Page 1 of 3 Message Kew Brian Contractor From Kozloff Keith Sent Friday September 17 2004 3 10 PM To 'DiZoglio Kerri A' Cc Allen Linda J Hurley John Subject RE Camisea demarche Kerri I don't have a formal read out Basically the NGOs expressed continuing concern about the project and follow on hydrocarbon development They also expressed frustration in their interactions with IDB on Camisea and were hoping to enlist USG support for their proposals for an independent audit of the project and an independent monitor A S Quarles reminded them that the US vote on the project had upset the GoP and reduced our leverage relative to if we had voted for it Still he thought that the current finance minister might be more open to discussing such proposals than the minister's predecessors I offered to meet with NGOs if they wanted to flesh out these proposals The NGOs also discussed the IOB's proposed environment policy with A S Quarles who assured them that Treasury was following it closely Keith Dr Keith Kozloff Senior Environmental Advisor Office of International Development Policy U S Treasury Department 1440 New York Avenue NW Room 3407 Washington DC 20220 ph 202-622-7719 fax 202-622-0218 email Keith Kozloff@do treas gov -----Original Message----From DiZoglio Kerri A mailto DiZoglioKA@state gov Sent Friday September 17 2004 2 54 PM To 'Keith Kozloff@do treas gov' Cc Allen Linda J John Hurley E-mail Subject RE Camisea demarche Hi Keith Would you happen to have a read-out of the meetings with the NGOs Larson was copied on the recent letter from the NGOs to Taylor and I'm sure would be interested in your response Thanks Kerri -----Original Message----From Keith Kozloff@do treas gov mailto Keith Kozloff@do treas gov Sent Friday September 17 2004 8 56 AM To AllenLJ@state gov johngarrison1@aol com LJohnston@usaid gov DiZoglioKA@state gov MattinglyAC@state gov PapazianES@state gov Cc jogarrison@usaid gov CMango@usaid gov GumbinerLJ@state gov MatuszakJM@state gov Subject RE Camisea demarche Linda et al 4 22 2008 Message Page 2 of3 I have proposed just a few edits to the cable I have also attached two documents recently transmitted to IDB as follow ups to meetings with them In Camisea closure actions1 Annex Bis most relevant to bilateral communication with the GoP as it lists actions that we had deemed incomplete under the Loe Also note the suggestion that USG send observers to the next meeting among IDB sponsors GoP and Peruvian civil society organizations A S Quarles met with a US NGOs yesterday and left the door open for possible USG support for an independent audit and or independent monitor but we would need to get further information on what is being proposed for these mechanisms first So getting a read-out from the next Lima meeting would be helpful Regards Keith Dr Keith Kozloff Senior Environmental Advisor Office of International Development Policy U S Treasury Department 1440 New York Avenue NW Room 3407 Washington DC 20220 ph 202-622-7719 fax 202-622-0218 email Keith Kozloff@do treas gov -----Original Message----From Allen Linda J mailto AllenLJ@state gov Sent Wednesday September 15 2004 6 35 PM To johngarrison1@aol com Johnston Leslie PPC RRB 3 08-062 Keith Kozloff@do treas gov DiZoglio Kerri A Mattingly Amanda C Papazian Elaine S OES Cc Garrison John LAC RSD RRB 5 09-057 Mango Cecily LAC RSD RRB 5 09-052 Gumbiner Lawrence J Matuszak John M OES Subject RE Camisea demarche Importance High Hi everyone - I am circulating the Camisea cable for final clearance please review and provide comments by OOB Friday Sept 17 OES and USAID EB and WHA do not feel it is appropriate or necessary to attach the ED's letter the cable can stand on its own if you have questions regarding this please give Kerri a call John Matuszak - I am sending this to Elaine but her email was not working earlier today please ensure that she gets it Regards Linda -----Original Message----From Johnston Leslie PPC RRB 3 08-062 Sent Tuesday August 17 2004 5 51 PM • To Allen Linda J Cc Garrison John LAC RSD RRB 5 09-057 Mango Cecily LAC RSD RRB 5 09052 Subject Camisea demarche Linda - Please find attached comments from USAID on the demarche Both EGAT 4 22 2008 Message Page 3 of3 and LAC would like to see final demarche before clearance Also we think it is important to attach the Treasury letter sent to IDB with its annexes since this is the basis for the demarche talking points Thanks -Leslie 4 22 2008