apCTBeHHOH COII HaJIbHOH C' HTaJIOCb C TeM 'ITO OJI eH rrpHHa J JIe aTb DHTBe KaK CBH3aHO C O J HOH CTOPOHbI TaKOH HCTOpH'IeCKOe ropo C rrpoIlIJ1oe 3KOHOMH'IeCKOH JIHTOBCKoro rOCY J apCTBa CTpyKTYPbI pyroH CTOpOHbI H OJI I I bI YKperrHTb OCHOBY MHpHoro JIHTOBCKoro Hapo a 06pococe 'CKoro B MHPOBOH HCTOPHH He 6bIJIO eIl e TaKoro CJIY'IaH '1T06bI 60JIbIIIOe COTpY J HH'IeCTBa Me J y H DHTBbI COBeTCKoe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO HaurnMH Hapo aMH B a C PyroH - 3arpaHH'IHOH HaII HOHaJIbHble '1aHHHH rre'laTH YKa3bIBaJIOCb 'ITO MbI CTOHM 3a '1eCTHOe H rryHKTyaJIbHOe rrpOBe eHHe B lf3Hb 3a­ rocy apCTBO rro c06CTBeHHOH BOJIe oT aBaJIO MaJIOMY rocy apCTBY KJIIO'IeHHbIX rraKTOB Ha YCJIOBHHX rrOJIHOH B3aHMHOCTH H 3aHBJIHeM TaKoH 6oJIbIIIOH ropo ' TeM Hp'le 3TOT aKT COBeTCKoro rocy apCT­ 'ITO 6oJITOBHH 0 COBent3aII Hli rrpH6aJITHHCKHX cTpaH BblrO J Ha TOJIb­ Ba eMOHcTpHpyeT ero 06pylO BOJIIO KO HaIIIHM 06Il HM BparaM H BCHKHM aHTHCOBeTCKHM rrpoBoKa­ TopaM B oco60M rrOJIO eHHH Haxo HTcH HaIIIH OTHOIIIeHHH C DHHJIHH­ 'HeH 3TO 06bHCHHeTCH rJIaBHbIM 06pa30M TeM 'ITO B DHHJIHH­ Ha OCHOBe ocTHrHYToro YJIY'lIIIeHHH rrOJIHTH'leCKHX oTHoIIIeHHH C 3cToHHeH DaTBHeH H DHTBOH COBeTcKHH COlO3 rrOIIIeJI urnPOKO HaBcTpeqy X03HHcTBeHHbIM HY J aM 3THX rocy apcTB cooTBeTcTBYIOIl He ToproBble COrJIaIIIeHHH B CBH3H 3aKJIIOlJHB C 3THMH xo­ J HH 60JIbIIIe CKa3bIBalOTCH pa3Horo po a BHeurnHe BJIHHHHH CO CTOPOHbI TpeTbHX ep aB oecrrpHCTpaCTHble JIIO J H OJI I I bI O J Ha­ KO rrpH3HaTb COBeTCKoro 'ITO Te COlO3a e BorrpOCbI 06eCrre'leHHH 6e30rraCHOCTH H oc06eHHO DeHHHrpa J a KOTopble CTOHJIH 3HHcTBeHHbIMH COrJIaIIIeHHHMH TOBapo060poT C rrpH6aJITHHCKHMH B rreperOBopax C 3CTOHHeH CTOHT H B rreperOBopax C DHHJIHH HeH CTpaHaMH YBeJIHlJHBaeTCH B HeCKOJIbKO pa3 H HMeeT 6JIarOrrpHHT­ MO l l o CKa3aTb 'ITO B HeKOTopoM OTHOIIIeHHH BorrpOCbI 6e30rrac­ HYIO rrepCrreKTHBY HOCTH JIH COBeTcKoro COlO3a 3 ecb CTOHT J a e oCTpee rrOCKOJIbKY J IH J aJIbHeHIIIero poCTa B YCJIOBHHX Kor J a TOprOBJIH Bcex eBporreHCKHX CTpaH B TOM lJHCJIe H HeHTparrbHbIX rJIaBHbIH rrOCJIe MOCKBbI ropo ' COBeTCKoro rocy apcTBa - rocy apCTB rrepe HBaeT rpOMa J Hble 3aTpY J HeHHH 3TH 3KOHOMH­ HHHrpa '1eCKHe corrraIIIeHHH CCCP C 3CTOHHeH DaTBHeH H DHTBOH HMelOT HH 3TO 3HalJHT 'ITO DeHHHrpa HaXO HTCH OT rpaHHII bI pyroro JIH HHX BeCbMa KpyrrHoe rrOJIO lfTeJIbHOe 3Ha'leHHe TaKHM 06pa30M C6JIH eHHe HaXO J HTCH Bcero B 32 rOCY J apCTBa Ha paCCTOHHHH MeHbIIIeM '1eM 3TO HY l l O J JIH apTHJI­ rrpOHCIIIe J IIIee Me J y CCCP JIepHHCKoro 06CTpeJIa H3 COBpeMeHHbIX J aJIbH060HHbIX opyJ Hif 3 cToHHeH DaTBHeH H DHTBOH 6y eT co eHcTBOBaTb 60JIee 6bICT­ C POMY 3Ha'lHTeJIbHOH Mepe 3aBHCHT OT Toro - rropTa rrO beMY H CeJIbCKOrO Bo06Il e X03HHcTBa HapO J HOMY rrpOMbIIIIJIeHHOCTH 6JIarOCOCToHHHIO HaIIIHX TpaHc­ rr pH 6arr­ THHCKHX coce 'eH npHHu HIIbI C OC060H pyroH CTOpOHbI MopCKHe rrO 'CTyrrbI K DeHHHrpa y TaK e B BeHHYIO rr03HII H1O B OTHOIIIeHHH Bpa 'e6HYIO HJIH 'py eCT­ COBeTCKoro COlO3a 3aHHMaeT DHHJIHH J HH KOTOPOH rrpHHa J JIe lfT BCH ceBepHaH '1aCTb rr06epe bH COBeTCKOH rrOJIHTHKH B CHJIOH rrpo eMoHcTpHpoBaHbI rrepe a'le DHTOBCKOH 06JIaCTH npH 310M DHTOBCKoe pecrry6JIHKe OTHOIIIeHHH MaJIbIX CTpaH Ha rrpHMepe oroBopa 0 ropo J a BHJIbHO rocy apCTBO H BHJIeHCKOH C ero HaCeJIeHHeM B Ba C rrOJIOBHHOH MHJIJIHOHa '1eJIOBeK 3Ha'lHTeJIbHO pacurnpHeT 292 De­ KHJIOMeTpax OT rpaHHII bI DHHJIHH­ DHHcKoro 3aJIHBa H Bce OCTpOBa B OJIb II eHTparrbHOH '1aCTH DHH­ cKoro 3aJIHBa C'IHTaHCb C TaKHM rrOJIO eHHeM a TaK e C C03 aBIIIeHCH B EBporre 06CTaHOBKOH MO l l O paCC'IHTbIBaTb 'ITO CO CTOpOHbI DHH­ JIHH J HH 6y 'eT rrpoHBJIeHO OJI I I oe rrOHHMaHHe 293 Ha 'IeM OCHOBbIBaJIHCb OTHOIIIeHIDI COBeTCKOrO COlO3a C l HH­ JIHH lUIeH 3a BCe 3TH rO lJ bI 113BecTHo 'ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHOIIIeHHH HBJIHeTCH MHpHblH lJ OrOBOp C lJ pyrHMH CBOHM HaIIIHMH 1920 rO lJ a rro THIlY uaIIIHX lJ OrOBOpoB 6aJITHHCKHMH COCe J HMH COBeTcKHH COlO3 CB060 J HbIM BOJIeH3'bHBJIeHHeM 06ecrre'IHJI caMocTOHTeJIb­ BblMbIceJI H JIO l b uPyrHe YTBep l J aIOT 'ITO rrepe lJ a'IH eMY ArraH lJ CKHX OCTpoBOB 3TO - CCCP Tpe6yeT TaKOH l e BbIMbIceJI H JIO l b EOJITalOT ell e 0 KaKHX-TO rrpeTeH3HHx HK06b1 cYll eCTBY­ 1Oll HX Y COBeTcKoro COlO3a B OTHOIIIeHHH mBeUHH H Ho JTO HopBerHH 6ecrrap lJ OHHOe BpaHbe rrpOCTO He 3aCJIY l HBaeT orrpOBep­ 06 l4uu Hoe H He3aBHCHMoe CYll eCTBOBaHHe l HlUIHH lUIH He MO l eT 6bITb l eHbH COMHeHIDI rrpH3HalOll ee rreperoBopax C l HHJIHH J HeH HBJIHIOTCH MaKCHMaJIbHO CKPOMHblMH pa3BHTIDI HaUHOHaJIbHOCTeH Morno rrOHTH H OrpaHH'lHBalOTCH TeM MHHHMYMOM 6e3 KOToporo HeB03MO I H0 rrpHHlum 'ITO TOJIbKO CB060 J Horo COBeTCKoe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO cMex Ha caMOM lJ eJIe HaIIIH rrpe lJ JIO l eHIDI B Ha 3TOT IIIar HY l HO CKa3aTb 'ITO HUKaKoe npa6UTeJlbCT60 6 Poc­ 06eCrre'IHTb 6e30rraCHOCTb CCCP H HaJIa lUlTb APY I eCKHe OTHOIIIeHIDI CUU KpoMe C06eTCK020 rrO lJ 'IepKHYTO pe lJ He MO l eT lJ OrrYCTHTb C l HHJIHH lUIeH CYll eCTBOBaHHe He3aBHCHMOH l HIUIHH J HH Y caMbIX BOPOT ileHHH­ MbI Ha'IaJIH rreperoBopbI C rrpe lJ CTaBHTeJIHMH l HlUIHH J HH lJ JIH rpa J a 06 nOM KpaCHOpe'IHBO rOBopHT OrrbIT C lJ eMOKpaTH'leC­ 'Iero KHM rrpaBHTeJIbCTBOM rr IIaacHKHBH H TaHHepa C rrpe lJ JIO l eHIDIMH 3aKJIIO'lHTb COBeTCKO- o KepeHCKoro-UepeTeJIH He rOBopH Y I e rrpaBHTeJIbCTBe KHH3H ilbBOBa-MHJIIOKOBa H TeM 6oJIee 0 uap­ l HHJIHH lJ CKoe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO KOMaH lUIpoBaJIO B MOCKBY 4 HHCKHH rraKT B3aHMorrOMOll H rrpHMepHo rro THrry HaIIIHX rraKTOB CKOM rrpaBHTeJIbCTBe HeT COMHeHIDI 3TO Ba I HOe 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO B3aHMorrOMOll H Morno IIoCKOJIbKY O J HaKO l HlUIHH lJ CKOe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO 3aHBHJIO HaM 6bI crrY l HTb xopoIIIeH rrpe J IIOCbIDKOH lJ JIH YJIY'lIIIeHIDI COBeTcKo-4 HHCKHX OTHOIIIeHHH B KOTOPbIX KaK BH J HO l HHmlH­ 'ITO J HH He MeHbIIIe 3aHHTepeCOBaHa 'IeM COBeTCKHH COI03 rr03HUHH COBeTcKo-4 HHcKHe rreperOBopbI HaqanHCb He J aBHO rro uaIIIeH HHHUHaTHBe qTO HBJIHeTCH rrpe lJ MeTOM 3THX rreperoBopoB 3aKJIIO'IeHHe C lJ pyrHMH TaKoro a6COJIIOTHOrO rrpH6aJITHHCKHMH rraKTa rrpoTHBOpe'IHJIO HeHTpaJIHTeTa MbI He rOCY lJ apCTBaMH 6bI 3aHHTOH HM CTaJIH HaCTaHBaTb Ha HaIIIeM rrpe lJ JIO l eHHH MbI rrpe lJ JIO l HJIH Tor J a rrepeHTH K KOH­ He KpeTHbIM BorrpocaM B KOTOPbIX MbI 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI C TO'lKH 3pe­ TpY J HO rrOHHTb 'ITO B COBpeMeHHOH Me l J yHapO J HOH 06CTaHOBKe HIDI 06ecrre'leHIDI 6e30rraCHOCTH CCCP H B oc06eHHOCTH 6e30rraCHO­ Kor J a B lIeHTpe EBporrbI pa3BepTbIBaeTCH BOHHa Me l J y KpyrrHeH­ CTH ileHHHrpa lJ a KaK CO CTOPOHbI MOpH - IIIHMH rOCY J apCTBaMH 'IpeBaTaH 60JIbIIIHMH HeO I H J aHHOCTHMH H CO orraCHOCTHMH J JIH Bcex eBporreHCKHX rOCY lJ apcTB - 30HbI K ileHHHrpa lJ Y MbI rrpe lJ JIO I HJIH lJ OrOBopHTbCH 0 TOM 'IT06bI COBeTCKHH CTOPOHbI COlO3 He TOJIbKO HMeeT rrpaBO HO H 06H3aH rrpHHHMaTb cepbe3HbIe OTO lJ BHHYTb MepbI lJ JIH YKperrrreHIDI CBoeH 6e30rraCHOCTH IIpH 3TOM eCTeCTBeH­ KHJIOMeTpOB HO 'ITO COBeTCKoe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO rrpOHBJIHeT oc06yIO 3a60ry Ha TeppHTOpHH rrOM K ileHHHrpa lJ y a TaK I e OTHOCHTeJIbHO TOH cyxorrYTHOH rpa­ TeppHTopHIO KOTopaH ileHHHrpa lJ OM H B KaKHX-HH6Y lJ b 30 KHJIOMeTpax HaBHCJIa ceBep OT B l HHCKOM 3aJIHBe TaK H 'Ipe3MepHOH ileHHHrpa lJ a COBeTCKo-4 HHCKYIO 6JIH30CTH Ha rrOrpaHH'lHOH HeCKOJIbKO lJ eCHTKOB rpaHHlIY Ha KapeJIbCKOM rrepe­ COBeTCKOH KapeJIHH rrepe J aBaeMYIO rrpeBbIIIIalOll YIO l HHJIHH lUIeH B J Ba COBeTCKOMY pa3a COI03Y Ha lJ MbI rrpe lJ JIO l HJIH TaK I e lJ OrOBopHTbCH 0 TOM 'IT06bI l HlUIHH J HH HarrOMHIO 'ITO HaCeJIeHHe ileHHHrpa lJ a lJ OCTHfJIO c J aJIa HaM B apeH J y Ha orrpe lJ eJIeHHbIH CpOK He60JIbIIIOii Y'IaCTOK Tpex C rrOJIOBHHOH MHJIJIHOHOB 'ITO rrO'lTH paBHo HaCeJIeHHIO BceH l HHJIHH lUIH BBH lJ y IIIeHKe B3aMeH 3Toro MbI rrpe lJ JIO I HJIH rrepe J aTb l HlUIHH J HH 'laCTb oTHOCHTeJIbHO l HHcKoro 3aJIHBa HBJIHIOll erOCH MOpCKHM rrO lJ CTY­ HHlIbI CYIIIH HaC'lHThIBalOll eH 3 MHJIJIHOHa 650 TbICH'I l HTeJIeH BeceJloe OJICU6J1eHUe 6 3aJle CBoeH TeppHTopHH B paiiOHe BXO J a B l HHCKHH 3aJIHB lJ a6b1 MbI MOrJIH TaM opraHH30BaTb BoeHHO-MOPCKYIO COBeTCKOH BoeHHO-MOPCKOH E J Ba JIH eCTb OCHOBaHIDI OCTaHaBJIHBaTbCH Ha Tex He6bIJIHuax 3aJIHB a HMeHHO B 6a3bI Y 6a3Y IIpH HaJIH'IHH IO I HOrO BXO lJ a B l HHCKHH EaJITHHCKOM rropTY KaK 3TO 06ycrroBJIeHO KOTopbIe pacrrpoCTpaHHIOTCH 3arpaHH'lHOH rrpeCCOH 0 rrpe lJ JIO l eHIDIX COBeTCKO-3CTOHCKHM COBeTCKoro COlO3a B rreperOBopax C l HlUIHH J HeH O J HH YTBep l ­ MOPCKOH 6a3bI Y ceBepHoro BXO lJ a B l HHCKHH 3aJIHB Morno 6b1 J aIOT 'ITO CCCP Tpe6yeT ce6e 'laCTb 294 r BHIlYPH Bbl60pr H ceBepuylO ila J O l CKOrO 03epa CKa l eM OT ce6H 'ITO 3TO - 'lHCTbIH rrOJIHOCTblO rraKTOM B3aHMorrOMOll H C03 lJ aHHe BoeHHO­ 06eCrre'IHTb Bpa l lJ e6HbIX 6e30rraCHOCTb rrOKYIIIeHHH co CTOPOHbI l HHcKoro lJ PyrHx 3aJIHBa rrpOTHB rOCY J apCTB MbI 295 He COMHeBaeMCH B TOM 'ITO C03Al1Hlfe TaKOH 6a3bI COOTBeTcTByeT lfHTepecaM caMOH He TonbKO COBeTCKoro C0103a HO 6e30rraCHOCTlf If l RHnHH um upyrlfe HaIilli rrpe J lO eHlfH If B '1aCTHOCTlf Hawe rrpe J lO eHlfe 06 06MeHe TepplfToplflf HeKoTopbIX OCTPOBOB B l lfHCKOM 3anlfBe a TaK e '1aCTlf rronyocTpoBOB PbI6a'llfH If Cpep ­ HRH Ha ABOHHYIO rro pa3MepaM TepplfToplfIO B COBeTcKoH Kap en lflf rrO-BlfAlfMOMY He BCTpe'l3IOT B03p3 eHRH CO CTOPOHbI l lfHnHHP CKO­ ro rrpaBlfTenbCTBa Pa3HornaClfH B OTHoweHlflf HeKOTopbIX HawlfX rrpe J lO eHRH eme He rrpeop oneHbI a cp enaHHble B 3TOM OTHoweHlflf l lfHnHHAlfeH yCTyrrKlf HarrplfMep '1aCTlf'IHaH YCTyrrKa TepplfTOplflf Ha KapenbCKOM rrepeweHKe HBHO He p OCTlfraIOT IIenlf MbI CKa3anlf 'ITO ecnlf 6y J yT rrplfHHTbI Hawlf OCHOBHble rrpe J lO­ eHlfH MbI roTOBbI CHHTb HaIilli B03pa eHlfH rrpOTlfB Boopy eHlfH AnaHp cKRX OCTPOBOB rrpaBlfTenbCTBO Ha '1eM y e AlIBHO MbI OrOBOpRnlf TonbKO B03pa eHlfH rrpOTlfB HaCTalfBaeT l lfHcKoe 'ITO MbI CHlfMaeM CBOlf Boopy eHlfH AnaHp cKlfX OCTpOBOB rrplf YC­ nOBlflf 'ITO YKa3aHHble Boopy eHlfH 6y J yT rrpOlf3BOP lfTbCH HaI lfO­ HanbHbIMlf CRnaMlf caMOH l lfHnHHAlflf If 'ITO B 3TlfX Boopy eHlfHX TpeTblf CTpaHbI He 6y J yT rrplfHlfMaTb HlfKaKoro Y'laCTlfH rrOCKonbKY If CCCP He Y'lacTByeT B HlfX MbI rrpe J lO lfnlf TaK e l lfHnHH Ufl rrpOBecm Ha rrepeweHKe BceH COBeTCKo-cplfHCKOH pa30py eHlfe rpaHlfIIe YKperrneHHbIX Ha paHOHOB KapenbCKOM 'ITO p on HO IIenlfKOM COOTBeTCTBOBaTb lfHTepecaM l lfHnHHAlflf MbI Bblpa3lfnlf enaHlfe YClfnlfTb COBeTCKo-cplfHCKlfH rraKT HeHarrap eHlfH p orronHlfTenbHbIMlf B3alfMHbIMlf rapaHTlfHMlf HaKOHeII yrrpo'leHlfe rrOnlfTlf'leCKlfX COBeTCKo-cplfHCKlfX OTHOWeHRH HeCOMHeHHO HBlf­ nOCb 6bI rrpeKpaCHOH 6a30H If J lH 6bICTporo rrop beMa X03HHCTBeH­ HbIX OTHoweHlfH Me J y HaWlfMlf CTpaHaMlf TaKlfM 06pa30M MbI rOTOBbI lfP Tlf HaBcTpeqy l lfHnHHP lflf B Tex CPbIBY rrpeAIIOnaraeMoro cornawe­ HlfH 3TO He COOTBeTCTBOBano 6bI rronlfTlfKe p py eCTBeHHbIX COBeT­ CKO-CPlfHCKlfX OTHOWeHRH If KOHe'IHO HaHecno 6bI cepbe3HbIH ymep 6 l lfHnH HAlflf MbI 6yp eT CKlfX 296 YBepeHbI rrpaBlfnbHo rrpocbI 'ITO PYKOBOAHmlfMlf rrOHHTO p py eCTBeHHblx 3Ha'leHlfe OTHOWeHlfH If cornaCOBaTb HeHTpanlfTeTa B CBoeM rrocnaHlflf C rronlfTlfKoH 12 Bblpa3lfn Hap e J y B 3Tlf BO­ aMeplfKaHCKOrO OKTH6pH Ha lfMH T KanlfHlf­ r Ha IIpep cep aTenH IIpe3lfAlfYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa Py3BenbT Ha COXpaHeHlfe If pa3BlfTlfe p py enI06Hblx If MlfpHbIX OTHOWeHRH Me J y CCCP If l lfHnHHAlfeH MO HO rro J y­ MaTb 'ITO y COeAlfHeHHblX lIlTaTOB AMeplfKlf ny'lwe 06CTOHT p ena OT CIIIA CB060 J bI If He3aBlfClfMOCTlf If y He MoryT lfX rronY'llfTb '1eM COBeTCKoro COI03a C l RHnHHAlfeH KOTOpaH p aBHO y e rrony­ '1Rna OT COBeTCKoro COI03a If cBo60p y If rocyp apcTBeHHYIO He3a­ BlfClfMOCTb Ha rrocnaHlfe r Py3BenbTa T KanlfHlfH OTBeTlfn cne J yIOmlfM 06pa30M C'IlfTaIO 'ITO YMeCTHbIM rOCYAllpCTBeHHaH 6bIna rrplf3HaHa HarrOMHlfTb BaM rocrrop lfH rrpe3lf J eHT He3aBlfClfMOCTb l lfHnHHP CKOH pecrry6nlfKlf CBo60AHbIM Bonelf3bHBneHlfeM COBeTCKoro IIpa­ 31 BlfTenbCTBa p eKa6pH 1917 rop a If 'ITO cYBepeHlfTeT l lfHnHH­ Alflf 06eCrre'leH 3a HeIO MlfpHblM p oroBopoM Me J y PC l CP If l lfH­ 14 nHHAlfeH OT CKoro OKTH6pH IIpaBlfTenbcTBa B3alfMooTHOWeHRH 1920 rop a YKa3aHHblMlf aKTaMlf COBeT­ orrpep eneHbI Me J y 6bInlf COBeTcKlfM OCHOBHble COI030M If rrplfHlIlfrrbI l lfHnHHAlfeH B COOTBeTCTBlflf C 3TlfMlf rrplfHIIlfIIaMlf Bep YTcH If HbIHeWHlfe rrepe­ rOBopbI Me J y COBeTcKlfM IIpaBlfTenbcTBoM If IIpaBlfTenbcTBoM l lfHnHHAlflf Mlfpe BorrpeKlf TeHp eHIIlf03HbIM BepclfHM pacrrpocTpaHHe­ ep lfHCTBeHHOH nHHAlfeH If CTpaH p ene B IIenbIO YKa3aHHbIX rreperOBopOB HBnHeTCH l lfHnHHp cKlfMlf KpyraMlf YKperrneHlfH cOBeTcKo-cplfH­ l lfHnHHP CKlfe p eHTenlf He YKperrneHlfe p py eCTBeHHoro 06eCrre'leHlfH COTpYAHlf'leCTBa 06eRX 6e30rracHOCTlf COBeTCKoro COI03a If l lfHnHHAlflf IIocne TaKoro HCHoro OTBeTa IIpep ceAliTenH IIpe3lfARYMa Bep­ xOBHoro 'ITO TPYAHO yrrpO'leHlfe B3alfMOOTHOWeHRHMe J y COBeTCKlfM COI030M If l lfH­ IIocne Bcero 3Toro MbI He J yMaeM '1T06bI CO CTOPOHbI l lfHnHH­ K p On eH OAHaKO C006I1 lfTb 'ITO AlI e rrpe3lfp eHT COeARHeH­ MbIM KpyraMlf O'leBlfAHO He 3alfHTepeCOBaHHbIMlf B eBporreHCKOM Borrpocax B KOTOPbIX OHa OC06eHHO 3alfHTepeCOBaHa P lflf CTanlf lfCKaTb rrOBOAli R HbIX IIITaToB AMeplfKlf Hawen YMecTHbIM BMeWaTbCH CKa eM C l RnlfIIrrlfHaMlf Rnlf C Ky60H KOTOpble AlIBHO Tpe6yIOT MbI cp enanlf p anee pHP HOBbIX warOB HaBCTpe'lY l lfHnHHp lflf p anee rrOMa J yTCH KaKoMY-nlf60 aHTlfcoBeTCKoMY p aBneHlfIO If rrop cTpe­ KaTenbcTBY co CTOPOHbI Koro 6bI TO Hlf 6bInO COBeTa CCCP p On HO 6b1Tb COBepweHHO rrOHHTHO 'ITO rrplf Hanlf'llflf P 06POH Bonlf l lfHnHHp CKOe rrpaBlfTemCTBO rrOHp eT HaBcTpeqy TonbKO HawlfM MlfHlfManbHbIM rrpe J lO eHlfHM KOTopble He He rrpoTlfBOpe'laT Hal lfOHanbHbIM lfHTepecaM l lfHnHH lflf HO If YKperrnHIOT ee HbIHeWHIOIO 6e30rraCHOCTb If C03p aIOT IillipOKyIO 6a3y J lH p anbHeHwero wlfpOKoro pa3BlfTlfH rrOnlfTlf'leCKlfX If X03HHCTBeHHbIX OTHoweHlfH Me J y HawlfMlf CTpaHaMlf 297