CU IF IUtNllAL WU u INCO MIUG Depart111ent of' tate PAGE 01 USNATO 10256 092125Z ACTION tUR-12 6962 IIIFO OCT-01 IS0-00 CIA -00 Pll-05 H-01 IUR-10 L-03 NSAE·CO NSC-05 PA-01 SP-02 SS-15 ICA- 11 ACDA-12 TRSE-80 HA-OS AI0-05 OES-09 1 06 II --- -------------- -890190 09 2323Z 21 P B91 649Z NOV 78 FIi USIIISSIO USIIATO TO S CSlAT IIASHOC PRIORI TY 532 1 SECDEF IIASHDC PRIORITY JCS 1 ASHOC PRIORITY All IIATO CAPl lALS CON F I O £NT AL USIIATO 10256 £ 0 11652 XGOS -1 TAGS NATO PARII SUBJECT IIATO EXPERTS ME ET IIIG ON HUMANITARI AN INTERNATIOIIAL LAIi IN ARMED COIIFL ICT NOVEMBER 8 REFS Al STATE 147385 Bl USNATO 9906 IC UStlATO 10067 SUMIIARY NATO LEGAL POLI TICAL EXPERT MEETING 8 NOVEIIBER COtlSI DEREO NATIONAL POSITIONS OU AL LIED INTERPRETATIOIIS or PROTOCOL I USIUG UK TE XT REHR NC C AND FRG PAPER IREF B AS BAS IS FOR DI SCUSS ION CONS£HSUS APPEARS TO 8£ FORMltlG AS TO BOTH FORM ANO SUBSTAUC or ltlT RPR TATIV STATEnEUTS OH HINIHUM ESSENTIAL STATEMEUT TO GIVE EFFECT TO ltlTERPRETATIOIIS FOUIID TO BE IIECESSARY IN MILITARY COMMITTEE STUDY US REP REITERATED THAT IT INTEtlOS TO MAKE THE DECL ARATIOtlS OUTLIUEO Ill REFEREIICE A THERE IS 110 CHAIIGE IN OECI SIOII or FRANCE NOT TO SIGH OR RATIFY PROTOCOLS mo SUIIMARY USNATO 10256 092125Z TELEGRAM DECL ARATIOII 01l ARTICLE H l 1111T IIIG or STAIIOARDS or DISTIIICTION BY GUERRILLAS TO OCCUPIED TERRITORY AIIO STRUGGl t S roR m r -DETERlllt ATIOU AS 1 Hl AS OEFIIIITIDII or • DEPL DYMEIIT 4 UK rDRMULATIOII FOR XPL AIIATORY STATEMENT OF IIILITARY AOVAIITAGE ANTICIPATED rROM ATTACK AIID EL ABORATIOtl or OEFltllTIOtl OF MILIT ARY OBJECTIVE AS INCLUDIIIG AREA OF LANO I ERE GENERALL Y ACCEP TED US HOll VER IIIOICAIED THAT 11 DOES IIOT COtlSIDER IIECESSARY FORMAL 0£CLARATIOII ON THI S SUBJECT S 111TH RESPE CT TD 1 ARS OF IIATIOIIAL LIBERATION THE UK ABANDOIIEO ITS EFFORT TO ASS IMILATE AR TICLE 1 PARA 4 TO LEVEL OF INTEIISI TY PRESCRIBED Ill PROTOCOL II OIILY BELGI UMAIIO UK SPOKE Ill FAVOR or COUOITIOIIIIIG RECOGN IT 1011 or l IBE RATI011 HOVEMEIHS 011 RECOGII IT I011 BY REGIOIIAL IIITER·GOV RIIMENTAL ORGANIZATION 6 HO DATE I AS SET FOR FUTURE MEET IIIC BUT IT I AS AGREED THAT NATO POLITICAL COMIIITTEE I Ill CONT INUE TO MONITOR PROGRESS BEING MADE TOI ARD PARLIAMENTARY SUBMISSION Of PROTOCOL S AtlD SERVE AS A CLE AR ING HOUSE FOR EXCHAIIGE or IIIFORMATIOtl GLITMAN 1 FRG REP ANIIOUIICEO THAT FRG HAS APPRO EO NUCLEAR DECLARATION Ill FORMPROPOSED BY UK IN RE F C THAT THE RULES RELATING TO THE USE OF IIEAPONS ESTABLISHED BY THIS PROTOCOL HAVE BEEU DESIGNED 111TH A VIEi TO COUVEIHIOIIAL IIEAPONS ANO IIERE IIOT IIHEIIDEO TO HAVE AIIY EFFECT 011 AND 00 NOT RE GULATE OR P OHI BIT THE USE OF NUCLEAR 1 EAPOtlS THE US BELGI UM ANO IIETHERL AUOS INDICATED THAT THIS STATEMENT IS ACCEPTABLE AS A NATIOIIAL OECLARATIOtl 111TH SOME NDU· SUBSTAIITIVE MOOIFI· TIOUS CANADA IS COtlSIOERIIIG A LOIIGER REHREIICE TO THE NEGOTIATI IIG RECORD PERTAINIIIG TO TH£ RULES GOVERNIIIG TH£ COIIOUCT OF MILITARY OPERATIOUS AUD COUCLUOING 111TH LANGUAGE SIMILAR TO THE UK·FRG TE XT CAUAOIAN PURPOSE IS TO DISCOURAGE ltlOUI RY AS TO OIFFEREtlCE BETIIEEN OLD RULES APPL ICABLE TO USE OF IIUCLEAR IIEAPOIIS AND IIEII RUL ES ESTABL ISHEO BY PROTOCOL 1 HICH ARE IIOT IT I AS GHIERALLY AGREEO TH AT VAR IATIONS Ill THE TfXT ER£ NOT HARMFUL PROVIDED THE OPERATIVE TE XT CLEARLY STAT ES THAT THE RULES 00 NOT REGULATEOR PROHIBIT TH US£ or NUCLEAR E APONS 2 US UK FRG BELGIUMAIIO CANADA URGED ALL NONNUCL EAR STATES 1 HI CH POS SSED NUCLE AR DELIVERY MEAIIS AND THOSE rRDII HOSE TERRITORY IUCL£AR IIEAPONS MAY BE L UIICHED TO HAVE AN APPROPRIATE DECLARATIOII ITALY HAS HOT YET MADE A OECISIO'I HORIIAY AIIO DElll1ARK I HILE AGREEING 111TH THE SUBSTAIIC OF TH£ IIUCL EAR UNDER· STANDIIIG COtlTltlUEO TO SEARCH FOR 1 AYS TO AVOID MAKIIIG A FORMAL DECLARATION ON THE SUBJECT 3 UK PROPOSAL 011 DEF INITIOII OF FEASI BL£ RH Cl I AS rouNo TO BE SATISFAC TORY BUT us NETH RL AltOS ANO NORIIAY INTEliD TD INCLUDE IT IN EXPLANATORY MATER IALS TO LECISLATUR t 1 ITHOUT HAVING A FORMAL DECLARATIOtl tHER£ I AS 1110£ 4CCEPTl ICE Of UK FORMUL AT ION FOR DECLASSIFIED CONFIDENTIAL Authority b N f